Now They Want to Drag Us, Kicking and Screaming

11 replies [Last post]
PaulMarsh's picture
User offline. Last seen 3 years 1 week ago. Offline
Joined: 26-09-03

Leader of the House of Commons, Geoff Hoon is arguing that going to the polls in British elections should become compulsory.

Has there ever been a clearer admission of failure by a domestic politician?

Hoon: make people go to polls

Evening Standard 4 July 2005

Going to the polls should be made compulsory in General Elections, the Leader of the Commons Geoff Hoon is to argue.

He will use a speech to the left-of-centre Institute for Public Policy Research to say that the change is needed to reinvigorate Britain's democracy. He is the most senior Government minister to endorse compulsory voting.

According to press reports, Mr Hoon will say that the 61% turnout in May's General Election - only a fraction up from the all-time low in 1997 - left him "more concerned about our democracy than ever before".

But he is not expected to say that voting should be made compulsory, instead he will suggest that attending a polling station or registering for a postal vote should be sufficient.

"It is vital that there should be an option available to abstain or spoil your ballot paper," he is expected to say.

A spokesman for Mr Hoon said his speech would aim to start a debate on "ideas to improve voter engagement".

PaulMarsh's picture
User offline. Last seen 3 years 1 week ago. Offline
Joined: 26-09-03

The article on PA about this is even funnier:

MAKE PEOPLE VOTE SAYS HOON

By Gavin Cordon, PA Whitehall Editor

Leader of the Commons Geoff Hoon issued a call today for the

introduction of compulsory voting at general elections to reverse the

sharp decline in voter turnout.

Mr Hoon warned that ``serial non-voters'' - particularly among

younger people and in the more deprived areas - could threaten the

long-term legitimacy of the political system.

While he acknowledged that new voting methods - such as electronic

voting - could help to boost turnout, international experience had

shown that the most effective way was to make voting compulsory.

In a speech to the Institute for Public Policy Research, Mr Hoon

said that the turnout at the last general election of 61.5% was way

below the 75% plus which had been the norm for most of the post war

period.

With voting rates highest among older voters, he said that the

situation was likely to get worse as the years progressed unless

action was taken to stem the decline.

``My fear is that as the older, more regular voters die, we will be

left with a significant number of people for whom voting is neither a

habit, nor a duty,'' he said.

``Now we are seeing, not just twenty somethings, but people in

their thirties and forties who have never voted and who actually seem

proud to say so. This is something that greatly concerns me.

``This deliberate non-voting seems to be spreading up through our

voting population, threatening the long term legitimacy of our

political system.''

Mr Hoon blamed a sense of ``alienation'' from the political system

among people who felt that voting made no difference, a trend that

would be exacerbated as the parties increasingly tailored their

policies to people they knew would vote.

``My fear is that as time goes on, as all political parties become

more sophisticated at targeting actual voters, we could fail to pay

attention to serial non-voters,'' he said.

``This will alter our democratic debate, risking encouraging a

greater focus on issues of concern to the chattering classes,

neglecting issues of wider and more general concern. It is profoundly

dangerous for our political life.''

In contrast, he said that in countries such as Australia where

voting was compulsory, turnout could exceed 90%.

``To me, and this is entirely my personal perspective, a higher

turnout, will generate more political participation across all

strands of society,'' he said.

``A higher turnout is vital if we are to ensure a representative,

healthy and vibrant democracy in our country.

``International experience points to compulsory voting being the

most effective way to increase turnout.''

Mr Hoon said that he did not believe that large penalties would be

necessary to enforce compulsory voting.

He suggested that people could even be offered an incentive to

comply in the form a a small reduction in their council tax bill.

He stressed that people would still have the right to abstain or to

spoil their ballot papers.

Downing Street said that Mr Hoon's comments were intended to start

a debate on the issue and did not herald a change in policy.

``I think Geoff Hoon is really starting a debate. This is his

personal view. It is not signalling that the Government is about to

introduce a change,'' a spokeswoman said.

end

Steven.'s picture
User is online Online
Joined: 27-06-06

Anyone know what anarchists do in countries where it's compulsory? Like New Zealand no?

Lazy Riser's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 33 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 6-05-05

Hi

I vote tactically to keep a Tory out.

Out of 10, how would you score that action?

01 = Bad

05 = Neutral

10 = Good

I give it a 6.

Cheers

Chris

User offline. Last seen 5 hours 14 min ago. Offline
Joined: 30-10-03
John. wrote:
Anyone know what anarchists do in countries where it's compulsory? Like New Zealand no?

No, you're thinking of Australia.

Anyway, I know people there who just don't register to vote in the first place, and have never had any hassles.

Lazy Riser's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 33 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 6-05-05

Hi

I heard a rumour that they get a "none of the above" candidate? Is it true, or myth?

Love and Peace etc

Chris

BB
User offline. Last seen 8 weeks 5 days ago. Offline
Joined: 12-08-04
Garner wrote:
John. wrote:
Anyone know what anarchists do in countries where it's compulsory? Like New Zealand no?

No, you're thinking of Australia.

Anyway, I know people there who just don't register to vote in the first place, and have never had any hassles.

WTF do they do, the state that is, come round an round you up...? Can you get time for it?

User offline. Last seen 5 hours 14 min ago. Offline
Joined: 30-10-03

I think they give out fairly hefty fines. But of course if you're not registered in the first place, they don't know you're supposed to have voted... The whole system seems pretty stupid really.

Dunno about the 'none of the above' thing.

User offline. Last seen 39 years 48 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 5-07-05
John. wrote:
Anyone know what anarchists do in countries where it's compulsory? Like New Zealand no?

You can get fined for it if you don't vote (whoah, a whole $50). But I'm not giving the government my hard earned cash for that...

We usually donkey-vote. ie. , vote for the fishing party, or the beer party, or something so totally ridiculous it won't get in.

Or write snarky but intelligent comments next to the major party options.

cinders x

Lazy Riser's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 33 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 6-05-05

Hi Cinders

Thanks for the information. I hope you enjoy Exeter, by the way.

I took the liberty of e-mailing the editor of Australia's Green Left Weekly www.greenleft.org.au , who kindly replied as follows...

Quote:
Hi

We're having a bit of a chat about democracy on http://www.libcom.org/forums/viewtopic.php?t=5749.

Would you let us know if Australians get a "None of the above" candidate on their election ballots?

In solidarity

Chris

Quote:
Nope, you can vote informal, but there is no option on the ballot

So that's that cleared up.

Peace and Love

Chris

User offline. Last seen 39 years 48 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 5-07-05

Hmmmm...Green Left Weekly.

I have some big issues with them.

They tend to have major issues sorting out facts before printing them sometimes.....

but that's a whole different story.

cinders x

Lazy Riser's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 33 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 6-05-05

Hi

I probably share your angle on GLW. I'm a bit of a tart.

Love

Chris

The jammy filling