Anyone seen Porto Marghera – The Last Firebrands?

12 replies
Joined: 21 Apr 06
User offline. Last seen 3 hours 27 min ago.

I was poking about in aut-op-sy list archives and found references to this Italian documentary distributed by German Wildcat! last year with English sub-titles. It sounds fascinating.

Quote:
A film about petrochemical workers who took matters into their own hands in the giant industrial zone engulfing Venice. The mass refusal of literally toxic work forced hours on the job down at the same time as driving wages up. The labour hierarchy that sets white collar against blue, permanent against casual, was attacked by workers insisting on the maximum for everyone. The battle in the factory was linked to working-class life outside through direct appropriation of basic social needs (electricity, housing, food).

More clearly than any before them, the Porto Marghera workers identified the factory as the trigger of fatal diseases and destroyer of life. They remained on the offensive against the concerted hostility of unions, multinational employers and state from the late 1960s until well into the '70s. As part of an international wave of struggle, their actions contributed to a global accumulation crisis, provoking the capitalist counter-attack which has never ceased since then.

Unlike most more or less academic accounts of Italian Operaismo, which tend to focus on high-profile groups and individual leaders, Porto Marghera – gli ultimi fuochi (Manuela Pellarin, Italy, 2004) documents autonomous worker organization from the point of view of the worker-activists themselves, who talk about their experiences in the film. Many aspects and problems of this phase of class struggle are of immediate relevance today. For example:

* The Porto Marghera workers fought for better conditions within their work and at the same time against the damaging impact the chemical industry and of work itself. They defended their health-damaging jobs, yet did so from a deeply critical perspective, at a time when a middle-class moralizing green movement did not exist.
* They developed independent organizational forms within the existing struggles of the time. This meant reassessing the relationships between:
o the workers' mobilizations and their own role as active workers
o the factory and the wider social terrain
o workers' struggles, new forms of union representation and 'professional' political groups like Potere Operaio
o mass movement, armed insurrectionist groups and state repression.

Joined: 19 Jun 07
User offline. Last seen 48 min 54 sec ago.

I have a copy of this. It is interesting but not amazing. There are interviews with contemporary NGO/union activists that are pretty uninteresting, but the historical interviews and film clips are cool. The film poses one example of what a 'proletarian response' to ecological destruction has looked like.

Joined: 29 Sep 06
User offline. Last seen 8 hours 2 min ago.

I also do and I agree that it's not super interesting. As a matter of fact, I saw certain contradictions in the whole thing; it is presented as an example of rank and file action, then throughout the movie you see crowds from the big mainstream unions present everywhere. It becomes obvious that somehow they got in there, but the viewer has no idea of what happened.

Joined: 25 Jul 08
User offline. Last seen 6 hours 34 sec ago.

I've also seen the movie. As the others already said, the parts about the contemporary NGO-led struggle are not too interesting, but the historical parts about Potere Operaio in Porto Marghera are.

Wildcat released this movie on a DVD, with an extra interview with one of the struggling workers, AND a great booklet about the struggles in the industrial zones in Porto Marghera. The booklet is most definitely worth checking out, I think there's some pretty rare stuff -- interviews, leaflets etc. I personally found it fascinating about a year ago.

It was released in German originally, but I'm sure there's an English version (somewhere), as the booklet was translated into several languages (I was part of the translating project).

Joined: 27 Jul 06
User offline. Last seen 1 hour 22 min ago.

The Wildcat DVD was only available to subscribers. Those of us who buy Wildcat in bookstores just got the booklet and cover.

Is there a torrent of the film somewhere?

Joined: 29 Sep 06
User offline. Last seen 8 hours 2 min ago.

I'll ask alterkino to put it up but it might take them a few days.

MT
Joined: 29 Mar 07
User offline. Last seen 1 day 12 hours ago.

Info-@-Police collective did a screening of it in Bratislava last year. It was fine but from a big part thanks to almost an hour long introduction by the collective member, so you first should perhaps read the booklet. The authors were not "workerist activists" (as far as I know) so perhaps this explains why people expect more from the document than it really contains and why Wildcat prepared the booklet.

Joined: 27 Sep 06
User offline. Last seen 2 weeks 3 days ago.
Angelus Novus wrote:
The Wildcat DVD was only available to subscribers. Those of us who buy Wildcat in bookstores just got the booklet and cover.

Take a look at www.syndikat-a.de and fill the search form with "porto"...

Joined: 27 Jul 07
User offline. Last seen 2 hours 23 min ago.

I agree with most of the above posts. I think the booklet is an excellent, although brief, overview of the history of class struggle in Italy especially from the 1960s through the 1970s. There simply isn't enough in English about that period, with the exception of Steve Wright's book. And the interview in the same vein is quite good too. But some of the more contemporary ones, as mentioned above, are pretty boring.

Joined: 19 Jun 07
User offline. Last seen 48 min 54 sec ago.
Angelus Novus wrote:
The Wildcat DVD was only available to subscribers. Those of us who buy Wildcat in bookstores just got the booklet and cover.

Is there a torrent of the film somewhere?

They sent me a copy, and I am not a subscriber.

Joined: 27 Jul 06
User offline. Last seen 1 hour 22 min ago.
yoshomon wrote:
They sent me a copy, and I am not a subscriber.

Presumably because you got it directly from Wildcat. All the bookstore copies just had the booklet and cover (this was actually noted in the editorial of the issue it came with).

robot: 7 euro? yikes. I'm not wealthy, man.

Joined: 21 Apr 06
User offline. Last seen 3 hours 27 min ago.

Hey, could one of you comrades who have a copy seed it on onebigtorrent or piratesbay and leave a link?

Joined: 22 Jul 07
User offline. Last seen 4 days 16 hours ago.

We saw it as part of a study circle based on steve wright's book "storming heaven". It was interesting, but not amazing as yoshomon said. Already knowing something about the background would probaby be useful for most people.

I will see what I can do to get the DVD onto onebigtorrent