Arson Fire at Detention Center in Vincennes, France

9 posts / 0 new
Last post
varlet
Offline
Joined: 9-04-08
Jun 24 2008 13:57
Arson Fire at Detention Center in Vincennes, France

A fire has been reported, Sunday, June 22nd, in the Detention Center in Vincennes (Val-de-Marne), where foreigners without papers face expulsion, according to police sources and defense associations for foreigners. The incident was reported in the afternoon and has destroyed two buildings at the center, the most important in France. The 280 detainees were able to be evacuated in time, but many people have been injured, mostly from asphyxiation. Some of those held benefited from the confusion created by the evacuation by fleeing. Sunday night, the prefecture of police was indicating that 50 of them were missing.

According to some foreigners actually held in Vincennes, the fire is linked to a riot which escalated in the middle of the afternoon. It would be notably linked to the heart attack death of a Tunisian without papers, Saturday, at the detention center. This story seems corroborated by the prefecture of police, who mentioned a "voluntary" fire and the "simultaneous setting of fires in the two buildings of the center".

TENSION

The death of this 41 year old Tunisian has provoked, according to the association RESF, strong emotions among detainees at the center, while the police are assuring that the victim did not suffer from any violence. A report has been opened, but the autopsy on Sunday has not, according to the prefecture, revealed anything abnormal.

A collective of foreigners without papers had called for a protest in front of the building on Sunday afternoon. It is not known if this protest is related to the fire. The detention centers are overcrowded and the tension there will be higher and higher, according to the organizations in defense of foreigners, which are pointing to the "cruel, brutal, and inhumane politics" led by the government.

See : http://news.infoshop.org/article.php?story=20080622211907743
http://www.indymedia.ie/article/88099

little_brother's picture
little_brother
Offline
Joined: 30-01-06
Jun 27 2008 10:09

The whole system of detention needs to be brought down somehow. The number of detention centres/camps/prison in Europe (and on the borders of Europe or in source countries funded by EU like Libya) is huge: http://www.migreurop.org/rubrique45.html?lang=en (this site has a set of maps showing camps - the French language one is the most up to date).

Currently the british government is in the process of building more detention (also called 'removal') centres and expanding others. Resistance by persons inside is continuous and there have been many incidents involving fire (like at Vincennes) and even some escapes. There are a good number of campaigns supporting detainees -getting them out of centres and stopping deportation flights- and to close the centres, like the Close Campsfield Campaign. No Borders groups are involved with these initiatives.

Note that EU is currently in process of 'harmonising' its asylum policy. This could well mean unwelcome migrants being moved around between member states to faciliate their concentration by country of origin, and then put them on chartered deportation flights. Anarchists/libertarians who have international links can hopefully create a more coordinated approach or at least gain an idea of the scale of the problem and what the differences are in different countries. Certainly the AF had some useful dicussions at the Balkans anarchist bookfair recently. For example in Greece the camps are very different than in Britain.

Mark.
Offline
Joined: 11-02-07
Jun 27 2008 10:35
little_brother wrote:
Note that EU is currently in process of 'harmonising' its asylum policy. This could well mean unwelcome migrants being moved around between member states to faciliate their concentration by country of origin, and then put them on chartered deportation flights.

There's been a vote by the European Parliament on this - with approval for internment of migrants for up to 18 months and a five year ban on re-entering the EU. There are reports in Spanish here but I haven't seen anything in English about it.

little_brother's picture
little_brother
Offline
Joined: 30-01-06
Jun 28 2008 22:50

Yes. Thanks for the link. The vote you are referring to was on the 'returns directive' and there is a website against it (vote was European Parliament on 17th or 18th June 2008 but I haven't checked the outcome): http://www.outrageousdirective.org/

UK probably opt(ed) out anyway as 'we' already detain for longer 18 month (for example some Zimbawbeans have been detained for nearly two years and are still trying to get bail, see: http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2008/jun/24/immigrationpolicy.zimbabwe ) and UK is also looking at imposing a 10 year ban in some instances (see: http://www.ncadc.org.uk/Newszine95/HC321.html for info ).

Mark.
Offline
Joined: 11-02-07
Jun 29 2008 09:59

I've just looked through the reports in Spanish again - the directive was passed but the UK has an opt out.

little_brother's picture
little_brother
Offline
Joined: 30-01-06
Jun 30 2008 15:06

OK - or didn't 'opt-in' apparently. There seems to be action against detention and deportation going on everywhere - see recent reports from belgium and denmark for example: http://www.nobordersnottingham.org.uk/index.php?newsid=126

See also: Shut Down EU Migrant Hunters! - Actions against Frontex
http://www.ainfos.ca/en/ainfos20985.html'

piter
Offline
Joined: 30-06-08
Jul 2 2008 15:48

what seem to have started the riot is that it to took 2 hours for the centre to call the doctors after the heart attack ot the tunisian people, that added to the hopeless situation of the peoples in the centre, bad treatment from the cops in the centre, etc...
the goverment party (UMP) tried to put the blame on RESF (the association that fight against the expulsions) and threaten to ressort to repression against the anti expulsion movement.

little_brother's picture
little_brother
Offline
Joined: 30-01-06
Jul 3 2008 07:00

Rioting following one individuals treatment is taking place regularly in these prisons.
Blaming the anti-deportation campaign is a good one - maybe this shows we are having an effect. In Britain some escapees from Campsfield have managed to stay free. But it seems like the war is on, within and without the borders of Fortress Europe. Sarkozy is to campaign against naturalisation of san-papiers in Europe as part of France's EU Presidency. In Italy things are truly disturbing with a new government proposal to fingerprint all Roma adults and children. No borders and anti-ID card action needs to be stepped up I'd say, to increase confidence and reduce isolation of those under attack.

varlet
Offline
Joined: 9-04-08
Jul 3 2008 14:05

Basically the guy died in the centre but management didnt want to say so for fear people would get angry and a 'riot' would take place. So they kept saying the guy was fine, or alive, until some ambulance came to pick him up. But at that point everyone knew they were lying and he was probably dead.

Now the thing nobodys saying is that this Tunisian guy was not suffering from heart problems. He was however ill (some mental illness), and people at the centre were refusing to give him his medication or any other treatment.
The day before the fire, he was reported shaking, trembling and feeling unwell.
On the day of the fire, he went to rest in a room cos he was feeling ill. He never woke up.

Such seem to be the 'natural causes' of his 'heart attack'.

A witness account, in French :
http://quotidiensanspapiers.free.fr/w/spip.php?article1310

The report below (in French too) makes clear that there's been a history of humiliations, resistance, repression and struggles at least since late 2007 in the centre :
http://contre.propagande.org/pravda/modules/news/article.php?storyid=214

Now of course, its much easier to blame support groups like RESF than to face the reality and admit it.
Just a way to direct the attention onto something else than their own responsibility.
Dont think governments are ready to say : yeah we put non-EU people there against their will because we decide so, the conditions are worse than in prison, and actually we're happy to let them die in there. So what?