starting up a class struggle newsletter--looking for tips, ideas, etc.

20 replies [Last post]
smg
User offline. Last seen 10 hours 10 min ago. Offline
Joined: 20-06-09

Some comrades and myself from a defunct anti-poverty organization are thinking about working together once again to put out a newsletter covering events in Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada; the newsletter would cover local events from a class struggle perspective. I am hoping that the newsletter can be a tool for linking up with other folks in struggle rather than another subculture affirming waste of time . How would folks here go about doing this? Any tips? Any advice?

prec@riat's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 week 1 day ago. Offline
Joined: 3-10-07

Write about your personal experiences in your workplace(s).
Incorporate graphics and good graphic design.
A humorous "advice columnist" column can be a plus.

I'm a little confused as to what you want the newletter to be... are the "other folks in struggle" you want to link up with in Halifax? in a specific workplace? all of Canada? all of North America/ the world? ...such considerations would change the scope of the newsletter imho.

User is online Online
Joined: 24-09-05

Hi Smg, I'd be interested to know what led to HCAP (http://www.hfxcap.ca/) collapsing. I know it's a bit off topic, so maybe you'd like to post your experiences here instead...

http://libcom.org/forums/organise/direct-action-casework-groups-04032009

Joseph Kay's picture
User offline. Last seen 12 hours 22 min ago. Offline
Joined: 14-03-06

one of the best local newsletters i've seen in the UK is the Hereford Heckler, a good mix of news, humour and local sport with a good clean design. basically have a look at other ones and see what they do that works (e.g. the news in briefs on the front of the Heckler helps draw in readers imho). One of the biggest and easiest mistakes to make is to use jargon that's obscure to your readers, which can lead to a subcultural readership without realising it. for example the last SolFed Catalyst had a headline reading 'Sweep ISS out of SOAS' - i know what that means and it's still obscure; handing it out at the local train station elicited a lot of baffled looks (i think it was a holding headline that got left in by mistake).

Farce's picture
User offline. Last seen 10 hours 33 min ago. Offline
Joined: 21-04-09

I can't guarantee there'll be anything useful you can learn from it, but there's also the Fargate Speaker, which at least aims to be a tool for linking up with other folks in struggle rather than another subculture affirming waste of time.

Jack's picture
User offline. Last seen 7 hours 25 min ago. Offline
Joined: 22-09-03
Joseph Kay wrote:
for example the last SolFed Catalyst had a headline reading 'Sweep ISS out of SOAS' - i know what that means and it's still obscure; handing it out at the local train station elicited a lot of baffled looks (i think it was a holding headline that got left in by mistake).

unfortunately this time it was the correct one. embarrassed

smg
User offline. Last seen 10 hours 10 min ago. Offline
Joined: 20-06-09

Prec@riat, I'm mainly interested in connecting with other individuals in Halifax--particularly folks who do not fall into the activist or anarchist subculture--who work low paying shitty or collect assistance and are generally pissed off about it and want to fight back.

Thanks for the links folks I'll check them out!

Posi I'll try to comment on the slow demise of HCAP later today in the other forum.

Steven.'s picture
User offline. Last seen 1 hour 23 min ago. Offline
Joined: 27-06-06

There are some practical tips in the media section of our organise Page:
http://libcom.org/organise

One thing that I would comment is that if you are doing a local newsletter, especially if you are writing new content for it, that you put it online as well so it can get out to a wider audience, and people can come across it via Google searches, etc - libcom is available to use as online archive for this purpose, so feel free to post stuff here!

Joined: 11-03-08

Perhaps you could write about how Simon has been accusing me of abusing women because I was critical of the anti-rape vigilantes from Guelph. You know me and my girlfriend, and hopefully you realize I'd never lay a hand on her. I know Simon is likely hated by ex-hcap but still it ties into....

How Halifax insurrectionary anarchists and anarchist black cross members threatened to call the cops on me, sabotaged the home of an ex-anarchist and accused him of rape (not alex, but you likely know who I mean) and threatened several people who were critical of the Guelph anarchists.

How about how the anarchists didn't allow the non-political folks to take part in house meetings, and how they were abusive towards them. How about how your house allowed people from Guelph to stay there after they had threatened me. My girlfriend convinced the other members of her house (I know you weren't there) that the Guelph kids were no longer welcome becuase they threatened me. That claire was no longer welcome because she lied about me and created the potentially violent situation. Then the house turned on my girlfriend and retracted the decision.

And of course I threatened these people with violence, they were threatening to gang up on me 15 on 1, and when I didn't budge they threatened to call the cops on me.

I know most of them have moved away now to live in the beautiful communes of Guelph, and I'm sure you don't want to hear this. But to suggest that you can't think of anything to write about? I know you're one of the few good kids in this city and I don't want to piss you off, I can take this elsewhere. But I think it would be really disrespectful to me and c if this situation was avoided in anarchist texts. This was the most important event that's event (essentially it was an implosion of three events)

Joined: 11-03-08

Ever happened to Halifax anarchists and it was a total failure. There is nothing in Halifax for revolutionaries unless they address how shitty anarchists treated each other, other revolutionaries and non-politicals. You know that not everyone is against me, and that it's no accident that the most well read as well as the nonpoliticals either took my side or have distanced themselves from the anarchists.

I won't keep bringing this up if you don't want to talk about it, I understand why. But these were your friends and ignoring it doesn't make the problem go away.

(sorry for the two posts, I tried to correct something but am typing on a phone and can't scroll down)

Joseph Kay's picture
User offline. Last seen 12 hours 22 min ago. Offline
Joined: 14-03-06
deadstareforlife wrote:
I think it would be really disrespectful to me and c if this situation was avoided in anarchist texts. This was the most important event that's event (essentially it was an implosion of three events)

tbh, the last thing any class struggle newsletter needs to do is perpetuate personal feuds (justified or not) between anarchists. that's about the most inward-looking, self-important subcultural irrelevance possible.

there may well be things that need to be discussed (although from what you say it sounds like a bunch of subcultural twats acted like subcultural twats and then fucked off), but a newsletter isn't the place.

Joined: 11-03-08

Maybe so, but I think class struggle is irrelevent if it's taken up by folks who can't get along in groups of more than ten folks. These were people involved in the atlantica black bloc, so I can imagine that any class struggle group in Halifax will be composed of folks who think accusing people of rape is a part of class struggle, or it will be their friends. People who are friends with snitches and liars have no place in class struggle. The people that did this were the class warriors in Halifax, and it occurred during two of there events. Are you saying that how revolutionaries treat other people is irrelevent if they publish a solid classwar rag? I don't know who else is involved but I wouldn't consider anyone involved with hcap, apart from smg, to have any understanding of class struggle from an anarchist or communist point of view. There is also a history of people treating others like shit in Halifax, and I'm assuming that this publication will involve at least one or two of these people. Class struggle is irrelevent when it's composed of people who treat each other worse than everyday people treat each other. If people can't tolerate minor personal crises then what's the point of trying to go beyond that? The united states is full of people in struggle who snitch when faced with jail time. In Halifax we have insurrectionary anarchists who threaten to snitch on people over personal squabbles. Why should they go any further? You're right Joseph, this should be discussed, but it has not been discussed and moving forward with a zine like this would indicate that people just don't care. You're not from here so maybe you don't realize that all the shit that has happened is more important than class struggle headlines. If anarchists could learn one thing from all this it should be that your personal relationships come before anarchist struggle, otherwise all that organizing is for nothing. You can't create a better society with a bunch of people who treat each other like shit.

Joseph Kay's picture
User offline. Last seen 12 hours 22 min ago. Offline
Joined: 14-03-06
deadstareforlife wrote:
Maybe so, but I think class struggle is irrelevent if it's taken up by folks who can't get along in groups of more than ten folks. These were people involved in the atlantica black bloc, so I can imagine that any class struggle group in Halifax will be composed of folks who think accusing people of rape is a part of class struggle, or it will be their friends.

tbh i don't think black blocs have much to do with class struggle, it's usually an opportunity for anarcho-kids to dress up like ninjas substitute street violence for class militancy (and yes, i've done it myself wink ).

these kind of intra-group dynamics are fairly typical of 'radical' subcultures in my experience, typified by informal hierarchies and cliques and the aversion to formal organsiation this usually results in.

deadstareforlife wrote:
You're right Joseph, this should be discussed, but it has not been discussed and moving forward with a zine like this would indicate that people just don't care. You're not from here so maybe you don't realize that all the shit that has happened is more important than class struggle headlines. If anarchists could learn one thing from all this it should be that your personal relationships come before anarchist struggle, otherwise all that organizing is for nothing. You can't create a better society with a bunch of people who treat each other like shit.

i don't pretend to know the specifics of Halifax, but Brighton's certainly not short of anarchist subculturals and their cliquey bullshit.

this project doesn't sound like a 'zine' of the kind you find in the 'the anarchist scene', but a newsletter aimed at people who aren't radical posturing fuckwits. tbh, insurrectionist subculturals are irrelevant, the best way to deal with them is to ignore them and orient your politics towards your workmates, neighbours etc. maybe write a critique of the scene in the hope of warning some kids off making the same mistake, but other than that just chalk it up as experience and leave the muppets to it.

prec@riat's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 week 1 day ago. Offline
Joined: 3-10-07

People do like to read opinion and opinionated reporting, I'm assuming that most of the articles will be local analysis and reportage of local struggles. Keeping it first person makes it more interesting imho...
In other words, avoid stuff like 3rd person reporting which sounds like- Janitors organized! Victory for working class and Union Local Blah Blah Blah... vs a first person account from a rank-and-file janitor describing their involvement in an organizing drive would be more interesting imho
*edit* also, I'd assume, winning 'union recognition' would be the least interesting aspect of such a hypothetical story, the story of the conditions people worked under and how people fight against that and win demands (of which winning formal union representation may or may not be particularly significant) in their particular context would be most interesting.

Joined: 11-03-08

Good response Joseph, I'd agree for the most part. To my knowledge I don't think there are groups capable of what you're suggesting here in Halifax. They're either all tied up with the insurrectionists, have abandoned that in favour of more general activism, or they're older communist associated with labour unions. There's no one else.

Joseph Kay's picture
User offline. Last seen 12 hours 22 min ago. Offline
Joined: 14-03-06

gotta start somewhere! you'd be surprised how many people are drawn to a decent class struggle anarchist presence once it's there - quite a few, probably half of our current members in Brighton said that they'd wanted to be involved in stuff but there wasn't a decent group. so better to be a small group going in the right direction than a larger irrelevant, dead-end one.

Steven.'s picture
User offline. Last seen 1 hour 23 min ago. Offline
Joined: 27-06-06

Could people now please keep the discussion on topic - i.e. tips and ideas for starting a class struggle newsletter, not a side discussion about some stuff that happened in Halifax please, thank you.

smg
User offline. Last seen 10 hours 10 min ago. Offline
Joined: 20-06-09

It looks like professors at community colleges around the province might strike soon. I'm hoping this might provide an opportunity to link up with folks and distro some sort of propaganda/newsletter. I know with previous attempts I have relied heavily on anarcho-speak. I have also been told my pieces have been too long. Any tips on writing to an audience of non-politicos about the political?

Joined: 9-08-07

I think relevant stories and advice and info are the best bet, and you definitely need funny eye-catching headlines.

The best newsletter I have ever been involved in is this: http://www.haringey.org.uk/content/images/hsg/newsletters/newsletter15.pdf

It's only fault I would say is that for me it's politics are a little too broad, it can have too many green issues, and some moralistic liberal stuff, but that's generally a tiny minority of content, and is due to the groups' broad membership.

The best headline it ever carried was for a very short article; 'Disposable Heroes of Hypocrisy' about the local council sending out a glossy mag about recycling and the environment in a plastic bag embarrassed wink

Joined: 22-10-09
smg wrote:
Prec@riat, I'm mainly interested in connecting with other individuals in Halifax--particularly folks who do not fall into the activist or anarchist subculture--who work low paying shitty or collect assistance and are generally pissed off about it and want to fight back.

Thanks for the links folks I'll check them out!

Posi I'll try to comment on the slow demise of HCAP later today in the other forum.

Why not have a section called something to the effect of "Interview With A Working Class Hero" in which you have a sit down interview with a regular working guy. You could highlight the personal struggles of people in your community who aren't necessarily anarchists or activists and at the same time you could ask them direct questions about anarchism so that you could also gain some perspective on what issues need to be more clearly addressed in terms of helping the working class better understand what anarchism is really all about and why it would be a preferable option for them. What do you think?

Joined: 22-10-09
Joseph Kay wrote:
this project doesn't sound like a 'zine' of the kind you find in the 'the anarchist scene', but a newsletter aimed at people who aren't radical posturing fuckwits. tbh, insurrectionist subculturals are irrelevant, the best way to deal with them is to ignore them and orient your politics towards your workmates, neighbours etc. maybe write a critique of the scene in the hope of warning some kids off making the same mistake, but other than that just chalk it up as experience and leave the muppets to it.

Exactly, you have to consider the audience. To go in to great detail about the disputes between various cliques would not only be pointless, it would be counter productive. The aim is to present to a new audience the positive things that anarchism can bring about, highlight the injustices of wage slavery and help to bring about change. To get into the sectarianism within anarchism would only be confusing and off putting.