Refusing to work?
Born out of the argument I've just had, and my relative inability to give a decent response, what justification can be had for refusing to work (in my case, just going on the dole until I find work) whilst not needing cash for a roof over my head or food to eat other than you're entitled to it?
Hope you're not suffering from anarchist-class guilt, this might help: Manifesto Against Labour
yeah, what Rob says makes sense, but my main incentive for refusing to work would be simply the fact that all the jobs I've had so far were absolute shit.
the more people hold out for a better deal before taking a job,
I don't think most people who have families to support can afford to do this though; that's why it will never really be successful as a strategy for putting serious pressure on capital.
yeah, what Rob says makes sense, but my main incentive for refusing to work would be simply the fact that all the jobs I've had so far were absolute shit.Rob wrote:
the more people hold out for a better deal before taking a job,I don't think most people who have families to support can afford to do this though; that's why it will never really be successful as a strategy for putting serious pressure on capital.
Oh, but then the solution is simple: avoid having a family to support to begin with.
assuming you're not just taking the piss ToJ, in the vast majority of cases throughout the world supporting a family doesn't just mean supporting kids and a spouse, it means supporting the people who conceived you as well as your siblings, which is pretty unavoidable.
And why should I or anyone else want to avoid having a family in the hopes that it might make it more difficult for companies to use job competition to undercut wages? Fuck that.
In fairness I was being a bit facetious there, it's one of those arguments which sounds good in an argument with randoms but doesn't entirely scan when thought about - eg. it might also imply that people who are made desperate enough to take a job for fuck all are effectively acting as scabs undercutting the working wage, rather than people making the entirely understandable decision to y'know, live.
I was looking for more concrete ideas, like why it's not sponging off people's tax money as suggested to me.
Cause work is well rubbish.
I was looking for more concrete ideas, like why it's not sponging off people's tax money as suggested to me.
Cos "the people" have no control over how "our tax money" is spent, it's scrounging off the state, which wastes far vaster sums on far more pointless destructive shit. If you had a guarantee that not signing on would mean that someone's tax money would be spent on something useful instead, then that'd be one thing, but it's just as likely to be spent on...well, on any of the bollocks the state spends money on, take your pick.
Steven, I've used that reason for several years now. I don't think it holds strong anymore.
I did mention the fact tax is spent this way and that way, but often on shite.
because work only creates more work and considering the fact we are facing an ecological crisis, it's about time we said fuck off to it!
You are not only furthering the demands of the proletariat, you are sucking captain planets balls too.
You're pretty much a legend.
p.s. it also means you aren't as likely to become a raging bigot when sitting across from a black person or woman in an interview waiting room.
Also it gives you more time for activisms. Maybe a zine?
screw them for all you can get. the govt,bosses, shareholders do it all the time.
the only difference is that they are lauded for it and you are vilified.
as long as you are genuinely striving for a fair and equitable world i see no problem.
you could also give some if not all of the money to cash starved political/protest groups of your choice.
the system paying for it's own downfall.....
now there's a happy thought
"If the unemployed are dole bludgers, what the fuck are the idle rich?"
On a serious note, I think a combination of the following arguments:
- it is taxpayers money, but not very much, certainly nothing compared to the scrounging of the idle rich, or the tax avoidance of the wealthy. And a lot of taxpayers money gets spent on stuff which is bad - handing it over to the rich by subsidising privatisation, building weapons of mass destruction, killing people in Iraq and Afghanistan...
- by refusing to work at current wage levels you help prevent general wage levels from falling, by helping to increase demand for labour
if I had a third argument I have now forgotten what it was. Hopefully this will do though.
The refusal to work is a major economic strut in the fight for a higher wage - the more people hold out for a better deal before taking a job, the more difficult it is for companies to use job competition to undercut wages.In fact it's actually a tremendous self-sacrifice to be living with such reduced means as a mechanism to improve the working power of others, I salute your indefatigability
.
A good argument but Labourist.
What if you're not holding out for higher wages and just don't want any job.
Locke's Social Contract is in exchange for recognising the right to private property ownership, those who own the property are obliged to support those who don't. (Who would presumably rather than starve to death stop recognising private property laws if they weren't supported).
Born out of the argument I've just had, and my relative inability to give a decent response, what justification can be had for refusing to work (in my case, just going on the dole until I find work) whilst not needing cash for a roof over my head or food to eat other than you're entitled to it?
We're in a recession, don;t really see why you need an argument right now. Loads of pretty career minded people i know are probably facing the dole, theres easily gonna be 4 million plus unemployed by the end of the year i'd reckon..
I defnitely wouldn;t try and politically justify it in terms of ''refusing to work'' with most people, coz its the equivalent of telling a starving man that your on a diet. Just tell people you can;t get a decent job, if they push further, lie and/or exaggerate about some applications and interviews you had.
Personally like most people I find being on the dole long term way worse than working. So i don;t really see refusal to work as much of an option, but i guess its a matter of personal preference.
work is shit. that's reason enough to refuse it if you can afford to. it's not really a collective strategy through without serious levels of organisation; the CNT in Spain in the 30s had a union of unemployed workers that would do things like demand a 'sitting wage', where laid-off workers would sit at factory gates for a whole shift then queue up to get paid, they also organised mass restaurant visits where they demanded to be fed, regardless of ability to pay. even then it was more a reaction to mass unemployment than a 'strategy of refusal.'
P.S. revol, keep that bollocks to the thread in question, or start a serious one in thought
A good argument but Labourist.
I pointed out later on in the same thread that it was flawed, but used a different example - what if you choose to work for peanuts because of particularly strong pressures? Doesn't that make you a destroyer of wage standards?
And as JoeK points out, it's not really a strategy as such, just an economic effect when lots of people do it.
If you just don't want a job, you're still having that effect on the market regardless. It's the fact that you're withholding labour power that's important, not that you have a blindingly good understanding of how supply and demand functions. And if everyone did it, we'd have a defacto general strike
.
I was getting a bollocking for my wanting to go on the dole just to tide me over, rather than refusing to work.
But someone who has a missus and kids, yet refuses to work was mentioned, and I did find it very difficult to argue his case.
Dear lots of zeros,
I was on the dole for years, and I used to have occasional massive fits of guilt about being a parasite on society, other people had to work to support me etc etc. Of course, I felt those things because other people (esp my grandparents) said them to me all the time.
Don´t listen to any of this crap! Most jobs I ever had contributed absolutely nothing to the wellbeing of anybody. I worked in a shop selling shampoo and makeup- well god, we´d all be done for if I wasn´t there to sell you a rose blusher for six pounds fifty on a Sunday afternoon eh? I worked in a lot of bars, well alcoholism never hurt anyone. And at least I was paying my taxes. So it´s not as if there are the working people, digging potatoes and cleaning hospitals and discovering penicilin, and the unemployed people lazing around. Most jobs are completely meaningless and you waste your life putting the shampoo bottles on the shelf with the labels facing the front. So sign on. Get lots of sun. Sign on double if you can.
I was getting a bollocking for my wanting to go on the dole just to tide me over, rather than refusing to work.But someone who has a missus and kids, yet refuses to work was mentioned, and I did find it very difficult to argue his case.
I'm sure I'll get called a humourless AF male feminist for this, but...can't he just do housework and rely on his missus to bring home a wage for the household?
he however is likely to a be a fat deadbeat loser who doesn't do any housework and prefers to mooch off his spouse's hard earned money to buy beer and sports memorabilia. I have a female friend who is precisely in this situation.
I agree with Fingers' post, and there is no sense in pretending that there is anything noble or even useful about most work done under capitalism, but some people really are lazy scumbags; that is not entirely a bourgeois myth.
Born out of the argument I've just had, and my relative inability to give a decent response, what justification can be had for refusing to work
This;
Age
10 - 19
Farce, I thought we had to be those to even join the AF in the first place?
Ironically, his missus doesn't work much either yet she was free from criticism. But he is pretty lazy in truth, not even working while his lady was, 7 months pregnant.
Farce, I thought we had to be those to even join the AF in the first place?Ironically, his missus doesn't work much either yet she was free from criticism. But he is pretty lazy in truth, not even working while his lady was, 7 months pregnant.
who is Karl Marx?
lol
Dear lots of zeros,
I was on the dole for years, and I used to have occasional massive fits of guilt about being a parasite on society, other people had to work to support me etc etc. Of course, I felt those things because other people (esp my grandparents) said them to me all the time.
Don´t listen to any of this crap! Most jobs I ever had contributed absolutely nothing to the wellbeing of anybody. I worked in a shop selling shampoo and makeup- well god, we´d all be done for if I wasn´t there to sell you a rose blusher for six pounds fifty on a Sunday afternoon eh? I worked in a lot of bars, well alcoholism never hurt anyone. And at least I was paying my taxes. So it´s not as if there are the working people, digging potatoes and cleaning hospitals and discovering penicilin, and the unemployed people lazing around. Most jobs are completely meaningless and you waste your life putting the shampoo bottles on the shelf with the labels facing the front. So sign on. Get lots of sun. Sign on double if you can.
yeah and this, the propaganda of 'working people' as opposed to the 'working class' is to promote a class collaborationist notion that all active working people (managers included) are contributing to society rather than working to expand capital.
As for a strategy of refusal to work, well I think it has become increasingly relevant in the west over the last 30 years and is increasingly so considering the ecological issues we are facing and the increasingly explicit futility of most jobs as primary and secondary sector jobs have went abroad.
Didn't Karl also knock up the family maid while not working?
Didn't Karl also knock up the family maid while not working?
yep and got Engels to take the blame.
Karl Marx was basically Frank Gallagher from Shameless but from bourgeois stock.














The refusal to work is a major economic strut in the fight for a higher wage - the more people hold out for a better deal before taking a job, the more difficult it is for companies to use job competition to undercut wages.
In fact it's actually a tremendous self-sacrifice to be living with such reduced means as a mechanism to improve the working power of others, I salute your indefatigability
.