Hunting banned! Class war, coming soon, to a town near you..
Big news, a strategy of tension in the run up to the election, the right going all out to stop themselves being routed at the polls by Blair... Foxhunters have already tried to pull down an electricity pylon in Cumbria, have threatened to poison Birminghams water supply, and are likely to be on the streets in large numbers... along with the BNP who support them and who turned up to the Countryside Alliances London demos... AND, in the news just when the top foxhunter, Prince Charles, is getting a hammering...
Don't you just love it?
im sorry but who really cares about fox hunting? its hardly of pressing concern is it? not exactly an issue likely to set the working class alight?? seems to be a nice wee distraction thrown to the left in order to take their minds of more important concerns such as Pfi, cutting/rationalisation of public services and the various wars around the globe.
really its perfect we can pretend its a class issue because a load of toffs head it up, that way we fail to notice that the real ruling class are cutting wages and labour rights all over the shop whilst we chase after some fucking aristo's who are hardly the fucking vanguard of capital!
im sorry but who really cares about fox hunting?
Me.
Anyways its something that its possible to imagine ending very soon. Then everyone can forget about it and move on to other issues. Its an achievable goal.
yes but u put class in quotations
and really but if u think about it the amount of fucking fucked up stufff in the world and the governement decideds fox hunting is a a real worry?? seems slightly strange to me, i mean the fact that all these mp's can be so unwavering on an issue like fox hunting but when it comes to voting on a war or tution fees they all collapse like the spineless careerist scum they are!
Possibly because tuition fees makes them money whereas foxhuntinf costs money to police?
Anyway I think it is important. Foxes are being sadistically tortured and butchered. That can be stopped. It seems pretty simple to me.
lots of things appear simple to those with simple minds.
Ouch
The clear tactic should be to Citizens Arrest the hunters on February 18th - remember ' reasonable force allowed'! Blair's cock-up gives us a top opportunity to bring class warfare to the streets again in the run up to the general election. Only this time we can arrest the fuckers! Prizes for most arrests. Toodle Pip.
Foxes are being sadistically tortured and butchered. That can be stopped. It seems pretty simple to me. :)
True...BUT (and it's a big butt
) most hunts are niothing more than a day out for the toffs. It's rare for them to actually catch anything, isn't it?
3rdseason wrote:
Foxes are being sadistically tortured and butchered. That can be stopped. It seems pretty simple to me. :)
True...BUT (and it's a big butt
) most hunts are niothing more than a day out for the toffs. It's rare for them to actually catch anything, isn't it?
exactly - how many foxes are killed by hunting? A few score, a few hundred?
And if you're an animal liberationist how does that even compare to the tens of millions killed for food?
And as for meat-eaters who get all sanctimonious about hunting, I think it's hypocrisy to, er, a really big degree.
im sorry but who really cares about fox hunting? its hardly of pressing concern is it? not exactly an issue likely to set the working class alight?? seems to be a nice wee distraction thrown to the left in order to take their minds of more important concerns such as Pfi, cutting/rationalisation of public services and the various wars around the globe.really its perfect we can pretend its a class issue because a load of toffs head it up, that way we fail to notice that the real ruling class are cutting wages and labour rights all over the shop whilst we chase after some fucking aristo's who are hardly the fucking vanguard of capital!
Hmmm, let me see, what's that word, oh yes. BOLLOCKS.
We fight on all fronts dickhead. But then, i don't suppose you've EVER fought the class enemy face to face, or looked them in the eye even... this issue gives you that chance
well i see that interest in italian autonomia has pulled one off for u again
We fight on all fronts dickhead. But then, i don't suppose you've EVER fought the class enemy face to face, or looked them in the eye even... this issue gives you that chance
have u faced the class enemy face to face?? i suppouse it was a cop or perhaps even a teacher u fucking muppet. Im sorry but may i repeat fox hunters are not the cutting edge of capital. Another issue with the fox hunting ban is that jobs will be lost but since they arent trendy worker jobs like miners they don't matter, and onc again may i suggest that capital has never been threatened by someone throwing a toff off a fuckinh horse.
if ur going to get wound up by fox hunting then fair enough but don't pretend its an important sphere of class struggle because it just isn't.
i mean theres an argument that engaging in blood sports is disgusting and shouldn't be accepted by society, much like we stop kids from torturing cats.
if the government are quite happy to see it passed u can be well assured it isn't and issue that threatens capitalism.
Still great fun watching the toffs and cops fighting tho....
I wouldnt just walk past if i saw some annoying rich looking pro hunt people wandering around in London... i dont think its something to make a big thing out of, but if they are putting themselves in the firing line might as well through some shit in their direction...
if ur going to get wound up by fox hunting then fair enough but don't pretend its an important sphere of class struggle because it just isn't.i mean theres an argument that engaging in blood sports is disgusting and shouldn't be accepted by society, much like we stop kids from torturing cats.
if the government are quite happy to see it passed u can be well assured it isn't and issue that threatens capitalism.
This is just 'holier than thou' moral bullshit.... wrong for many reasons...
In brief because where are these 'important spheres of class struggle' (and what makes you think we don't do other things?) Do these ofh so important struggles threaten capitalism? (the answer is no arsehole) You're trying to impose an hierarchy of struggle which is so very Leninist... whereas I have a libertarian position which recognises the complimentary nature of struggles...
well i see that interest in italian autonomia has pulled one off for u again
Quote:
We fight on all fronts dickhead. But then, i don't suppose you've EVER fought the class enemy face to face, or looked them in the eye even... this issue gives you that chancehave u faced the class enemy face to face?? i suppouse it was a cop or perhaps even a teacher u fucking muppet. Im sorry but may i repeat fox hunters are not the cutting edge of capital. Another issue with the fox hunting ban is that jobs will be lost but since they arent trendy worker jobs like miners they don't matter, and onc again may i suggest that capital has never been threatened by someone throwing a toff off a fuckinh horse.
Is the state part of the productive apparatus? Is the land part of production? If you answer yes to these questions your position is contradictory
AS it goes, yes I have faced the class enemy face to face knobhead....
Nobody has said foxhunters are the cutting edge of capital - that's a straw man you built for your own stupid purposes... AS for the bullshit about 'trendy workers like miners' - now it's plain to see you're just desperate... I live in the mining county par excellance, Durham... there's nothing you can tell me or Dave Douglas about mining... www.minersadvice.co.uk SO STOP BULLSHITTING OR FOAD.
gangster if ur too thick to be unable to see how fox hunting is not a real class struggle issue let alone one that is capable of empowering the working class then ur a tad thick, the government is pushing this ban ffs it doesnt take a fucking brain surgeon to work out that its a rather secondary issue and is actually taking the debate way from iraq for the past few days.
and sorry but complimentary struggles are all well and good but i fail to see how getting worked up over fox hunting is actually complimentary to any struggle especially in light of this being a government motivated issue as most people might in principle oppose fox hunting but it isnt something they really give 2 flying fucks about! and those that do atleast have the deceny to present it as a ethical stance and not some wanky "yeah fuck the toffs, clarse war, in'it!" that Class War seem so focussed on.
as for the miners they were just an example u wanker, uve managed to dodge the central issue here tho so thats good! so tell me what is ur position on the lose of the 8,000 jobs? im not actually using this as an argument for or against the ban just pointing out that for "class struggle" to favour a ban they should atleast offer some opinion on the job loses! I suspect however that because these jobs aren't as proletarian and sexy as say mining that u couldn't really care and don't feel the need to address the issue. trying to make out i was attacking miners is just fucking sad.
anyway gangster Wayne's already put u in yer place lad so do urself a favour and stay there instead of using "autonomia" rhetoric to justify claiming the fox hunting ban is a relevent to class struggle.
Calm it down a bit you two
TO be honest Wayne and Revolting nonce 68 are dimwits - barely capable of putting a lightbulb in 'place'...
You just don't get it, caught, like Wayne, trying to fit your pet 'hard' theory to a situation you know nothing about...
If you can't recognise the class enemy you're not interested in class struggle at all... (Duke of Windsor ring a bell???)
Calm it down a bit you two ;)
No, don't...this is far too entertaining watching one guy goad and the other hysterically throw insults at his/her PC screen.
well huntsabbing is about the only exercise alot of anarchists get, so more should do it. running for hours through muddy fields is worth much more than private gym membership. and i think you'll find that in large sections of the countryside where hunting takes place, it is a pretty big class issue, with most working class people being very much against these rich fucks who are driving up prices so it's barely affordable to live bleating about their right to mangle animals on 'their' land, and then frequently not even keeping to 'their' land and trampling people's gardens.
the reason that hunting is such a big issue is that it is not just an animal rights issue, as if that was the case the meat industry should by comparison be seen by large swathes of the population as being worthy of being bombed into the stoneage. while it is not in any way something that will bring down capitalism or go anyway towards it, it is still a class issue, and more specifically an attack on one of the few remaining priveledges of the old landed ruling class, their right to do whatever they want on their land. which is why they're getting so uppity about it compared to other things which probably otherwise offend their sensibilities more, like homosexuality. so they could actually become something of a dangerous reactionary force. or at least pretend to, i don't know if they have the energy to continue acting as they are for very long, hopefully they can just burn out and stop causing a distraction. anyway, i can't do anything from here, but seeing toffs being beaten up on bbc world is always cheering!
may i suggest that capital has never been threatened by someone throwing a toff off a fuckinh horse.
true, but it's still a good laugh!
Revolting nonce 68
Where DO you come up with such genius?
TO be honest Wayne and Revolting nonce 68 are dimwits - barely capable of putting a lightbulb in 'place'...![]()
![]()
You just don't get it, caught, like Wayne, trying to fit your pet 'hard' theory to a situation you know nothing about...
If you can't recognise the class enemy you're not interested in class struggle at all... (Duke of Windsor ring a bell???)
Bloody hell
Right, first off, simple fucking etiquette. Be nice children. What the fuck is going on? I go away for a second and come back to find the children bickering in the playground! If you can't say anything nice, then don't say anything at all. I'm being dead serious.
As for foxhunting, I wouldn't say that it was central to class struggle but then neither is supporting asylum seekers or anti-fascism and I think both of those are really worthwhile. Personally, I'm not so moved by foxhunting as to go out sabbing but I've got a lot of respect for those who do. Are you saying that unless we're involved in workplace or community politics then we're not doing anything worthwhile? They might not be what eventually brings down capitalism (only a self-active working class movement deeply rooted in workplace and community can do that) but they're still worth doing surely?
And as for meat-eaters who get all sanctimonious about hunting, I think it's hypocrisy to, er, a really big degree.
Why? Firstly, if hunting is a class issue then it is of interest to class struggle anarchists regardless of dietry preference (this doesn't mean we should all prioritise it tho). Secondly, there is a difference between being against foxhunting (which essentially is a way of killing an animal in a slow and painful way - revol's cat-torturing reference is a good one) and being against eating animals. You know that. Just coz you like to eat meat doesn't mean you like to torture animals. There is a difference. Also, eating meat doesn't mean support for the meat industry before you start
Also, revol, I don't know loads about the job aspect of this (don't know loads about most of it tbh) but from what I've read, all the places that used to do foxhunting that stopped and changed to other stuff like say, horse riding, rambling etc actually created more jobs than foxhunting. Also, the fact that you're a city boy saying that foxhunting is irrelevant is also an issue. Like the man GT said, people in the country generally hate the Countryside Alliance coz foxhunting drives up house prices, stops them walking where they want etc. Lastly, I'd say the fact that there are working class people who DO support the CA is an issue for socialists coz that's our class, supporting the ruling class i.e. the class we are not. We can't be having that surely!!
Anyway, all our politics are so similar that this is actually a molehill, turned into a mountain, by tiny midget people. Remember people, workers of the world unite (regardless of position on foxhunting!)
PS 3rd, I like you and all. It was cool being in the AYN with you, but your politics are shite
TOFFBUSTERS: Citizens Arrest the hunters!
Ho! Tally Fucking Ho! Ho! Blair's complete cock-up on the hunting bill gives us an unparalleled opportunity to bring class warfare back onto the streeets in the run up to the General Election.
The simple tactic will be to make Citizens Arrests on the hunters on February 18th when hunting becomes illegal. We cannot expect our overworked and underesourced plods to do this so we'll do it for them. After years of them using the law to further their class interests now the boot will be on the other foot. There's been plenty of calls on other threads to do this so lets use this thread to get it organised. We can oppose the Countryside Alliance whenever they show their faces up till Feb 18th but lets make that day the day for action against the fuckers all over the country.And lets be clear from the start - this isnt about animal welfare - its about class warfare making a long overdue return to centre stage. Remember 'reasonable force allowed'!!
The next step.......
Dont think we need get too worried about intricacies of citizens arrest at this stage.. The key element is to make the declaration that we will be attending hunts to prevent any law breaking. The police will be caught in a totally contradictory situation.They have used various laws to prevent people attending strikes - miners - demonstrations - Huntingdon etc - in the past. But we are going specifically to uphold the law - so will they try and stop our carloads of law abiders heading to the nearest hunt and not stop the hunt? The contradiction the police are placed is wonderful - and will open up all sorts of political opportunites depending on the way they act. As Machen points out our way of seeing things may be the common sense way for once!
Once the Countryside Alliance start trying to block access to electricity pylons etc etc the willingness to take action against them will extend far beyond the usual suspects.... it already does in fact.
This doesnt need a centralised campaign it need people to take the initiative locally, publicise their intentions and find out what the local CA and hunts are up to. We can use urban 75 to spread information. I think from response on this thread we already have enough for a Bristol Toffbusters and anyone in the West Country can contact us at toffbusters@yahoo.co.uk - suggest other people set up e-mail contacts by sticking town name in front of toffbusters or whatever you want to call yourselves.The more local groups there are the bigger the impact.
There will also be a leaflet available at the anarchist bookfair this weekend.
Get February 18th in them diaries now!
As for foxhunting, I wouldn't say that it was central to class struggle but then neither is supporting asylum seekers or anti-fascism and I think both of those are really worthwhile. Personally, I'm not so moved by foxhunting as to go out sabbing but I've got a lot of respect for those who do. Are you saying that unless we're involved in workplace or community politics then we're not doing anything worthwhile? They might not be what eventually brings down capitalism (only a self-active working class movement deeply rooted in workplace and community can do that) but they're still worth doing surely?
Ed are u joking??? anti facism and supporting asylum seekers are not central to class struggle?? It is obvious that the fight against fascism necessitates a class response, fascists seek to push corporatism, that the bosses and workers must put aside their differences for the good of the nation, its violent nationalism weakens the working class worldwide. Anti Fascism is a fucking class struggle neccessity, even when it is not a major movement its supporters spread fear and hatred within working class communities.
Support for aslyum seekers is integral to libertarian communism, saying as it is based on proletarian internationalism and rejects borders and nations. People fleeing persecution and poverty are victims of the class system! Not to mention how anti immigration sentiment is hyped up to scapegoat them for the underfunding of public services! In terms of actual wage labour, aslyum seekers make up one of the most exploited sectors of the labour market and this is not only a problem for asylum seekers but also depresses wages and conditions for all workers.
A government backed banning of fox hunting might be nice in terms of saying "fuck off to rich fucks playing cruel sports!" but lets remember that this is a cross class issue, one section of the ruling class is stopping a rather marginal section of the old landed ruling class from fox hunting, it will never threaten the actual productive relations in the countryside and will have no effect on the working class's empowerment! Instead it acts as a fig leaf to cover the Labour Parties vicious anti working class programme, its racist immigration policies and its militarism. Tony and co are quite happy to see us get all worked up over a few red coated toffs (in fact im sure many in the government personally hate them) on horses chasing after, admittedly, cute foxes.
To be honest im not against the ban i just feel that claiming that it is complimentary to the class struggle is just daft, gangsters class war on the streets post was hyperbolic nonsense! the real class struggle isn't about people with plummy voices or their cider drinking pseudo serfs coming to the city to protest a ban on their hunting, its waking up everyday and having to go spend 8 hours doing shit for shits to make other shits richer, or going down to collect ur £44 the govt see as adequate for ur existance, its about not having time to play with ur kids as much as ud like, its about the atomised communities we live in.
Revol68... you still haven't got it have you? I said earlier that if the state is part of capitalist production, and if land is integral to capitalism, then you had a contradictory position... which you have... So access to land isn't integral to class struggle? Here's me thinking factories and communities were BUILT on land... also to teach you a bit of history, the working class in the 19th century wanted access to the countryside ('lungs for workers') to get away from the pollution, and the Kinder Scout protests in the 1930s were all about access to land with a solid working class composition... If you continue to state that this ISN't class struggle, i honestly don't know which planet you're from... AS it goes you have a workerist definition of class which you prioritise, of which Stalin would have been proud, and which thankfully died a death when EP THompson and many others left the Communist party in 1956 cos of workerist excesses ie. tanks into Hungary.
I know that where I live, opposing hunting is sort of like political suicide. It is really popular with a lot of working class people and only the animal rights kids really oppose it. I don't hunt and am against killing animals, but I don't really see opposing hunting as an effective strategy for class war. Now, foxhunting is done by the rich right? So it seems like in that case it could be a good way to rally people around the capitalists out hunting foxes while they are working, but only if the effort is not headed up by a bunch of greens and hippies.
The strategy is NOT to 'oppose hunting' in the abstract -
The strategy IS to attack the toffs... These sort of things can snowball you know...
why has thise even turned into an arguement??no fox hunting isn't the corner stone of capiltilism and its fall won't insure tjhe end of the ruling class blahblahlalala i swear people disagree on these boards just for the sake of a lame ten minuteh arguement.
fox hunting = bad.class struggle = good. fox hunting and class struggle = two different things but not completely irrelevent to one anothoer because both things disagree with upperclass wankers havingg their own way there we go i win well done to shoes she's so cool.
am i drunk??why yes i am









Personally as far as Im concerned foxhunting is an animal rights issue not a class issue.
I'm possibly sabbing the Avon and Vale hunt again tomorrow.