What next?

Submitted by Joe Roe on 10 July, 2005 - 22:04.

Is there going to be an assembly to get together so everyone there can discuss the positives and negatives but ultimatley what happens next.

I think overall the week was great, although the last two days were a bit disappointing. I felt that there was division in tactics and I felt the insurrectionary anarchists became increasingly marginalised by a group of pacifist facilitators.

Regardless, I think it's important to have a post-G8 analysis and where we go next type thing.

11 July, 2005 - 16:52

wasnt it fairly reasonable that the 'insurrectionists' got marginalised in the latter part of the week, what kind of reaction do you think we wouldve received if we'd kicked off with the police or planned anything audacious on the 7th or after?!

It was good though, the direct democracy at stirling was really inspiring despite some difficulties. I'm just trying to collect my thoughts and recollections of what happened over the summit but once ive done so i'll post something or other.

Does anyone think that such demo's (despite the benefits) are still beneficial in the long term with regards to the amount of information the police are able to gather?

12 July, 2005 - 01:53

I think some kind of general Dissent! debrief/gathering was planned for the end of July. No idea whether it'll happen with all of us so fried..

12 July, 2005 - 12:36

just a few points need to be made first congratulations to activists who took part in actions against the g8. people with disabilities children and their parents. also people in the kitchens

let me repeat what I said last tuesday that for people who wanted to protest in a peaceful manner that was their right. I personal have no problems with direct actions against the state remember the state uses voilence.

the issue of people doing security at the eco village gate need to be looked at do we need people stoned out of their heads on acid, mushrooms, e what would happen if there was a raid. security is a priority. a old Irish saying fish that keep their mouth shut never get caught.

neither would I condem the actions of black block political activists

12 July, 2005 - 13:22
Vaneigemappreciationclub wrote:
wasnt it fairly reasonable that the 'insurrectionists' got marginalised in the latter part of the week, what kind of reaction do you think we wouldve received if we'd kicked off with the police or planned anything audacious on the 7th or after?!

There were enough people there on the Thursday to break through the police lines so that the Prisoner Solidarity demo could try and get to Stirling as they had wanted.

The bombs in London however, suddenly saw everyone moderating their politics in order to console the authorities, regardless of the fact our right to protest was being curbed in what was an obvious case of state repression. The reaction to that was disappointing.

12 July, 2005 - 13:24
Lazlo_Woodbine wrote:
I think some kind of general Dissent! debrief/gathering was planned for the end of July. No idea whether it'll happen with all of us so fried..

End of July is much too soon. Mid/End of August beginning of September would be better. Give people time to put everything into perspective.

12 July, 2005 - 16:00

Check out http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2005/07/318050.html for more info, I agree it is a bit soon but there are some pressing concerns like those stuck in jail. neutral

13 July, 2005 - 11:37

can i sugguest that dissent have a genereal meeting at the anarchist bookfair in October people maybe om their holidays.

13 July, 2005 - 11:53
Quote:
The bombs in London however, suddenly saw everyone moderating their politics in order to console the authorities, regardless of the fact our right to protest was being curbed in what was an obvious case of state repression. The reaction to that was disappointing.

I dont think it was a matter of cuddling up to the authorities, the fact is any provocational action (even ones to defend our rights that were ridden roughshod over all week) wouldve a)left us open to immense police brutality which could have easily gone unreported b) been the worst PR move in history, we shouldnt pander to the press but any action following the london bombings wouldve been disastorous.

14 July, 2005 - 11:57
Con Carroll wrote:
can i sugguest that dissent have a genereal meeting at the anarchist bookfair in October people maybe om their holidays.

That's a very good idea.

14 July, 2005 - 11:59
Vaneigemappreciationclub wrote:
any action following the london bombings wouldve been disastorous.

Disastrous for who? If we had a united front within the camp we could have easily broken through police lines so that the Prisoner Solidarity march could have happened as planned. That objective was winnable.

14 July, 2005 - 13:06
Quote:
If we had a united front within the camp we could have easily broken through police lines so that the Prisoner Solidarity march could have happened as planned. That objective was winnable.

it may well have been possible but you know how trying to break through police lines wouldve ended-in a massive ruck with more arrests and more injuries-and with what happened in stirling the locals may well have happily helped the police shoe us-it would have made the media, they wouldve portrayed us as heartless yobs who just want to fight regardless of the situation in london. The police surrounding the camp were also the Met who were probably pretty pissed that they werent in london to help, so they wouldve been pretty pumped up and couldve kicked the shit out of us with little worry about any inquiry or press attention-disasterous.

15 July, 2005 - 10:52
Vaneigemappreciationclub wrote:
Quote:
If we had a united front within the camp we could have easily broken through police lines so that the Prisoner Solidarity march could have happened as planned. That objective was winnable.

it may well have been possible but you know how trying to break through police lines wouldve ended-in a massive ruck with more arrests and more injuries-and with what happened in stirling the locals may well have happily helped the police shoe us-it would have made the media, they wouldve portrayed us as heartless yobs who just want to fight regardless of the situation in london. The police surrounding the camp were also the Met who were probably pretty pissed that they werent in london to help, so they wouldve been pretty pumped up and couldve kicked the shit out of us with little worry about any inquiry or press attention-disasterous.

Yeah but, No but!

You speak some truth. They would have portrayed us badley whatever the situation and there was outreach work in Stirling happening. Also, there were more of us, than there were of them. To start with anyway.

23 July, 2005 - 02:11

I was somebody trying to stop people trying to breach police lines on Thursday for the Prisoner support demo! (or rather prevent people from mouthing off provocatively about 'fucking the police' and then running to the back had you suceeded in provoking them).

The police had overwhelming numbers. Only the most romantic dreamer amongst us would have thought we would have got more than a further 20 feet from the site, before inviting much more repression.

We would have then risked a further clampdown, and invasion of the whole campsite. You would have only provoked a riot on our own doorstep, nowhere near the citadels of power! Given the general state clampdown after the bombings, the state was in an ideal position to smash us.

Those who can not recognise this are not capeable of successfully conducting the class war. To fight a successfull class war, you need to know how and when to retreat as well as when to advance. Armies that cannot retreat are broken - they are routed instead. They are a rabble, not a victorious army of the class war.

And the person i love was held in nick for protest, along with 20 of my best mates. The van to pick them up for bail was held up by the rabble / predictably paranoid police blockade. When we got you and the coppers to back off, the vans got out.

And to some of those who abused me for trying to organise this orderly retreat. Well soon you will fuck off out of our movement and pick up your trust funds, reminiscing with your petite bourgeoise buddies about how you once were rude to a copper.

The rest of us, who are trying to sustain a class war year in and year out don't need to shoot our load in fustration at a summit spectacular, on a day when the window for effective action is passed. Stick around, be patient and you will have plenty of other, better opportunities. Duh! There, got it orf me chest! sorry if I was rude to decent and committed activists. red star

24 July, 2005 - 23:30

Personally I was in Stirling talking to local people - they were pretty supportive after a bit of argument/discussion. Ex-miners and so on and I was in their town as an activist when the poll tax (not to mention the miners' strike) happened, so they knew I knew. (quoted local people, places, happenings).

Actually some people made a point of shaking my hand and saying they were proud of us.

Unofficial outreach as well as showing some of my comrades how hard the work really is to get the message across to the 'man in the street'.

30 September, 2005 - 09:22

Generally the anti capitalist argument has been confined to a few large demos, for many, in far off cities.

In the Locale, it hardly exists, and we should remember the old addage; think global act local... turn up the volume locally....

Heres a few ideas

.... get onto your council web site , most have a public forum... challenge local politicians to a public debate on capitalism [they wont do it on the forum], invite them to the local park on a particular Sunday afternoon, they probbally wont come either, but you can, with your aurgument and with your mates, to give the people in the park a laugh and some food for thought.

Graffitti is an old favorite and if you want to do it legaly then, write it on a sheet and hang it from a flyover or at a roundabout [like the happy 50th birthday ones]

Blatantly cover up the big bill boards with your own message.

Remember the more signs of discontent around the town the more discontent will be encouraged

Create free space for everyone and inject a fusion of pure democracy into the system

.... why not set up an on line parliament..[great for setting up the right wingers into an alterative approach to politics]

. Encorage users to stand as representatives for the results of the parliament at local elections. this puts the cats among the politians and we will get local politicians representing local democracy as well as the lib, lab con. and because its a free space , its another space where we can bring the anti capitalist argument too.

Im sure if we can get a dozen or so sites up we can then get the concept [e-democracy] some media coverage which can only help snowball it. More sand in the wheels for the old school politicians and a small injection of democracy into the system. There is one on line already in the sleepy conservative town of Poole in Dorset, check it out www.pooleparliament.co.uk.

Keep plugging away locally , critical cycle masses etc. turn the back of your bike into a billboard, its a great place for a social message and the cars find it very difficult to drive around you..... dont let the preasure drop..become a living protest....

see you in Sheffield!

1 February, 2006 - 19:17

Hi

Post of the year.

Love

LR