Syriza, Podemos, Left Front… May capital's far left die!

Syriza, Podemos, Left Front… May capital's far left die!

Critique of some contemporary far left political parties.

This joke could very well summarize the programmatic lessons to be drawn from the situation that proletarians in Greece, our brothers and sisters of misery and struggle, are subjected to. Indeed since always or at least since the great campaigns of Social Democracy in the early 20th century for the establishment of universal suffrage, which aimed at nothing else than the containment and the destruction of the proletariat’s energy developed to put an end to misery and exploitation, the communist critique (whether the latter expressed itself under the “anarchist” label, the “revolutionary socialist” or another one is not what we are interested in here) has always denounced the electoral circus, parliamentarianism, governmentalism, collaboration with bourgeois institutions, and the almost religious belief that reforms could improve the lot of our class…

In this short contribution we will not further talk about the “Greek sovereign debt” or the rescue of the “euro zone”, and even less about the “Grexit”, so fashionable these last weeks in bourgeois media. We are not going to develop the different strategies of Syriza government to “defy” the financial institutions of the European Commission and the Troika. We leave all these “details” to the fervent followers of political economy. For our part, we consider that the communists do not have to wallow in the biology of Capital, while our task is fundamentally to participate in its necrology! We will also not turn our attention to the Prime Minister Tsipras’ “psychology”, to what he hoped or intended to do, we will not take into account the media show and the incredible statements of his Finance Minister the foppish playboy Varoufakis (self-proclaimed “libertarian Marxist”!) and his gang of leftists, just able to snivel about the “denial of democracy” vis-à-vis the July 5th referendum results and about the “diktat of the euro zone”. What the communists are interested in is not what people say about themselves but what they do and assume in their social practices…

So what’s going on in Greece is just the antepenultimate episode of the always sad and lamentable story of the historical Social Democracy, that is to say the bourgeois party for workers and proletarians, this social force in charge of emptying our movements of struggle from their subversive substance, of diverting their perspectives of radical transformation of the world onto a simple reform, and finally of making us falling back into ranks of social peace. The camp of Social Democracy materializes at two levels: by setting up a militant structure external to our class, a structure directly stemming from leftist and progressive factions of the bourgeois class on the one hand, and by development of a reformist ideological corpus generated within our class and based on the weaknesses, limitations and illusions of the struggle on the other hand, all that in a dialectical back-and-forth movement between both.

So what’s going on in Greece is nothing very different from what the very “radical” Workers Party of Brazil (led by the reformist Lula da Silva and the former “guerrilla” Dilma Roussef) achieved in recent years in terms of attacks on proletarians’ living conditions; what by the way provoked the June 2013 revolt against austerity and misery.

Historically we got used to the “betrayals” of Capital’s left and far left (even if only gullible fools believing that any bourgeois alternative will solve the fundamental problems of our class, of humanity can consider themselves to be “betrayed”)… Already in 1871, during the significant proletarian movement known as the “Paris Commune”, the left and the far left took over its leadership and set up a government that had never taken any revolutionary measure to counter the bourgeois forces of Versailles or to internationally extend the militant efforts underway. All the measures of this “Paris Commune’s government” had resulted to only one thing: disarming (both military and programmatic) of our class confronted with our historical enemy that could after it had been defeated for a short time, reconstruct itself…

Going back to 1914, we can notice the same phenomenon when leftists, who had declared to be openly opposed to war, changed the side before you could say knife. For example, the French “revolutionary socialist” militant Gustave Hervé who had originally written in the newspaper “La Guerre Sociale” (“The Social War”) that we have to “plant the national flag on the dunghill” quickly joined the defense of “the country in danger”… Ditto for the French anarcho-syndicalist CGT which after years of antimilitarist propaganda joined in serried ranks of war supporters and sacred union, allowing thus the feasibility of general mobilization or at least contributing to its smooth course…

In 1917, while soldiers were getting increasingly angry on all fronts against the capitalist slaughter, the “Bolshevik Party” went at the head of the war refusal movement in order to better bring it in the dead end of a “radical” change of government, toppling the reign of the millennial Tsar, and it ultimately participated in the reconstruction of the capitalist State in Russia, roughly shaken by our class in struggle, what resulted in Stalinism and its “socialism in one country”…

In 1918 in Germany, after several years of open collaboration with the headquarters of the imperial army, which resulted in the mobilization on the front as well as in the participation of industrial workers in the war effort, a significant faction of Social Democracy (the SPD) was directly called to the political management (and thus set up a government), and it was militants of the left who directly participated in crushing of the proletarian struggle while forming of “Freikorps” under the aegis of the “worker” and “socialist deputy” Noske…

Finally, to conclude here this non-exhaustive list, in 1936 in Spain it was thanks to the “critical support” and the votes of the CNT militants that the Popular Front won the elections. It was thus able to develop an “antifascist” republican politics which practically opposed the proletariat’s boosts in its struggle for social revolution, all that with an active help of the CNT-FAI’s “comrades-ministers”. Once again, the revolution was sacrificed on the altar of the defense of one bourgeois camp considered as a “lesser evil”!

Anyway we could fill up in this way dozens of pages with the horrors that our class has experienced in diversion of its struggles and in deepening of its weaknesses. As we can see, the left and the far left (all factions taken into account) have always been and will continue to be predominant elements in structuring and maintaining the capitalist dictatorship. The proletariat is historically forced and determined to fight against them in the same way as it fights all the other factions of the bourgeoisie if it wants to put once and for all an end to misery, exploitation and wars…

But let’s come back to the present events and to how the current leftist managers of our misery claim to solve the problem… All those who criticized (rightly so moreover) the referendum organized by Tsipras’ government missed the whole point: their critics did not go beyond the endless sniveling according to which the “Yes” would mean a tough austerity and the “No” a less harsh austerity. In fact, and what followed proved it, (anyway could it be otherwise?), the “No” has never meant anything else (as in every election) than giving to the government a “free hand” and letting it to develop an austerity even stronger than the one originally imposed by the European authorities and their capitalist gangsters. You would really have to be a first-rate “useful idiot” to believe for a single second that the election or referendum show can be anything else than a farce which the proletarians fool themselves with… Capital’s far left historically accustomed us to its leftist policy, which is never anything else than a facelift more or less “radical” according to the circumstances and needs of the moment, the whole finally being only a red-painted version of the same capitalist dictatorship. In this case of Greece, there is an “originality” – a leftist party and government apply word for word the structural adjustment plan and the relentless austerity measures concocted in the headquarters of what people call decision-making centers of capitalism’s liberal policies. But finally beyond the differences of forms and speeches, all that directly and intrinsically partakes in the very logic of the capitalist system. Or, better said, it is not Syriza which is the actor of history but the history of capitalism that finds in Syriza an actor up to the task, an actor able to perform its dirty work, that is to say to frontally attack the proletariat in its means of existence and struggle.

Because what is the principal point in the “Greek crisis” is not the “debt”, which anyway amounts “only” to € 324 billion (more than three-quarters being repayable in only several years); for comparison the debt of France is € 2,089 billion, that of Italy 2,194 billion and 9,293 billion for the “euro zone”, not to mention that of the largest debtor nation-state in the world and in history: the USA with a colossal and abyssal debt of $ 18,152 billion! Capitalism clearly needs to produce the debt, anyway it cannot do anything else than to race out of control and to always more rest its expanded reproduction on fictitious capital, on a not yet produced value which will probably never be realized… No, what’s really the point is the practical implementation of a program to contain the proletariat, not only in Greece but also in other parts of Europe where Capital needs to hit even harder and to discipline a surplus labor power, to always more divide proletarians into different categories, whites and “darkies”, nationals and migrants, the good hard-working citizens who accept the austerity without too much fuss and those who raise their heads, those who show their teeth and organize, struggle, revolt… And in this sense, Greece is a social laboratory for the bourgeoisie and its far left servants!

The proletariat all over the world is condemned to always get its face smashed…

If the law-abiding and pacified proletariat in Europe and North America, addicted to always more terrorist State campaigns of citizenship attitude development, believe to escape its fate without struggling, it is kidding itself as never before…

We will have to put an end to all these illusions about the parliamentary circus, about the game of political parties, but also that of trade unions which do nothing but saving social peace and negotiate the sale of our labor power to the highest bidder.

We have nothing to gain either in new beliefs that would guarantee the “purity” of our struggles against the scoria of bourgeois politics: self-management (that is to say the management of our own misery), “popular assemblies” open to all and where everyone can speak freely (including “scabs”, strikebreakers, “moderates”, good citizens…), production cooperatives where the essence of Capital (money, exchange and therefore the value!) is never eliminated…

In a declaration issued on July 1st an “Antiauthoritarian Movement” from Thessaloniki says seriously: “We do not care about the currency that will be part of a national reawakening and we cannot support of course a currency that is part of the financial intrusion into every aspect of our lives. We prefer to think of the currency in its normal dimension as an instrument for exchange with its main function being social needs and facilities.” Pitiful leftism and its lack of understanding of what capitalism is!

In short all this fashionable democratic jumble that has never ever been any guarantee for the development of our struggles and the deepening of our ruptures with the society of Capital and its staunch defenders.

Comrades, against the capitalist catastrophe made of more misery, austerity, repression and wars, against the environmental destruction of the planet generated by a social relation that does not care about humans, there is no other alternative but the revolutionary struggle to the death for the destruction of what destroys us…

The only alternative is as follows: either communism or the end of humanity! In between, there is nothing!

# Class War – July 2015 #

Source: http://www.autistici.org/tridnivalka/class-war-022015-syriza-podemos-left-front-may-capitals-far-left-die/

Posted By

Guerre de Classe
Aug 2 2015 17:25

Share

Attached files

Comments

James MacBryde
Nov 8 2015 21:33

"The communists dreamt it [the nightmare] up, Syriza realised it."

This joke could very well summarise the programmatic lessons to be drawn from the situation that proletarians in Greece, our brothers and sisters of misery and struggle, are subjected to. For time, or at least since the great campaigns of Social Democracy in the early 20th century for the establishment of universal suffrage, which aimed at nothing else but the containment and destruction of the proletariat’s energy – developed to put an end to misery and exploitation – the communist critique (whether the latter expressed itself under the 'anarchist' label, as 'revolutionary socialist' or as any other is not what we are interested in here) has always denounced the electoral circus, parliamentarianism, governmentalism, collaboration with bourgeois institutions, and the almost religious belief that reforms could improve the lot of our class…

In this short contribution we will not talk further about the 'Greek sovereign debt' or the rescue of the 'euro zone', and even less about the 'Grexit', topics so fashionable these last weeks in the bourgeois media. We are not going to develop the different strategies of the Syriza government to 'defy' the financial institutions of the European Commission and the Troika. We leave all these 'details' to the fervent followers of political economy. For our part, we consider that the communists do not have to wallow in the biology of Capital but our task is fundamentally to participate in its necrology! We will also not turn our attention to the Prime Minister Tsipras’ 'psychology', to what he hoped or intended to do, we will not take into account the media show and the incredible statements of his Finance Minister, the foppish playboy Varoufakis (self-proclaimed 'libertarian Marxist'!) and his gang of leftists, just able to snivel about the 'denial of democracy' vis-à-vis the July 5th referendum results and about the 'diktat of the euro zone'. What communists are interested in is not what people say about themselves but what they do and assume in their social practices…

So what’s going on in Greece is just the antepenultimate episode of the always sad and lamentable story of historic Social Democracy, that is to say the bourgeois party for workers and proletarians, this social force in charge of emptying our movements of struggle from their subversive substance, of diverting their perspectives of radical transformation of the world into a simple reform, and finally, of making us fall back into the ranks of social peace. The camp of Social Democracy materialises at two levels: by setting up a militant structure external to our class, a structure directly stemming from leftist and progressive factions of the bourgeois class on the one hand and, on the other hand, by development of a reformist ideological corpus generated within our class and based on the weaknesses, limitations and illusions of the struggle, all that in a dialectical back-and-forth movement between both.

So what’s going on in Greece is nothing very different from what the very 'radical' Workers Party of Brazil (led by the reformist Lula da Silva and the former 'guerrilla' Dilma Roussef) achieved in recent years in terms of attacks on proletarians’ living conditions; which, by the way provoked the June 2013 revolt against austerity and misery.

Historically, we have got used to the 'betrayals' of Capital’s left and far left (even if only the gullible fools that believe any bourgeois alternative will solve the fundamental problems of our class, of humanity, consider themselves to be 'betrayed')… Already in 1871, during the significant proletarian movement known as the 'Paris Commune', the left and the far left took over its leadership and set up a government that never took any revolutionary measure to counter the bourgeois forces of Versailles or to internationally extend the militant efforts underway. All the measures of this 'government of the Paris Commune' had resulted in only one thing: the disarming (both military and programmatic) of our class confronted with our historical enemy that, once it had been defeated temporarily, reconstructed itself…

Going back to 1914, we can observe the same phenomenon, when leftists who had declared openly to be opposed to war, changed sides before you could say 'knife'. For example, the French 'revolutionary socialist' militant Gustave Hervé who had originally written in the newspaper La Guerre Sociale (The Social War) that we have to 'plant the national flag on the dunghill' quickly joined the defense of 'the country in danger'… Ditto for the French anarcho-syndicalist CGT, which after years of antimilitarist propaganda, joined in the serried ranks of war supporters and sacred union, thus allowing the feasibility of general mobilisation, or at least contributing to its smooth course…

In 1917, while soldiers were getting increasingly angry on all fronts at the capitalist slaughter, the 'Bolshevik Party' went to the head of the war refusal movement in order to better bring into force the dead end of a 'radical' change of government, toppling the reign of the millennial Tsar, and ultimately participating in the reconstruction of the capitalist State in Russia, roughly shaken by our class in struggle, which resulted in Stalinism and its 'socialism in one country'…

In 1918, in Germany, after several years of open collaboration with the headquarters of the imperial army – which resulted in mobilisation to the front, as well as the participation of industrial workers in the war effort – a significant faction of Social Democracy (the SPD) was directly called upon to political management (and thus set up a government), and it was militants of the left who directly participated in the crushing of the proletarian struggle, while forming 'Freikorps' under the aegis of the 'worker' and 'socialist deputy', Noske…

Finally, to conclude this non-exhaustive list, in 1936, in Spain it was thanks to the 'critical support' and the votes of the CNT militants that the Popular Front won the elections. It was thus able to develop an 'antifascist' republican politics, which practically opposed the proletariat’s boosts in its struggle for social revolution, all that with the active help of the CNT-FAI’s 'comrades-ministers'. Once again, the revolution was sacrificed on the altar of the defense of one bourgeois camp, considered as a 'lesser evil'!

Anyway we could fill up dozens of pages in this way with the horrors that our class has experienced in diversion of its struggles and in the deepening of its weaknesses. As we can see, the left and the far left (all factions taken into account) have always been and will continue to be, predominant elements in structuring and maintaining the capitalist dictatorship. The proletariat is historically forced and determined to fight against them, in the same way as it fights against all the other factions of the bourgeoisie, if it wants to, once and for all, put an end to misery, exploitation and wars…

But let’s come back to the present events and to how the current leftist managers of our misery claim to solve the problem… All those who criticised (rightly so, moreover) the referendum organised by Tsipras’ government, missed the whole point: these critics did not go beyond the sniveling, endless sniveling according to which 'Yes' would mean a tough austerity and 'No', a less harsh austerity. In fact – and what followed proved it – (how could it be otherwise?), the 'No' vote has never meant anything else (as in every election) than to give the government a 'free hand' enabling it to develop austerity measures even stronger than the ones originally imposed by the European authorities and their capitalist gangsters. You would really have to be a first-rate 'useful idiot' to believe for a single second that the election or referendum show can be anything else than a farce which proletarians fool themselves with… Capital’s far left historically accustomed us to its leftist policy, which is never anything else than a facelift more or less 'radical' according to the circumstances and needs of the moment, the whole finally being only a red-painted version of the same capitalist dictatorship. In the case of Greece, there is an 'originality': a leftist party and government apply word for word the structural adjustment plan and the relentless austerity measures concocted in the headquarters of what people call decision-making centres of capitalism’s liberal policies.But finally, beyond the differences of forms and speeches, all this directly and intrinsically partakes in the very logic of the capitalist system. Or, better said, it is not Syriza which is the actor of history but the history of capitalism that finds in Syriza an actor up to the task, an actor able to perform its dirty work, that is to say to frontally attack the proletariat in its means of existence and struggle.

The principal point in the 'Greek crisis' is not the 'debt', which anyway amounts to 'only' €324 billion (more than three-quarters being repayable over several years); for comparison, the debt of France is €2,089 billion, that of Italy €2,194 billinon and €9,293 billion for the 'euro zone', not to mention that of the largest debtor nation state in the world and in history: the USA with a colossal and deep-seated debt of $18,152 billion! Capitalism clearly needs to produce debt, besides it can do nothing other than to race out of control and increasingly resting its expanded reproduction on fictitious capital, on value not yet produced and that will probably never be realised… No, the real point is the actual implementation of a programme to contain the proletariat, not only in Greece but also in other parts of Europe where Capital needs to hit even harder and to discipline surplus labour power, to continually increase the divide between proletarians into different categories, 'whites' and 'blacks', nationals and migrants, the good hard-working citizens who accept the austerity without too much fuss and those who raise their heads, show their teeth and organise, struggle, revolt… And in this sense, Greece is a social laboratory for the bourgeoisie and its far left servants!

The proletariat all over the world is condemned to always get its face smashed in…

If the law-abiding and pacified proletariat in Europe and North America, addicted to increasing campaigns of State terror of model citizenship development, believe it can escape its fate without struggling, it is kidding itself as never before…

We will have to put an end to all these illusions about the parliamentary circus, about the game of political parties, but also that of trade unions, which do nothing but safeguard social peace and negotiate the sale of our labour power to the highest bidder.

We have nothing to gain either in new beliefs that would guarantee the 'purity' of our struggles against the dross of bourgeois politics: self-management (that is to say the management of our own misery), 'popular assemblies' open to all and where everyone can speak freely (including 'scabs'/strikebreakers, 'moderates'/good citizens…), production cooperatives where the essence of Capital (money, exchange and therefore value!) is never eliminated…

A statement issued in all sincerity by 'Anti-authoritarian Movement' from Thessaloniki says: 'We do not care about the currency that will be part of a national reawakening and we cannot support of course a currency that is part of the financial intrusion into every aspect of our lives. We prefer to think of the currency in its normal dimension as an instrument for exchange with its main function being social needs and facilities.' Pitiful leftism with its lack of proper understanding of what capitalism is!

In short, all this fashionable democratic jumble has never ever been any guarantee for the development of our struggles and the deepening of our ruptures with the society of Capital and its staunch defenders.

Comrades, against the capitalist catastrophe made up of more misery, austerity, repression and wars, against the environmental destruction of the planet generated by a social relation that does not care about human beings, there is no other alternative but the revolutionary struggle to the death for the destruction of what destroys us…

The only alternative is as follows: either communism or the end of humanity! In between, there is nothing!

# Class War – July 2015 #

bastarx
Nov 9 2015 12:44

Is there a point to making a comment that is just the whole article repeated without adding any of your own boring commentary?

James MacBryde
Nov 9 2015 16:38

The above article is a translation by someone who's first language is not English. Although not my mother tongue, English is my first language. It was, therefore, my pleasure to correct ungrammatical parts of the text. Thanks for your interest in the text and I look forward to reading your comment.

Spikymike
Nov 9 2015 17:00

James,
Always useful to provide 'grammatical' corrections to texts but suggest you say that in the introduction if you do it again as I read the first version pretty easily and didn't realise that's what you had done. By the way I think this is a sound and punchy analytical and historical summary of the objective role of the Left of Capital if not necessarily what motivates many of it's working class supporters.

James MacBryde
Nov 9 2015 19:23

Thank you for your gracious praise for the text, Mike.

I did struggle to find an English equivalent for the French word 'abyssal'. I had to make do with 'deep-seated'.

James MacBryde
Nov 9 2015 19:25

Thank you for your gracious praise for the text, Mike.

I did struggle to find an English equivalent for the French word 'abyssal'. I had to make do with 'deep-seated'.

Guerre de Classe
Nov 10 2015 18:22

Thanx a lot for your proofreading...
Solidarity...