Debate on 'direct unionism'

Comments

Chilli Sauce
Dec 2 2011 08:00

Thanks for posting these up (Juan, I presume).

Ed
Dec 2 2011 10:41

Yeah, cheers.. I'm feeling a bit ill and just read it all. Really good stuff!

Inhousejoke
Dec 2 2011 12:58

Cool stuff, might be worth adding the original paper up there too?

http://libcom.org/library/direct-unionism-discussion-paper-09052011

Nate
Dec 7 2011 20:10

Just wanted to say thanks to Juan for getting the initial ball rolling of conversation in print about the direct unionism discussion paper and Chili for pushing folk to write letters on this. Aside from the contents of the debate, I've been pleased to see back and forth about vision and values in the Industrial Worker like this.

Juan Conatz
May 26 2016 22:50

Hmm. Actually I'm pretty sure the way this is organized is all in order. I'll check later.

EDIT: yeah, Klas, the order that it is in is the correct one and based off when each article was published or posted. Your order is incorrect as it changes the order of Lynd's reply (doesn't really make a difference either way) and puts my final reply before John O'Reilly's, even though I refer to his.

klas batalo
May 27 2016 02:12
Juan Conatz wrote:
Hmm. Actually I'm pretty sure the way this is organized is all in order. I'll check later.

EDIT: yeah, Klas, the order that it is in is the correct one and based off when each article was published or posted. Your order is incorrect as it changes the order of Lynd's reply (doesn't really make a difference either way) and puts my final reply before John O'Reilly's, even though I refer to his.

okay weird. i also think maybe not all the articles are actually linked. hmm. well good to know. grin

Juan Conatz
May 27 2016 02:25

As far as I'm aware, these are all the articles that are direct replies to the discussion paper. Are you aware of others? I know that that 'Wobblyism' mentions and assesses direct unionism, but it's more its own thing.

Juan Conatz
Jan 8 2018 01:26

FYI, self-deleted a comment I made. Looks like a reply by syndicalist was deleted along with it. Sorry about that.

syndicalist
Jan 8 2018 01:49
Juan Conatz wrote:
FYI, self-deleted a comment I made. Looks like a reply by syndicalist was deleted along with it. Sorry about that.

NP. It was only relative to the OP so no sweat.