I have a question about the current situation of the Coordinadora in Spain, the Spanish dockworkers union. My question is, have they been able to maintain their non-bureaucratic, assemblyist practice?
A bit of background. At the time of the big strike wave that smashed the old fascist unions after Franco's death, the longshoremen in Barcelona conducted a strike through a mass assembly. They bashed in the doors to the union hall owned by the fascist union & seized it. Although that strike was for re-instatement of a docker who was a CP member, members of the CNT reportedly gained dominant influence over the movement. They persuaded the longshoremen to continue the assembly as a union. This was how the Coordinadora federation was formed, with autonomous local assemblies in each port. They followed the old CNT practice of attaching the national coordination committee to a locality, and thus having the workers in that locality elect it.
When the system of government established bargaining councils were established, they followed the practice of those sections of the CNT who eventually became the CGT. That is, they participated in the union elections. But they did not allow their elected delegates to receive the pay provided by employers & the state under the Spanish collective bargaining system. They are required to give the pay to the union. They did not want members to seek election for careerist motivations. They also had, as of the '80s, no paid positions whatsoever in the local port unions. The only paid position in the union was the national coordinator....a position that was rotated.
From what I had heard back in the '80s I gather they decided not to affiliate to CNT or CGT because they did not want to be drawn into factional disputes which would break the unity of the assemblies.
I do know that in the 2006 union elections in Spain the Coordinadora received 80 percent of the vote of dock workers in Spain. I also know that in recent years they have periodically paralyzed the ports in strikes. I believe the other 20 percent of votes in union elections has mainly gone to the Workers Commisssions & UGT. What I do not know is the degree to which they've been able to maintain the assemblyist control & absence of paid bureaucracy.
It gets a mention here:
It gets a mention here: http://www.alasbarricadas.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=57085&p=595646&hilit=Coordinadora#p595646
I'm not sure if it helps much. I've looked for information on this before and not found a lot.
Sounds like the assemblyist
Sounds like the assemblyist structures are still intact. Says they still have no liberados (paid officials) and refuse "subsidies" (pay to the delegates). The criticism there is that it has "been emptied of content". I take this to mean that they are not as overtly revolutionary as they were in the early years.
On the other hand, I have noticed that during the last few years when there have been attempts to form "revolutionary blocs" of the radical unions to left of the "pactist" Workers Commissions & UGT, which have usually involved the CGT & sometimes CNT, the Coordinadora has sometimes been listed in these blocs.
In Spain there is a strong
In Spain there is a strong current of radical unionism not strictly anarchosyndicalist. It is made of different unions coming from other political and ideological background. Coordinadora is one of them. It has been living quite isolated from other unions since the 80s. In some general strikes it has no been part of them, remaining strictly in their workplace struggles. I think they might be kind of radical socialdemocrats, similar to STES (http://www.stes.es/) and SF (http://www.sindicatoferroviario.com/)
In recent years CGT is been gaining a small ground in some docks and shipyards (i.e. Valencia, Tenerife and Barcelona).
http://estibadores.cgtvalencia.org/
http://fetyc.cgt.es/category/mar-y-puertos/
Another radical union in Tenerife is also growing:
http://estibadores.cgtvalencia.org/2014/03/tenerife-deja-de-ser-100-coordinadora.html
CNT also has some members in a shipyard
http://puertoreal.cnt.es/es/secc-s-navantia.html
New thread on alasbarricadas:
New thread on alasbarricadas: http://www.alasbarricadas.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=61634
Here is a great 45 minute
Here is a great 45 minute documentary on La Coordinadora, uploaded by the Swedish Dock Workers' Union (aside from the SAC the other large independent, radical union in Sweden)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bg87F7q5YFc
[youtube]bg87F7q5YFc[/youtube]
Report on the Coordinadora's
Report on the Coordinadora's current dispute with the Spanish government:
http://www.idcdockworkers.org/en/home/8-noticias/691-unions-around-the-world-press-spanish-government-to-negotiate-modification-of-the-stowage-system-with-workers
The Coordinadora on facebook:
The Coordinadora on facebook:
https://en-gb.facebook.com/CoordinadoraEstatalDeTrabajadoresDelMar/
According to this report nine strike days have been called, starting on the 6th March:
http://cadenaser.com/ser/2017/02/21/economia/1487701623_158495.html
Reuters report from a couple of weeks ago:
http://www.reuters.com/article/us-spain-ports-idUSKBN15O1J4
Support from Australia: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AGHPvphk9UQ
[youtube]AGHPvphk9UQ[/youtube]
A report from Tarragona on
A report from Tarragona on the conditions and pay of dock workers (in Spanish):
http://www.diaridetarragona.com/tarragona/81958/¿privilegiadosr-por-la-manana-ni-siquiera-sabemos-si-vamos-a-trabajar
RTVE Informe Semanal -
RTVE Informe Semanal - Estibadores: ¿Carga o descarga? - Spanish TV report on the legal and political background to the dispute:
http://www.rtve.es/m/alacarta/videos/informe-semanal/informe-semanal-estibadores-carga-descarga/3925966/?media=tve
Radio discussion about the dispute (starts at 13 minutes in):
https://www.spreaker.com/user/radiocable/lacafeterasosestibadores
http://container-mag.com/2017
http://container-mag.com/2017/02/28/spanish-port-strikes-set-march/
According to this CGT report (in Spanish) the first two strike days have been suspended, so I think that means the first strike will be on Friday:
http://estibadores.cgtvalencia.org/2017/03/el-gobierno-impone-servicios-minimos-de.html
.
A long interview (in Spanish) with a CNT dock worker from Barcelona (edit: from a union branch organising 'amarradores', I'm not sure of the correct translation but the workers dealing with mooring ships, as opposed to 'estibadores'. I take it they wouldn't normally be organised by the Coordinadora or have the same employers. I don't know how this corresponds to the way ports work in other countries):
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=LQuinFT8u2s
[youtube]LQuinFT8u2s[/youtube]
.
Local press report from Algeciras on solidarity shown by local Coordinadora dock workers to other struggles:
http://www.elestrecho.es/2017/03/los-estibadores-algecirenos-se-convierten-simbolo-la-lucha-obrera/
5 months without pay: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=N58zcAEUiWc
[youtube]N58zcAEUiWc[/youtube]
https://www.munz.org.nz/2017/
https://www.munz.org.nz/2017/02/09/war-on-the-wharves-spanish-dock-workers-fight-government-absolute-extinction-agenda/
http://www.nasaships.com/SitePages/NasaNews.aspx
Report on marxist.com:
Report on marxist.com:
https://www.marxist.com/spanish-dockers-strike-the-popular-party-destroys-the-rights-of-dockworkers-to-benefit-big-business.htm
Interview (in Spanish) with a
Interview (in Spanish) with a Coordinadora spokesperson from Gran Canaria, on the negotiations and the suspension of strike days this week:
http://www.coordinadora.org/noticias/nacional/14817-en-diez-anos-nos-hemos-bajado-el-sueldo-tres-veces-y-la-leche-cuesta-lo-mismo
Blog post (in Spanish) from a teacher in Valencia on 'why I support the dock workers and why you should too':
http://jsmutxamel.blogspot.co.uk/2017/03/por-que-apoyo-los-estibadores-y-por-que.html?m=1
TV report (in Spanish) from Cartagena, including support from Podemos:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CGTMk5d3S_8
[youtube]CGTMk5d3S_8[/youtube]
Time-lapse video of graffiti
Time-lapse video of graffiti art on a container at the port of Algeciras. The finished result is shown at the top of the Coordinadora facebook page, and also here.
¡Ni un paso atrás! https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=m2VPp3j5LAQ
[youtube]m2VPp3j5LAQ[/youtube]
.
Carnival in Algeciras: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=bR1QsS7ExHA
[youtube]bR1QsS7ExHA[/youtube]
.
The propaganda war: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VlGPfpjnIEs
[youtube]VlGPfpjnIEs[/youtube]
altemark wrote: Here is a
altemark
I've only just got round to watching this but really it's essential for understanding the history of dock workers' organisation in Spain. The current dispute is clearly just the latest round in a conflict that has carried on intermittently since the death of Franco.
Here's an academic paper on the Coordinadora from 1989:
Peter Waterman - Between the old international labour communications and the new: the Coordinadora of Spanish dockworkers
https://repub.eur.nl/pub/18927/wp61.pdf
Thanks for all these updates,
Thanks for all these updates, Mark!
The view from the UGT and
The view from the UGT and CCOO:
http://mail.statik.be/t/r-C664DA4285898E9A2540EF23F30FEDED
According to the marxist.org article above: "Union representation is held by the Coordinadora with 74%, UGT with 16%, CCOO with 8%, with smaller positions held by CGT, LAB, ELA, CIGA." LAB and ELA are Basque nationalist unions. I think CIGA is a Galician nationalist union.
The CGT Valencia dock workers site has reposted this article (in Spanish):
http://estibadores.cgtvalencia.org/2017/03/vientos-neoliberales-amenazan-la-estiba.html
Blog post (in Spanish) from a
Blog post (in Spanish) from a dock worker in Valencia:
https://mundoestiba.com/2017/03/04/ni-un-paso-atras/
On twitter: https://mobile.twitter.com/mundoestiba
Edit: there's a comment below the post from a dock worker employed on a different basis to the Coordinadora workers who says he earns three times less. There seem to be other workers in the ports with quite different wages and conditions who are not organised in the Coordinadora. I'm not sure how this works or how many people are involved.
Edit2: looking at the Coordinadora site I see they have a separate section for workers other than 'estibadores', and so they do at least aim to organise all workers in the ports:
http://www.coordinadora.org/trabajadores-ftp
Reuters report on the
Reuters report on the suspension of the first two strike days:
http://www.reuters.com/article/spain-ports-idUSL5N1GF79F
Article reposted by
Article reposted by Coordinadora (in Spanish) arguing that there are alternative ways to comply with EU legislation:
http://www.coordinadora.org/noticias/nacional/14829-cumplir-con-europa-es-obligatorio-pero-caben-otras-formas-de-cumplimiento
'A brutal reduction of costs' in the words of an enlightening report from a Spanish business and finance site. It suggests a possible, if unconfirmed, motive for the government's move in JP Morgan and others looking to offload their interests in Spanish ports to COSCO, the Chinese corporation already involved in Greek ports:
http://www.icnr.es/articulo/el-real-decreto-sobre-el-regimen-laboral-de-los-estibadores-apunta-a-una-brutal-reduccion-de-costes
I'm finding this hard to
I'm finding this hard to follow but it looks like the government has delayed attempts to get legislation passed until next week. I'm not sure what happens if it fails to get parliamentary support. It looks like the strike on Friday will still go ahead:
https://www.elestrechodigital.com/destacado/los-estibadores-aseguran-gobierno-margen-junio-aprobar-la-reforma-del-sector/
So that's strikes in all Spanish ports starting at 8.00 and working one hour on and one hour off through the day. Also a three hour stoppage in all European ports from 12.00 to 15.00, and a one hour stoppage in ports in the rest of the world.
Interview (in Spanish) with Coordinadora spokesperson Antolín Goya on Canary Islands TV: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=WqjuexMCO0s
[youtube]WqjuexMCO0s[/youtube]
.
Letter from a Barcelona dock worker (in Spanish):
http://diario16.com/familia-de-oxido-hierro-y-salitre/
Spanish goods face paralysis
Spanish goods face paralysis over dockers dispute
Solidarity rally at Spanish
Solidarity rally at Spanish Consulate San Francisco, Friday March 10
https://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2017/03/03/18796985.php
http://www.idcdockworkers.org
http://www.idcdockworkers.org/en/home/8-noticias/697-the-international-dockworkers-council-idc-goes-before-the-european-commission-and-withdraws-from-the-sectorial-social-dialogue-on-ports-2
I'm wondering a bit about the
I'm wondering a bit about the lack of response to this, both here and more widely on the English speaking left. I've seen a few articles from the left but not much. By contrast there's been plenty of business coverage from sites to do with shipping, logistics and so on, though some of it is fairly superficial. It's still possible that strikes will go ahead on Friday and the government will then back down or fail to get its legislation passed next week. If not then then the situation is serious all round. The dock workers can't really give in - if they did they wouldn't have much of a future. They handle most of Spain's imports and exports and there have already been talks between Coordinadora and the Canary Islands government about how the islands will be affected. Coordinadora has as far as I know been the main force behind setting up and running the IDC and I'd expect international support to hold up.
I suppose a comparison could be made with the Liverpool dockers dispute in the 90s but that involved 500 workers in one port, compared to over 6,000 workers across all Spanish ports. Coordinadora, incidentally, gave a lot of support to the Liverpool dockers, with contact originally made by an ex-DAM member through his Trades Council. If the PP government gets its legislation through and strikes continue then maybe we're looking at something more like the scale of the miners strike, but, I'd say, with a much better chance of a successful outcome. As to what people can do outside Spain the IDC has said that 'solidarity actions will also be scheduled for workers at various Spanish embassies around the world'. As the decisions being made are essentially political it may be that this kind of action will have some effect.
Any thoughts would be welcome.
Photos from demo in Algeciras
Photos from demo in Algeciras today:
https://mobile.twitter.com/Portuariosworld/status/839471936610709504/photo/1
https://mobile.twitter.com/Portuariosworld/status/839475429161463808
Report on the demo here:
https://www.elestrechodigital.com/destacado/algeciras-esta-estibadores/
Edit: another, more informative, report from Algeciras (in Spanish again). This points out that Algeciras accounts for something like a third of Spain's dock workers, and is a centre for the transfer of cargos between ships, business that could easily be lost to ports elsewhere. Here even the local PP are saying they oppose the government's position:
http://m.europasur.es/maritimas/portuarios-reivindican_0_1115888461.htm
The strikes on March 10, 13
The strikes on March 10, 13 and 15 have now been called off. The first strike is now scheduled for Friday March 17. Report in Spanish here:
http://www.ondacero.es/noticias/espana/estibadores-desconvocan-jornadas-huelga-dias-1013-marzo_2017030858c0668a0cf2600f3f57a388.html
Statement from Coordinadora:
https://www.facebook.com/CoordinadoraEstatalDeTrabajadoresDelMar/photos/a.597519247083648.1073741828.592517537583819/733245380177700/?type=3&theater
Edit: report from El País:
http://economia.elpais.com/economia/2017/03/08/actualidad/1489004113_241872.html
For now it looks like the government doesn't have the parliamentary support to get the bill passed, although this leaves the dock workers relying on some unlikely political allies. The first strike is now scheduled for the day after the parliamentary debate. I'm assuming that tomorrow's international stoppages have also been suspended but I haven't seen anything that actually confirms this.
Graffiti at the southern
Graffiti at the southern entrance to the port of Barcelona:
"Ni un paso atrás CNT - CETM - IDC" ("Not one step back")
https://mobile.twitter.com/PortuariosCNT/status/839774641866559488
Photos - dock workers
Photos - dock workers gathering today to support student protests. I think this is in Algeciras:
https://mobile.twitter.com/Portuariosworld/status/839776552543977473
Also in Tarragona:
https://mobile.twitter.com/estibaverdader/status/839813382886866945
https://mobile.twitter.com/estibaverdader/status/839775119937515521
In other cities, including Barcelona and Almería:
https://mobile.twitter.com/SoyCoordinadora/status/839810361230524417
Bilbao:
https://mobile.twitter.com/ni300dst/status/839874795307155456
Quote: I'm assuming that
Confirmed here: ETF-ITC-IDC statement on the situation in Spanish ports
http://www.leftvoice.org/Over
http://www.leftvoice.org/Over-Six-Thousand-Spanish-Dockworkers-Jobs-Face-the-Axe
http://www.leftvoice.org/Span
http://www.leftvoice.org/Spanish-and-International-Unions-Strike-to-Defend-Spanish-Dockworkers
Article from a Spanish
Article from a Spanish shipping site on the state of negotiations. Considering that this is business journalism it's interesting to see how damning it is about the government's position.
http://www.naucher.com/es/actualidad/la-rigidez-del-gobierno-que-impide-el-acuerdo-en-a-estiba-mientras-los-puertos-crecen/_n:6093/
Some more business
Some more business journalism, this time pointing out the benefits of the government proposals to the balance sheets of investment funds with an interest in Spanish ports. JP Morgan and a possible sale are mentioned here (headline: "JP Morgan are rubbing their hands..."). A benefit to a few investment funds isn't the same thing as a benefit to the wider economy, and certainly not to the local economies of some of the port cities where the loss of large numbers of relatively well paid jobs can be expected to hit other business interests. This may help to explain some of the support for dockworkers from what on the face of it look like unlikely sources.
http://www.elconfidencial.com/espana/comunidad-valenciana/2017-02-17/jp-morgan-naotum-ports-estibadores-reforma-plusvalias_1333299/
An article from the same site
An article from the same site on investment funds with interests in ports lobbying in support of the government proposals. Headline: "War in the ports. The bosses want to cut the pay of dockworkers by 60%".
http://www.elconfidencial.com/espana/comunidad-valenciana/2017-02-08/inversores-portuarios-lobby-liberalizacion-estibadores-recorte-salarial_1328122/
Drawing by the daughter of a
Drawing by the daughter of a dockworker from Huelva
https://mobile.twitter.com/ana1981ole/status/840294143406538753/photo/1
Video about the IDC - the
Video about the IDC - the International Dockworkers Council - in English, Spanish and French. Watch on youtube for English subtitles.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xgTUWGl2FmY
[youtube]xgTUWGl2FmY[/youtube]
.
The IDC and Spanish dockworkers
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cLPOYxClsfY
[youtube]cLPOYxClsfY[/youtube]
Mark, appreciate the updates!
Mark, appreciate the updates!
Interview with Miguel
Interview with Miguel Rodriguez from the Coordinadora (in Spanish)
http://deverdaddigital.com/articulo/21377/estibadores-orgullo-unidad-y-lucha
Portuguese dockworkers ban
Portuguese dockworkers ban work on ships diverted from Spanish ports between March 20 and April 3 (report in Portuguese)
https://www.publico.pt/2017/03/09/economia/noticia/estivadores-decretam-greve-aos-navios-desviados-de-espanha-1764588
Getting the message across to
Getting the message across to the European Commission:
https://mobile.twitter.com/jordiaragunde/status/839849042783924225
I'm not on twitter myself but anyone who is may want to retweet this.
Dockworkers linking up with
Dockworkers linking up with taxi drivers, transport workers and other groups with ongoing conflicts. I think this initiative may just be in Barcelona but I'm not sure.
http://cronicaglobal.elespanol.com/business/estibadores-taxistas-intersindicatos-plataforma-combate_69450_102.html
Article from a Spanish
Article from a Spanish leftist site about the postponement of strike action, with some criticism of Coordinadora tactics, including from dockworkers in the FSOC - the Frente Sindical Obrero de Canarias. I've no particular position on this and I can't say I understand much about the disagreements between the different unions.
http://www.izquierdadiario.es/La-Internacional-Estibadora-posterga-el-plan-de-lucha?id_rubrique=2653
Report on the postponement of
Report on the postponement of strike action from portstrategy.com
("insight for senior port executives")
Europe-wide strike action delayed
TV report from Algeciras,
TV report from Algeciras, Spain's largest port, on Canal Sur (in Spanish). The first nine minutes of the video deals with the dispute and what working in the docks now involves. Coordinadora get the chance to put their case. The employers' organisation Anesco declined to take part.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=nSThBt6YZtQ
[youtube]nSThBt6YZtQ[/youtube]
Pipe Díaz - Ni un paso atrás
Pipe Díaz - Ni un paso atrás (#SOSESTIBA)
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Tt_fOLzqkKA
[youtube]Tt_fOLzqkKA[/youtube]
.
Pipe Díaz on facebook
Blog post from a dockworker
Blog post from a dockworker in Valencia
Carta de agradecimiento al comité
Report from Las Palmas paper
Report from Las Palmas paper La Provincia on myths about dockworkers
https://www.facebook.com/groups/estibadoreslaspalmas/permalink/1894792937423864/
Dockworkers in Sweden The
Dockworkers in Sweden
The APMT Gothenburg dispute. Watch on youtube for English subtitles.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Bt03FpimA5M
[youtube]Bt03FpimA5M[/youtube]
.
flyer on the dispute: http://hamn.nu/assets/files/English_Colour.pdf
From 'O Estivador' the blog
From 'O Estivador' the blog of the Portuguese dockworkers union, the Sindicato dos Estivadores e da Actividade Logística
https://oestivador.wordpress.com/2017/03/09/estivadores-decretam-greve-aos-navios-desviados-de-espanha-traducao-em-frances-e-ingles/
Interview in Portuguese with Lisbon dockworkers leader António Mariano on the formation of SEAL as a new national union:
https://ionline.sapo.pt/artigo/547378/antonio-mariano-so-um-sindicato-nacional-pode-combater-por-melhores-condicoes-de-trabalho-?seccao=Portugal_i
(No subject)
Blog post from a dockworker
Blog post from a dockworker in Algeciras
Comida con amigos…
Roughly translated: "...today is Monday, another Monday of uncertainty, another week of stress and doubts, doubts about whether the opposition parties which up to now have supported the Spanish dockworkers will continue with the NO to the decree, doubts about whether it will finally be put to the vote this week, or if the Minister will carry on stringing things out to see if some party starts to feel the pressure they're putting on. Doubts about the future of our way of life and the consequences these gentlemen can lead us to..."
Article in Spanish on
Article in Spanish on dockworkers struggles during the transition, from 1976 to 1986
Las luchas obreras autónomas en los puertos durante la transición
Also this radio broadcast
http://anabasis.radioqk.org/110-lucha-autonoma-en-el-puerto-de-barcelona-1976-1986/
Article on the current
Article on the current dispute, also from the March issue of Todo Por Hacer
Si paramos, se paran los puertos
Report from a shipping site
Report from a shipping site on the state of negotiations (in Spanish). In summary Iñigo de la Serna, the minister responsible, is still hoping to get the PSOE to vote with the government on Thursday morning. The PSOE abstaining would be enough for the decree to be passed. He's offered assurances that jobs would still be secure, without any real explanation as to how this would work. The European Commission has indicated that there's still time to negotiate. In the opinion of the journalist; "Hay tiempo y este compromiso es algo que los grupos de la oposición deben tener my claro antes de creer las mentiras del ministerio." ~ "There's time and this commitment is something the opposition groups should be very clear about before they believe the lies from the ministry." Given this kind of coverage it may be hard at this point for any of the opposition parties to be seen to be backing the government.
http://www.naucher.com/es/actualidad/reves-de-la-comision-europea-al-ministerio-de-fomento-en-el-conflicto-de-la-estiba/_n:6114/
Press statement (in Spanish) from the Coordinadora, rejecting assurances from de la Serna.
http://www.coordinadora.org/noticias/coordinadora-cetm/14883-esta-semana-no-habra-acuerdo-en-la-estiba-porque-el-gobierno-no-ha-convocado-la-mesa-de-negociacion-solicitada-por-patronal-y-trabajadores
Report on the dispute and interview with Coordinadora president Antolín Goya from Canary Islands TV.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=NFPUYaD1uCw
[youtube]NFPUYaD1uCw[/youtube]
Article (in Spanish) on
Article (in Spanish) on solidarity among dockworkers, giving some historical background.
Lo extraño de los estibadores
This report suggests the
This report suggests the decree could be passed by 174 votes to 173, depending on last minute political deals and which deputies are out of the country or ill.
http://politica.elpais.com/politica/2017/03/15/actualidad/1489564931_656062.html
Press statement from Coordinadora on the government's latest manoeuvres.
http://www.coordinadora.org/noticias/14-cabecera/14890-estupefaccion-entre-los-estibadores-ante-el-anuncio-del-ministro-sobre-la-participacion-de-fomento-en-la-reunion-tecnica-a-la-que-no-estan-convocados-los-representantes-de-los-trabajadores
The decree is now being
The decree is now being debated in Congress, dockworkers in the public gallery. Three opposition deputies flew back from New York overnight to vote. Updates in Spanish on twitter: https://mobile.twitter.com/mundoestiba
Photo: dockworkers following the debate in Algeciras
Coordinadora twitter feed:
Coordinadora twitter feed: https://mobile.twitter.com/SoyCoordinadora
It's still going on but it
It's still going on but it looks clear that the government is going to lose the vote.
Report from El País
Following the debate in
Following the debate in Algeciras:
https://mobile.twitter.com/Portuariosworld/status/842333492226727939
Report updated a couple of
Report updated a couple of days ago. It isn't great but it's in English.
Spanish dockers rebel over EU port liberalization
I've been looking for English language coverage of today's debate and vote and haven't found anything despite its importance. I'm wondering if this is partly because it doesn't fit easily into a pre-existing media narrative. It will be interesting to see what reports come out later.
The government has lost the
The government has lost the vote:
https://mobile.twitter.com/Juanmi_News/status/842352598854299649/video/1
Yes 142, No 175, Abstentions 33
https://mobile.twitter.com/MLSCH17/status/842346064921407489/photo/1
Report from El País: El
Report from El País:
El Gobierno fracasa y no logra convalidar el decreto de los estibadores
Apparently this is the first time a decree has been voted down by Congress since 1979. The government got the support of the Basque nationalist PNV but the liberal right Ciudadanos abstained after saying last night that they would vote with the government.
Other Spanish media reports:
El Congreso tumba el decreto de reforma de la estiba
Los estibadores desconvocan los paros tras el rechazo del Congreso a la reforma del sector
Photos: press conference
Photos: press conference outside Congress
https://mobile.twitter.com/SoyCoordinadora/status/842352992972075009
Reactions from the dockworkers inside:
https://mobile.twitter.com/SoyCoordinadora/status/842366935790702592
https://mobile.twitter.com/SoyCoordinadora/status/842367267874721792
Statement from
Statement from Coordinadora
The strikes scheduled for tomorrow and for alternate days next week have been called off and negotiations will continue.
Reaction on
Reaction on twitter:
https://mobile.twitter.com/JaviViadero/status/842358493021671424
Roughly: 'You can carry on criticising the dockworkers, or you can take them as an example. That's going to be a way to tell the difference between the dickheads and the rest of the people.'
Photo: dockworkers in
Photo: dockworkers in Congress
Reuters
Reuters report:
http://in.reuters.com/article/spain-ports-idINL5N1GT41T
I've posted a short news
I've posted a short news report on today's vote:
https://libcom.org/news/spanish-government-loses-vote-dockworkers-employment-reform-16032017
Blog post on today's
Blog post on today's vote:
https://mundoestiba.com/2017/03/16/el-dia-de-iniesta/
Barcelona Sants railway
Barcelona Sants railway station today:
https://mobile.twitter.com/ierrejon/status/842427743199465473
https://mobile.twitter.com/Sonia_Farre/status/842415409957601280/video/1
Article from a Spanish
Article from a Spanish leftist site that makes some good points before losing me towards the end with the writer's political project.
Estibadores: el Sí Se Puede de la clase obrera
It starts off by pointing out that just the threat of a strike was enough for the government decree to be voted down. This simply wouldn't have happened without the muscle of the dockworkers and the threat of a major conflict.
Watching the vote in
Watching the vote in Algeciras:
https://mobile.twitter.com/romerito1462/status/842458682130612225/video/1
Analysing an editorial on the
Analysing an editorial on the vote in El País:
https://mobile.twitter.com/_ju1_/status/842525870074093568
AP report: Spain's government
AP report:
Spain's government faces setback in reforming labor in ports
From today's Journal of
From today's Journal of Commerce:
[quote=JoC]Spanish dockworkers call off remaining strikes
Bruce Barnard, Special Correspondent | Mar 16, 2017
The Spanish dockworkers’ union on Thursday canceled the remaining four days of a nine-day strike campaign after the government failed to win parliamentary support for reforms of the country’s dock labor system.
The strikes, which would have involved dockworkers stopping work every other hour, were due to take place on March 17, 20, 22, and 24.
The CMT union had earlier canceled five days of strikes while it held negotiations with the terminal operators and stevedores’ organization Anesco.
The minority Popular Party government’s planned reform was in response to a European Court ruling in December 2014 that the country’s dock labor system, which is run by local union controlled port pools, breaches EU rules on the freedom of establishment.
Spain was fined 15.6 million euros ($16.7 million) last July for failing to comply with the court’s ruling and faces a daily penalty of 134,000 euros until it carries out the reforms.
The draft reform would dismantle the union’s monopoly over the hiring of dockworkers across the Spanish waterfront and free port employers to hire non-union labor and remove the obligation to be paying members of the local dock pools.
The dockworkers’ union said it is prepared to start “serious and rigorous” negotiations with all parties, including employers and the government, to reach a consensus on responding to the Luxembourg court’s ruling.
The government has said it must comply with the court’s ruling and proposed a three-year transition for the reformed labor system to come into effect in a bid to win parliamentary support and meet some of the concerns of the union, which claims the reform will result in up to 7,000 job losses.
The government has not said how it will respond to the failure to obtain parliamentary approval for its planned reform.
[/quote]
Today's front
Today's front pages:
https://mobile.twitter.com/estibacanaria/status/842664543792873472/photo/1
More video clips from
More video clips from Barcelona yesterday:
https://mobile.twitter.com/PortuariosCNT/status/842368291863683073
https://mobile.twitter.com/ATLNTCBCNETA/status/842476873632432129
Edit: also this clip. I'm sure where it's from:
https://mobile.twitter.com/Jlbdocker/status/842441547782189056/video/1
Photos from Algeciras with
Photos from Algeciras with the new t-shirt:
https://mobile.twitter.com/Portuariosworld/status/842934251091906561
https://mobile.twitter.com/romerito1462/status/842946466327003136
Statement from the CNT
Statement from the CNT Amarradores del Puerto de Barcelona union branch in support of the Coordinadora in its conflict with the government (in Spanish):
Comunicado de nuestra Sección ante los últimos acontecimientos en el conflicto de la estiba
Some responses from Coordinadora members:
https://mobile.twitter.com/PortuariosCNT/status/843189032662319105
Also:
https://mobile.twitter.com/crisalidaliquid/status/843192202058780672
https://mobile.twitter.com/berflowersta/status/843197577227132930
Article in support of the
Article in support of the dockworkers by a former port worker (in Spanish):
Los puertos en lucha. Los portuarios otra vez…
Blog post on the media
Blog post on the media campaign against the dockworkers (in Spanish):
Desmontando la sucia y rastrera campaña para criminalizar a los estibadores
A brief summary in English of
A brief summary in English of the legal and other issues in the dispute:
http://www.nepia.com/media/641056/CIRCULAR-Stevedore-Strike-Action-March-2017.pdf
Poster for a rally in Sydney
Poster for a rally in Sydney to support Spanish dockworkers. I don't actually know if this is still going ahead or whether it has been called off along with this week's strikes.
https://mobile.twitter.com/jordiaragunde/status/843399476022841345/photo/1
This report confirms that the
This report confirms that the IDC have called off the international actions planned for March 23:
Desconvocadas las movilizaciones de la estiba mundial ante el inicio de las negociaciones en España
A Guerra dos Portos | The War
A Guerra dos Portos | The War of Ports - video produced in 2014 by Portuguese dockworkers - interviews with dockworkers from various European countries on the attacks they are facing from employers, states and the EU. Watching this helps put the dispute in Spain in perspective, with a dockworker from Valencia predicting that what was happening in Portugal and other European countries would also happen in Spain. Subtitles in English and Portuguese.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=oKRJ5k1N4dM
[youtube]oKRJ5k1N4dM[/youtube]
.
Report on the 2013-2014 dispute in Lisbon:
.
In the Face of Austerity, Portuguese Dockers Win Back Union Jobs
December 19, 2014 / Katy Fox-Hodess
In a time of global economic crisis, many unions feel they have no choice but to focus on just minimizing concessions.
But dockworkers in Lisbon, Portugal, who refused to follow suit have garnered widespread support—setting an example of how organized workers can use solidarity to resist austerity. With a crucial assist from dockworkers in Spain and elsewhere, they won reinstatement of their fired, non-union co-workers.
Portugal has been among the European countries hit hardest by the crisis. Unemployment has reached Depression-era levels, climbing past 40 percent for younger workers.
Making matters worse, in exchange for bailouts to national governments, the “Troika” of the European Central Bank, European Commission, and International Monetary Fund has demanded privatization, deregulation, weakened labor standards, and massive cuts to social programs.
In the name of stimulating the economy and cutting costs, longtime social rights and benefits have been severely eroded. For example, the number of hours in the workweek has increased. So has the retirement age. And the number of national holidays recognized annually has been reduced by four.
Average wages in Portugal, which already had the lowest minimum wage in Western Europe, have fallen dramatically. Legislation passed during the crisis has undermined unions’ ability to negotiate contracts. The numbers of collective bargaining agreements and of union members have declined significantly.
Assault by the Banks
The Portuguese government’s May 2011 memorandum of understanding with the Troika called for an array of legislative measures targeting working people.
Most relevant for the dockworkers was a provision to narrow the definition of dock labor (shrinking the group of workers who get extra protections beyond those in the general labor law) and to impose other anti-labor measures benefiting port employers. The target date for implementation was January 2012.
After legislation was introduced to carry out these changes, nearly all Portugal’s ports struck in protest, delaying the law’s passage well past the target date.
The International Dockworkers Council, one of two international organizations of European dockworkers (the other is the European Transport Workers Federation, ETF), organized a November 2012 protest that brought hundreds of workers to Lisbon for the largest pan-European dockworker protest in several years. It sent a strong message of unity to the employer, the government, and the Troika.
But the law eventually got through at the end of 2012, and went into effect in February 2013. The dockworkers began negotiating a new collective bargaining agreement, which now had to be in compliance with the new anti-union law.
Dockworkers Sacked
At the beginning of 2013, 18 casual dockworkers from the Lisbon union pool were dismissed.
This followed the new law’s revised definition of which jobs were part of the union labor pool—though it violated the contract still in place at the time. In July, another 29 additional casual dockworkers were dismissed. The union believed the employers had dismissed the 47 workers as part of a long-term strategy to create labor scarcity, in order to justify the creation of a second non-union labor pool at the port.
The employers tried to bring in scabs, so the union decided to shift its own strategy. In Lisbon the dockworkers moved toward “protection strikes”—meaning they only stopped work when scabs were brought in, and the maximum they stopped per day was four hours.
Protection strikes were a legal means for the dockworkers to prevent scabs from working the ships. For a time the strike threats dissuaded the employers from following through, but at the end of year, they succeeded in bringing in scab labor.
Despite the fact that the casuals are not members of the union, reinstating the 47 casual dockworkers employed through the union labor pool became the Lisbon dockworkers’ union’s rallying cry. The union also demanded:
that the new non-union labor pool not be permitted to grow beyond the 21 workers already employed
that those workers have the option of being integrated into the union pool after a new collective bargaining agreement was negotiated
that the employers drop a lawsuit they had filed against the union for damages during the strikes
and that the government agree to help mediate, and extend the contract negotiations until September 2014.
All year, the union dockworkers financially supported the dismissed casual workers so that they could continue to fight for their jobs and not have to find other work. The campaign to reinstate the fired workers became an important factor in garnering public support for the union.
Working with the Unemployed
Meanwhile, outside official union channels, a group of rank-and-file members of the Lisbon union had formed an activist organization, Estivadores Solidariedade (Dockworker Solidarity). These were members who felt their leaders weren’t doing enough to prevent the law from being implemented.
In particular, they wanted to reach out to the broader community, to counteract the employer/media message that privileged workers were disrupting the ports for their own narrow interests. They began working with others who were inspired by their fight, including social movement organizations of unemployed workers, rank-and-file railway workers, nurses, and call center workers.
The group set up a Facebook page and retained a left-wing activist as its communications specialist—both helpful in combating the media disinformation campaign against them. The Facebook page also became a way to make direct contact with rank-and-file dockworkers in other countries. These rank-and-filers sent messages of support, made plans to participate in the November protest in Lisbon, and built solidarity efforts in their local ports.
Some of the Estivadores Solidariedade activists ran for union office in 2013, on a platform of social justice unionism, and won.
The outside support bolstered the dockworkers’ resolve as they faced the very difficult situation inside the port. Contract negotiations dragged on; progress was very slow.
Spanish Workers Refuse Scab Cargo
As the law’s February 2014 deadline approached, the dockworkers resumed their strikes. International allies stepped up support too. Dockworker unions affiliated with both federations participated in a February 4 European Day of Action, holding stop-work meetings at the ports and sending delegations to Portuguese embassies and consulates.
The most significant international action was taken at the Port of Algeciras by La Coordinadora, the Spanish dockworkers union. Algeciras is a major transshipment port at the Strait of Gibraltar. It was February when the first ship loaded entirely by scabs in Lisbon—the Samaria, operated by a Maersk subcontractor—reached Algeciras, its first port of call.
While the ship was being loaded, the Lisbon dockworkers had recorded a video to document the fact that the poorly prepared scabs had taken seven days to load the ship—compared with the one day it would typically take the union workers.
The badly loaded ship posed a safety hazard to dockworkers who would handle the cargo at subsequent ports. Cargo that has not been properly secured creates the risk of serious injury or even fatality.
La Coordinadora stopped the ship at Algeciras and issued the captain what the Portuguese dockworkers called a “yellow card.” Citing safety concerns, they warned that they would refuse to unload any ships loaded by scabs in Lisbon.
The ship’s captain communicated this message to Maersk, one of the largest shipping line operators in the world. Maersk sent a letter to the Portuguese stevedoring companies, informing them it didn’t want any of its ships loaded by the Lisbon scabs.
A major breakthrough was reached shortly thereafter.
Momentum across Europe
In a meeting mediated by the Portuguese Ministry of Transport and attended by an IDC representative, the employers agreed that the fired dockworkers would be reinstated, the second pool would not be permitted to grow beyond the 21 already employed, and those workers would have the option of being integrated into the union pool after a new collective bargaining agreement was negotiated. The employers’ lawsuit against the union for damages during the strikes was dropped.
The government agreed to help mediate the contract negotiations. Those negotiations were extended until September and then again until the end of the year. They are making slow but steady process towards a contract.
A joint IDC-ETF meeting in March, which had been planned to coordinate solidarity for Lisbon, turned into a celebration and a discussion of other issues facing European dockworkers. There was a strong sense that the Lisbon victory had provided greater momentum to address the needs of other Portuguese dockworkers (particularly in Aveiro), the long-standing dispute at the Port of Piraeus in Greece, and a dispute in Norway.
Katy Fox-Hodess is a doctoral student in sociology at the University of California, Berkeley. She thanks Antonio Mariano and Sergio Sousa of the Sindicato dos Estivadores in Lisbon for their help with this article.
Blog post from a dockworker
Blog post from a dockworker in Tarragona:
Privilegiado sí, pero…
Interview with Jordi Aragunde
Interview with Jordi Aragunde from the Coordinadora and IDC about dockworkers' struggles in Spain and internationally. This is from 2014 but it's still relevant.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5LbMYXeRElM
[youtube]5LbMYXeRElM[/youtube]
Protest organised by Lisbon
Protest organised by Lisbon dockworkers in June 2016.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=AA59lbDFCNw
[youtube]AA59lbDFCNw[/youtube]
.
.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=80pS9u1HUoE
[youtube]80pS9u1HUoE[/youtube]
.
Andy Green from Tilbury speaking in Sines in January 2016:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=oJJBmcAJPNE
[youtube]oJJBmcAJPNE[/youtube]
.
Marc Storms from Antwerp speaking at the same conference in Sines:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wwdbx7pxzOw
[youtube]wwdbx7pxzOw[/youtube]
.
Labour historian Raquel Varela speaking in Sines:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Kmw6dJjNKO8
[youtube]Kmw6dJjNKO8[/youtube]
.
Blog post (in Portuguese) by Raquel Varela on Spanish dispute. Also here.
Negotiations resumed today -
Negotiations resumed today - twitter thread in Spanish that isn't optimistic about the outcome:
https://mobile.twitter.com/mundoestiba/status/844203115905736705
https://mobile.twitter.com/mundoestiba/status/844284527061159937
One suggestion here is that the government side is looking to get parliamentary support back rather than negotiate seriously with the dockworkers.
Report (in Spanish) on
Report (in Spanish) on yesterday's negotiations:
http://www.europasur.es/maritimas/subrogacion-estibadores-principal-escollo-acuerdo_0_1119788120.html
Coordinadora meeting in Madrid today to discuss the negotiations:
https://mobile.twitter.com/SoyCoordinadora/status/844491154628390913
Coordinadora press
Coordinadora press statement:
¿Garantía de empleo para los estibadores o no?
Hey really useful thread Mark
Hey really useful thread Mark
Was it a Mick Parkins (?) who
Was it a Mick Parkins (?) who wrote a pamphlet on the dockers and the Coordinadora. He was host of CNT postal section visiting Edinburgh and Glasgow mail centres (EH had just had a walk-out so she witnessed our strike meeting) a couple of decades ago and i also hold a vague memory of him explaining that all that recallable bits in constitutions have proven meaningless since he knew of no occasion that it was ever evoked
ajjohnstone wrote: Was it a
ajjohnstone
That sounds quite possible but I can't remember seeing the pamphlet and it doesn't seem to be online anywhere. Edit: Mick Parkin gets a mention in this report on the 1997 CGT congress in the context of organising a visit by Liverpool dockers to speak to CGT and Coordinadora dockworkers:
https://libcom.org/library/1997-cgt-conference-spain
fingers malone wrote: Hey
fingers malone
Thanks. I'm still surprised that the dispute hasn't attracted more attention outside Spain. I'm not sure what the PP government are trying to do but it looks as if they may be aiming to force a confrontation and a strike. I don't really see what they expect to gain from it though. Maybe I'm missing something.
Articles about the
Articles about the Coordinadora written by Stan Weir in the 80s
(pages 151-163):
https://libcom.org/library/singlejack-solidarity-stan-weir
Raquel Varela - Why dock
Raquel Varela - Why dock workers can change the world
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=1paOv1xdwQY
[youtube]1paOv1xdwQY[/youtube]
As far as I'm concerned and
As far as I'm concerned and because of the essence of the Spanish right, the PP never gives its arm to twist if it is not for a social conflict, strike or pressure on the street.
If I am not mistaken, the PP tries to follow a neoliberal policy in the naval sector. Liberalize and outsource functions, subcontract and precarious working conditions. It tries to damage 2000 of a total of 7000 workers in the naval sector and promises that it will maintain the 5000 jobs. This question has never been fulfilled since the Spanish naval reconversion of the 1980s and 1990s, adding that working conditions will worsen.
Mick Parkins....another
Mick Parkins....another winner
This is an interesting
This is an interesting interview with Ana Corrales, a dock worker in Barcelona. It's more about her personal experience, both in terms of working conditions and what it's like being a woman in what is still a male dominated workplace. I'll try and post something about what she says when I have time.
“No es ningún secreto. Estas son las condiciones en las que trabajamos”
Another article along the
Another article along the same lines on the experiences of four dockworkers in different Spanish ports. The pay of dockworkers seems to be a contentious issue, with some apparently exaggerated claims being made of average annual earnings of over €60,000. No one is disputing that they are well paid but the figures given for the individuals interviewed for this article are all significantly lower; Daniel Miguel (Bilbao) €30,000-40,000, Rosa Dilla (Barcelona) under €40,000, Santiago Medina (Gran Canaria) under €40,000, Esther Lázaro (Valencia) under €50,000. Dockworkers' earnings are variable and depend very much on how busy the ports are. Earnings at smaller, quieter ports are likely to be significantly lower than these figures. This is all for shift work which is potentially quite dangerous. Beyond this I haven't seen anything that I'd really consider to be a reliable source on average earnings, despite the figures repeatedly quoted in different articles.
Retrato de la estiba: el conflicto de los estibadores en cuatro esquinas de España
Edit: report from Cartagena, one of the smaller ports.
No somos unos privilegiados ni tenemos 'supersueldos'
Barcelona dockworkers
Barcelona dockworkers banner:
https://mobile.twitter.com/Dockers_ES/status/846874610259939328/photo/1
Interview with a dockworker
Interview with a dockworker from Almería:
Entrevista a Gabriel Sánchez, estibador del puerto de Almería
It´s in catalá but with
It´s in catalá but with google translate I think that is easy understand.
https://directa.cat/chicharra-assemblea-motor-de-lluita
I struggle with Catalan, but
I struggle with Catalan, but that's a useful article. It does suggest that the Coordinadora have managed to counteract some of the negative effects of the works committee system by maintaining weekly mass meetings and ensuring committee members continue with their usual work rather than turning into union full timers. The article is mainly about the port of Barcelona where all the committee members are Coordinadora. I suspect this may help to keep the works committee system in check, and that one of the problems for other radical unions that take part in works committee elections (the CGT and other smaller unions, but not the CNT) is that they are rarely in the majority, with the wider workforce being left without much direct control over the activity of the committees.
Academic article from
Academic article from 2011:
Mònica Clua-Losada - Trading solidarity: dockworkers and the EU liberalisation of port services
rtve radio broadcasts:
Spanish Dock Workers (I) - 30/03/17
Spanish Dock Workers II - Contexts - 31/03/17
Mònica Clua-Losada's dissertation on the Liverpool dockers dispute:
http://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/1137/1/thesis_MCL_2010.pdf
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rR3DrE1DJtc
[youtube]rR3DrE1DJtc[/youtube]
Some old videos from the
Some old videos from the Coordinadora youtube channel:
30 años de Coordinadora Estatal de Estibadores Portuarios
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=50RdEL93UO8
[youtube]50RdEL93UO8[/youtube]
.
Canción de los Estibadores Portuarios
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rLfpD-UAfNw
[youtube]rLfpD-UAfNw[/youtube]
Mark. wrote: Article from a
Mark.
Here's an English translation from the Left Voice site. The original article from Izquierda Diario was published on the day the decree was voted down.
Dockworkers: the “can do” of the working class
Editor’s note - March 16 saw the Spanish parliament vote against the Royal Decree Law that sought to scrap the country’s port labor system. The decree put forward by the conservative Partido Popular (PP - People’s Party) government was voted down - 175 votes against, 142 in favor and 33 abstentions. Crucially, 32 of these abstentions came from the center-right Ciudadanos (Citizens) party that helps to prop up the minority Partido Popular government. This vote is the first time in nearly four decades that a royal decree has been rejected by the Spanish parliament.
The simple threat of a strike was enough to ensure the overturning of the anti-worker Royal Decree Law drawn up by conservative leader Mariano Rajoy. The “no” vote was not just a blow for the current Partido Popular government but also for the EU Court of Justice and its threat of sanctions.
One of the most concentrated, unionized and coordinated sectors of the labor movement has flexed its “muscle”, which this time round was enough to stop the parties of the post-Franco regime from voting for the “national interest” as they have done in the past. The threat of a strike was not only to have economical consequences - an estimated potential loss of 50 million Euros a day - but also political consequences. The flexing of this political “muscle” raised the specter of a big labor dispute taking center stage in Spain, one that could potentially recreate the solidarity and militancy of the Spanish coal miners’ dispute of 2012 and direct this at all those who voted “yes”. This is a scenario that the social-democratic Partido Socialista Obrero Español (PSOE - Spanish Socialist Workers’ Party) fears as it enters its worst crisis in recent history.
If anything, what this demonstrates is that - despite all the skepticism about social mobilization and all the illusions in “storming heaven” through institutional means – determined class struggle is the way to defeat a government and the European institutions which shield its anti-labor policies. But not only that, it is also the way to open up the opportunity to bring the “democracy of the IBEX35” (the Spanish stock exchange) to an end and impose a program that makes the capitalists pay for the crisis.
As the media have pointed out, parliament’s rejection of the Royal Decree Law is historic. It has only happened twice since 1979, and one of these was by accident. Not only that, but among the “no” voters were key social-democratic PSOE deputies. These deputies belong to the same “socialist” party that, under pressure from the European Union (EU) and the financial markets, amended Article 135 of the Spanish Constitution in 2011 to ensure budget stability; that introduced a series of austerity measures in 2010 at the behest of the ‘Troika’ of the European Commission, European Central Bank and International Monetary Fund; that implemented the industrial reconversion process in the 1980s that closed down and sold off much of the country’s state-owned enterprises at the EU’s request ... if anyone knows anything about offloading economic crisis onto the strategic sectors of the labor movement, it is the “socialists” of the PSOE. Nevertheless, the dockworkers have taken advantage of the current crisis affecting this political pillar of the regime and shown that they could twist its arm and force it to vote “no”.
There is no doubt that the attacks on the dockworkers are far from over. Now the “cavalry” will come from the EU capital of Brussels; the media campaign against these so-called “privileged workers” will start again ... and the last word has not been spoken. Nevertheless, there are some interesting lessons that can be drawn from this first victory that go well beyond just the dockworkers.
Since 2014 we have seen the imposition of a new “common sense”, one that has been fueled by the rise of the neo-reformism of political parties such as Podemos (We Can), one that suggests that social mobilization is incapable of finishing off a rotten regime and the policies it uses to unload the crisis onto the majority of the population. This new “common sense” suggests that the key is to take the movement off the streets and into the electoral arena. Through these electoral projects, these forces would fight for social, political and economic reform with the idea of taking hold of government institutions and using them to make social change.
After nearly three years, the growth of various parliamentary groups for “change”, beginning with the 71 Congress deputies of Unidos Podemos (United We Can) and its allies*, has seen these forces take hold of a number of important municipalities and legislative bodies. However, their political practice is very different from what has been promised. In the municipalities of “change”, government debt is paid religiously, demands such as remunicipalización (taking previously privatized entities back into public hands) are abandoned and either their minority status or the existing legal framework is used to justify their refusal to take effective measures to end unemployment, evictions or energy poverty. In the Congress and the regional parliaments, they allow themselves to make very left-wing speeches and come out in support of existing mobilizations such as those of the dockworkers, but they do not propose one single measure of struggle or organization that would help to implement concrete measures against major social problems.
The dockworkers have shown us that just flexing their “muscle”, without even having to put their fighting ability into action has, to date, managed to overcome both the problem of the parliamentary majority - 268 of the 350 deputies are from neoliberal formations that have turned obedience to the EU into a dogma - and the threats from Brussels. It has not been the threat of strike action alone that has achieved this, for the division among the employers and especially the conditions of open crisis in the regime and its political agents have undoubtedly played a role. But this critical situation is not an exceptional one, for it has in fact been the norm since 2011. What dockworkers have demonstrated is that there is another way to occupy the electoral space.
You have to wonder about what we could achieve if the reformist left, which speaks of “change” and even of “returning to the streets”, started demanding that trade union leaders end their criminal policies of compromise and social peace? What could we impose on the parties of the regime if the reformist left took advantage of their positions and called for the organization and mobilization of workers, young people and women?
Examples arise by the dozen. The municipalities of “change” say that they cannot take privatized firms back into public hands because they are in a minority, or that if they generate quality public employment, then Partido Popular Finance Minister Cristóbal Montoro will audit them. Both things are as true as the fact that the EU Court of Justice will sanction the Spanish government if Rajoy cannot get his ‘reforms’ to the port labor system approved. Then what should be done? Resign yourself as local mayors for change such as Manuela Carmena (Madrid), Ada Colau (Barcelona), Pedro Santiesteve (Zaragoza) and José María “Kichi” González (Cádiz) have done? Or, on the contrary, prepare a great movement that fights to impose its demands on the politicians that serve big business and their courts, just like the dockworkers have done?
The same can be said of the parliamentary work of Podemos. As Pablo Iglesias himself says, in the Courts you can draw up little more than proposals that do not become law. But why is it that in over one year as a deputy, he has not called for a mobilization, or an assembly, or demanded that the union bureaucracy moves a finger ... for an increase in the official minimum wage, for the repeal of various labor ‘reforms’ or the nationalization of the criminal energy sector?
The dockworkers have shown us what they think of the new “common sense”, fueled as it is by the reformism of “change” that tells us that we cannot aspire – “because it is one thing to form government and another to have power”, “because I am only going to promise what I can get, in agreement with the PSOE and existing legality”. This “common sense” can be quickly surpassed once the road of social mobilization is returned to, with workers on the front foot and consistently defending the only realistic program to solve the great social problems: one that directly affects the profits and interests of the capitalists.
The most important conclusion that those moved by the victory of the dockworkers can draw is that the whole working class “has to do it like them. Our class has to learn how to flex its “muscle” and set it in motion a massive movement of workers together with young people, women and immigrants... in order to end unemployment by imposing the distribution of working hours with no reduction in wages, at the expense of the record profits being made by large corporations; by demanding the nationalization of banking and large strategic companies such as electricity providers under workers’ control; by refusing to pay all government debt; and by taxing large fortunes in order to guarantee good education, universal health and public services, among other urgent and fundamental measures.
The dockers’ victory is a victory for the whole working class against the precariousness of work. It is necessary to use this victory as a launching pad. They are going to keep attacking the dockworkers in order to try to break them, so for that reason we need to close ranks and surround them with our solidarity. At the same time, we must demand that if the trade union bureaucracy and the ‘neo-reformists’ want their declarations in favor of the unemployed, the precariously employed and other workers to have some credibility, they must call assemblies in every workplace for the organizing of a real plan of struggle that imposes a working-class solution to the crisis.
Translation: Sean Robertson
This is a translation of an article which first appeared at the Spanish Izquierda Diario website
* Unidos Podemos (United We Can) is the left-wing coalition that contested the 2016 Spanish general election. It consists of Podemos (We Can); Izquierda Unida (United Left) which has the Communist Party of Spain at its core; the Green Party “Equo” and other smaller, mainly regional parties. In various regions, it ran under different names, such as En Comú Podem (In Common We Can) in Catalonia and En Marea (En Masse) in Galicia.
Blog post about a visit to
Blog post about a visit to the port of Algeciras from a teacher active in supporting the dockworkers:
72 horas con los estibadores de Algeciras: Conociendo la estiba desde dentro
(No subject)
Report in Spanish on the
Report in Spanish on the first national meeting of female dockworkers:
Las estibadoras denuncian el "odio" del Gobierno y niegan que sean un colectivo machista
Also
Las mujeres estibadoras rompen amarras: «Tratan de hacernos invisibles pero no lo lograrán»
The government has now put
The government has now put forward a revised version of the decree. I haven't looked into it closely but I don"t think there are substantial changes. Coordinadora has announced a new series of strike days on 24, 26, 29 and 31 May and 2, 5, 7 and 9 June. Brief report in Spanish:
Los sindicatos de estibadores ante el engaño del gobierno anuncian 8 días de lucha y huelga
Blog post in Spanish by Juanjo Peris:
Dignidad
Quote: Dear IDC
http://mailchi.mp/12d6808ba76e/idc-coordinadora-strike-advisory
The revised version of the
The revised version of the decree has now been passed by Congress with 175 votes in favour, 164 votes against and 8 abstentions. This time Ciudadanos supported it. It looks like the strikes will now go ahead, beginning on 24 May.
El Gobierno convalida el decreto de la estiba con apoyos políticos pero no de los trabajadores, que irán a la huelga
Report in Spanish on calls by
Report in Spanish on calls by the IDC for dockworkers in other countries not to unload ships diverted from ports in Spain.
115.000 estibadores de todo el mundo apoyarán las acciones que emprendan los estibadores españoles con todas sus consecuencias
Portuguese dockworkers refuse to handle ships and cargoes diverted from Spain. Report in Portuguese.
Estivadores portugueses em greve aos navios desviados de Espanha
Statement by Portuguese dockworkers.
Portuguese Dockworkers decree strike on ships diverted from Spain
Meanwhile in Sweden... APM
Meanwhile in Sweden...
APM Terminals escalates the Gothenburg dispute - massive lockout announced from the 19th of May
A message of support from
A message of support from taxi drivers in Valencia (in Spanish).
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wfPf3ZvGDo8
[youtube]wfPf3ZvGDo8[/youtube]
.
And from Las Kellys (hotel cleaners) on Fuerteventura.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=FhnH_LpjLPk
[youtube]FhnH_LpjLPk[/youtube]
::: DOSSIER SOBRE LA LUCHA DE
::: DOSSIER SOBRE LA LUCHA DE LA ESTIBA :::
Hoy el Congreso ha aprobado el decreto ley de la estiba, por tanto los estibadores y estibadoras están en pie de guerra. En este contexto del incremento de la conflictividad en los puertos, difundimos el siguiente número especial elaborado por La Soli.
Puedes descargarlo y leerlo en el siguiente enlace: http://lasoli.cnt.cat/hemeroteca/2017/2017-04-24.pdf
::: ESSENTIAL FIGHTING DOSSIER :::
Today Congress has approved the stevedown law, so stevedores and stevedores are on the warpath. In this context of increased conflict in ports, we released the following special issue prepared by La Soli.
You can download it and read it at the following link: http://lasoli.cnt.cat/hemeroteca/2017/2017-04-24.pdf
Shipping press report on the
Shipping press report on the new strike call out. I'm not sure if the claim that go slows are already happening is accurate. I suspect not.
https://www.lloydslist.com/ll/sector/ports-and-logistics/article555864.ece
Well, that is possible. Due
Well, that is possible. Due to strikes or possible jealousy of port workers, delays and so on, companies have diverted workloads to other ports.
As I said before is not something new in this sector since the dismantling of much of the naval since the 1980s.
To have such a function the dock workers' coordinator can be vital for the pulse that Spanish dock workers are carrying.
The first five strike days,
The first five strike days, which were due to start tomorrow, have been called off following talks yesterday with the employers organisation Anesco. It appears that the more moderate wing of the port employers are willing to reach an agreement on maintaining job security. It remains to be seen whether all the employers will go along with this.
http://www.naucher.com/es/actualidad/el-acuerdo-de-estibadores-y-patronal-retrasa-la-huelga-a-la-espera-de-que-anesco-renazca/_n:6501/
http://www.coordinadora.org/noticias/estibadores-ceep/15218-la-asamblea-acuerda-exigir-a-anesco-la-garantia-de-la-totalidad-del-empleo
As always, thanks for the
As always, thanks for the updates Mark!
It looks like the strikes are
It looks like the strikes are finally happening, starting tomorrow.
https://mobile.twitter.com/Portuariosworld/status/870654607902601216
According to this dockworkers will be striking on alternate hours on June 5, 7 and 9, followed by an all out 48 hour strike from June 14 to 16, and striking on alternate hours again on June 19, 21 and 23.
JP Morgan hace caja con la reforma de la estiba y vende a Cosco sus puertos españoles
Another report here claiming that J P Morgan are looking to sell their interests in Spanish ports to Chinese port operator Cosco, and so have an interest in the government's reforms going through to reduce labour costs before a possible sale. I'm not sure the report actually contains any new information, though it may help explain some of the divisions on the employers' side. Some other employers seem content with the status quo and less than keen on the government's plans.
La estiba europea reafirma el "apoyo incondicional a nuestros compañeros españoles”
Report on IDC meeting in Barcelona last week.
More on J P Morgan and
More on J P Morgan and Cosco:
Cosco se quedará con Noatum...
Report on the strike plans from the same site:
Los estibadores inician este lunes una dura huelga para forzar a las empresas al acuerdo
The strike dock workers'
The strike dock workers' begins in defense of their rights and jobs
Comienza la huelga del colectivo de estibadores en defensa de sus derechos y puestos de trabajo
http://kaosenlared.net/comienza-la-huelga-lxs-estibadorxs-defensa-puestos-trabajo-derechos/
"The Ministry of Public Works has ordered minimum services of up to 100% in operations involving perishable and dangerous goods, passengers, emergency situations and essential products for the islands, Ceuta and Melilla. Abusive minimum services that also require dockers to guarantee a yield of not less than 50% of the average of the previous calendar year on a comparable day."
Images from the link above:
Images from the link above:
Reports on today's strike
Reports on today's strike action
Spanish ports hit by nation-wide strike
Dockers strike disrupts Spanish ports and trade routes
A call for international
A call for international solidarity with the Spanish dockers
Report on yesterday's strike
Report on yesterday's strike action
Estibadores: 1 - Fomento: 0. Primer día de seguimiento masivo y sin incidentes
Quote: Spanish dockworkers
From here
Dockworkers in Algeciras:
Dockworkers in Algeciras:
https://mobile.twitter.com/tiresias365/status/872382563372937216
Blog post by Juanjo
Blog post by Juanjo Peris
Días de lucha
Report on the Gothenburg
Report on the Gothenburg dispute
Gothenburg lockout 'descends into farce' as mediators say they've had enough
Report from the Puerto de
Report from the Puerto de Marín, near Pontevedra
Ni lujos ni Ferraris: la estiba desde dentro
Podcast:
Podcast: http://thedockerpodcast.libsyn.com/itf-cape-town-part-1-jorge-garcia-faerna?tdest_id=258903
The situation in Sweden is
The situation in Sweden is now beginning to turn into momentous issue for the independent workers movement as well as for the majority reformist unions. The social democrat government are now trying to use the pressure put on them by the Swedish Confederation of Enterprise to kickstart a government inquiry that could remove the right for non-CBA holding unions to engage in labor disputes (if the industrial action is not explicitly aimed at winning a CBA). This would not only mean problems for minority unions like the Swedish Dockworkers' Union, but also libertarian unions like SAC - the Syndicalists. The majority confederation, the LO, are staying very quiet on this issue, even though a change like this would make it possible for companies to form their own yellow unions, sign CBAs with these paper constructions, and effectively get rid of even reformist opposition.
From the Hamn4an:
Support from dockworkers in
Support from dockworkers in Valencia for Las Kellys hotel cleaners in Benidorm.
https://mobile.twitter.com/xavillin/status/873211413912838145
https://mobile.twitter.com/KeRoLeT/status/874310746141843456
https://mobile.twitter.com/NataliaOhYeah/status/874405852530311168
What is CBA?
What is CBA?
^collective bargaining
^collective bargaining agreement
Confirmation that Cosco has
Confirmation that Cosco has bought a controlling interest in port operator Noatum, including the Valencia and Bilbao container terminals.
Cosco compra el 51% de Noatum Ports por 203,5 millones y se queda con la terminal de València
Edit: report on this in English
Cosco Shipping Ports takes majority stake in Noatum Ports
48 hour strike to go ahead
48 hour strike to go ahead starting at 8am tomorrow following the breakdown of the latest talks between unions and employers organisation Anesco. The report blames the failure of talks on divisions on the employers side.
Los estibadores convocan una huelga de 48 horas tras fracasar las negociaciones con la patronal
Maersk Line on the effects of
Maersk Line on the effects of the strikes
https://www2.maerskline.com/spanish-port-contingency
More strike days called for
More strike days called for the end of June / start of July
Los estibadores elevan la tensión y convocan cuatro nuevos paros en los puertos
AFP report on the current 48
AFP report on the current 48 hour strike
Spain's dockers up fight for jobs with two-day strike
IDC calls for two hour
IDC calls for two hour Eiurope-wide strike on 29 June in support of Spanish dockworkers.
La estiba europea anuncia un paro de 2 horas el 29 de junio en apoyo a los trabajadores españoles
Reuters report Spanish dock
Reuters report
Spanish dock workers extend strikes into July
Demo by CNT linesmen from the
Demo by CNT linesmen from the port of Barcelona on Monday. This seems to be their own separate dispute, and I think the employers are different.
https://mobile.twitter.com/PortuariosCNT/status/875028242029309954
Overtime ban, which may have a wider effect together with the action by Coordinadora:
https://mobile.twitter.com/PortuariosCNT/status/874567633156354048
Solidarity action against
Solidarity action against unloading world's second largest container ship the Madrid Maersk which had been rerouted from Algeciras. I'm not sure of the details but it's now back in Algeciras.
https://mobile.twitter.com/IDC_Dockers/status/876003739127218176
https://mobile.twitter.com/ACV_Maritime/status/873111691600379905
https://mobile.twitter.com/ACV_Maritime/status/873113561681100805
https://mobile.twitter.com/ITFglobalunion/status/873131160620191744
https://mobile.twitter.com/pico_de_loro/status/874344750744252417
https://mobile.twitter.com/romerito1462/status/875854741011668992
Edit: report here
ITF/ETF dockers take action to back Spanish colleagues
Edit2: A more complete report in Spanish. According to this dockworkers in Antwerp, Felixstowe and Rotterdam refused to unload it. I can't find any other confirmation of action at Felixstowe although it did call there.
Boicot de los estibadores europeos al barco que Maersk desvió de Algeciras a Tánger
Spain's ports paralysed by 48
Spain's ports paralysed by 48 hour strike
Statement from Coordinadora
Statement from Coordinadora on the rejection of its latest proposals by Anesco
Antolín Goya: “Anesco falta al respeto a sus clientes, a los españoles y, especialmente, a nosotros, los trabajadores”
Another strike day
Another strike day today
https://mobile.twitter.com/pablogfajardo/status/876731960428822533
https://mobile.twitter.com/Portuariosworld/status/876717208310775809
https://mobile.twitter.com/mundoestiba/status/874948700233236480
Report claiming that
Report claiming that divisions on the employers' side are leading to some companies making agreements with unions to guarantee job security and so avoid further strike action. I haven't seen this confirmed elsewhere as yet.
Los pactos bajo cuerda entre empresas y estibadores abren una brecha en la patronal
Some background on the various port employers.
De la lista de Liechtenstein a los primos de Rato: ¿quiénes son los patrones de la estiba?
Edit: statement from Coordinadora which seems to confirm the report above.
https://mobile.twitter.com/Portuariosworld/status/877205454941769728
Another report based on this statement.
Los estibadores no harán huelga en las terminales que garanticen los empleos
Podcast in Spanish -
Podcast in Spanish - interview with Antolín Goya from Coordinadora.
¿Qué pasa con los Estibadores? La venta de los Puertos Españoles a China
Dockworkers at all Europe's
Dockworkers at all Europe's ports ready for action to support Spanish strikers
It seems that agreement has
It seems that agreement has been reached for now with most of the major port operators and strike action will only continue against companies that are holding out.
https://mobile.twitter.com/JordiNova/status/877418743223242754
https://mobile.twitter.com/CopeCanarias/status/877433194261381120
https://mobile.twitter.com/CopeCanarias/status/877433752804360192
https://mobile.twitter.com/mundoestiba/status/877430542446284800
https://mobile.twitter.com/dockerspain/status/877439965424218114
Edit: report in Spanish
Los sindicatos disipan la posibilidad de un acuerdo fortalecidos por la división empresarial
Twitter thread (in Spanish)
Twitter thread (in Spanish) on the tactic of creating divisions between the employers.
https://mobile.twitter.com/estibaverdader/status/877546734813155329
"It's the first time that in
"It's the first time that in a collective conflict the employers are split instead of the union side. Dockworkers you are an example."
https://mobile.twitter.com/PortuariosCNT/status/877562716084252673
This is a fairly clear report
This is a fairly clear report in Spanish on the current state of play in the dispute. Algeciras, the largest port, is working normally. In Valencia and Barcelona, the next most important ports, one terminal at each is still affected by strikes. Between them these ports account for more than half of Spain's dockworkers. Strikes are continuing at some of the smaller ports where agreement hasn't been reached with employers, including, according to this report, Alicante, Almería, Cádiz, Castellón, A Coruña, Ferrol, Motril, Huelva, Málaga, Melilla, Cartagena, Avilés, Marín, Vigo, Santander, Tarragona and Bilbao. Elsewhere I've seen mention of dockworkers in Algeciras setting up a fund to support those still on strike.
Los estibadores ganan por la mano su batalla con la patronal
Edit: strikes planned for June 23, 26 and 27 suspended pending another meeting with employers next week.
La estiba suspende (en parte) la huelga
This report has more background on the (divided) positions of the employers. In brief some of the major, and more intransigent, companies have now left the employers' organisation Anesco, where, although in a minority, they had been exercising a veto on attempts to reach an agreement with the unions. They're now demanding government intervention in the dispute.
La 'nueva' Anesco pide tiempo a la estiba para democratizar su estructura y estatutos
A report in English on the
A report in English on the latest developments. It's confused about which companies have left Anesco (it's the hardliners, not the ones that want to reach an agreement) but seems accurate otherwise.
Spain: workers suspend strikes as companies quit Anesco
Agreement reached between
Agreement reached between dockworkers and Anesco with all jobs guaranteed. Remaining strike days called off. I'm not sure what happens now with the companies that have left Anesco.
https://mobile.twitter.com/Portuariosworld/status/880409647064207360
Stoppage today in Algeciras
Stoppage today in Algeciras as part of IDC Europe-wide action.
https://mobile.twitter.com/joseferlo361/status/880483628899323904
Stoppage in Valencia in solidarity with dockworkers in Gothenburg.
https://mobile.twitter.com/mundoestiba/status/880476229857669120
Edit: Tenerife
https://mobile.twitter.com/estibacanaria/status/880506810892996608
Las Palmas
https://mobile.twitter.com/estibacanaria/status/880508280677838848
Elsewhere in Europe
https://mobile.twitter.com/jordiaragunde/status/880514894516424704
AFP report Spain's dockers
AFP report
Spain's dockers end strike after deal with employers
Reports in Spanish from the
Reports in Spanish from the Naucher Global site:
El IDC mantiene mañana el paro de dos horas y Anesco se reúne con los sindicatos en Madrid
La verdad de la dimisión de Joaquim Coello y sus consecuencias a corto plazo
Patronal y sindicatos alcanzan un acuerdo: tras la guerra llega la paz
El día después al acuerdo de la estiba: dudas, posicionamientos y futuro
Blog post by Juanjo Peris La
Blog post by Juanjo Peris
La victoria es sólo el comienzo
Coordinadora in Barcelona
Coordinadora in Barcelona have announced that they will not work with ships used by police in light of the current crisis over the Catalan independence referendum planned for 1 October. The decision was made unanimously in an assembly today. At the moment there are two ships moored in the port of Barcelona to provide accommodation for upwards of 4,000 police from the Policía Nacional.
https://mobile.twitter.com/CoordinadoraBCN/status/910814954814627841
https://elpais.com/ccaa/2017/09/21/catalunya/1505981808_365812.html
https://mobile.twitter.com/CgtMar/status/910798886893182976
https://mobile.twitter.com/PortuariosCNT/status/910561218162814984
https://mobile.twitter.com/PortuariosCNT/status/910554845731573760
The CGT in Catalunya are proposing a general strike starting on 3 October. According to the report they have been in discussions with other unions, aiming for united action.
http://rojoynegro.info/articulo/agitación/la-cgt-presenta-preaviso-convocatoria-huelga-general-catalunya
Edit: also the smaller Catalan unions IAC and COS.
https://mobile.twitter.com/LasKellysBCN/status/910910585021370368
alasbarricadas thread
http://www.alasbarricadas.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=25&t=54033&start=1815
A useful report from Freedom
A useful report from Freedom (though I think the PortuariosCNT tweet about repainting the ship was meant to be ironic rather than taken seriously):
https://freedomnews.org.uk/barcelona-cnt-warns-of-riot-cops-shipped-into-docks/
The Coordinadora action is reported in the Telegraph. It mentions that dockworkers in Tarragona have joined in:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/09/21/boats-spanish-military-police-blocked-catalan-ports-unrest-grows/
STRIKE: MOORING & PORT
STRIKE:
MOORING & PORT SERVICES (Servicio de Amarre del @portdebarcelona) the days 15, 16 y 17 of february.
https://twitter.com/PortuariosCNT/status/958731685738278913?s=09
Guerra laboral en el Puerto
Guerra laboral en el Puerto de Barcelona: despido de sindicalistas, trabajadores sin salvavidas y amarradores avituallando barcos
La empresa de amarres Mooring & Port Services ha echado a tres trabajadores de CNT por negarse a provisionar buques por considerarlo fuera de sus funciones. El sindicato ha convocado tres días de huelga para lograr su readmisión.
https://twitter.com/portuario
https://twitter.com/portuarioscnt?lang=es
"We have finished the Workers' Assembly. The staff supports the strike to force the reincorporation of their colleagues. Tomorrow we are summoned for the first mediation before the Labor Authority."
"A nuestra asamblea han acudido representantes de: -Remolcadores (CGT) -@BcnTepsa -@USTP_PORT_D_BCN -@CoordinadoraBCN No existe ni existirá un Puerto sin vosotros. Sois enormes. Gracias."
"Representatives of:
- Tugboats (CGT)
- @ BcnTepsa
- @ USTP_PORT_D_BCN
- @ CoordinadoraBCN
- There is not a Port without you. You are huge. Thank you."
https://twitter.com/Portuario
https://twitter.com/PortuariosCNT/status/962003227674857472
ULTIMA HORA| La empresa RECTIFICA y accede a READMITIR a nuestros tres trabajadores despedidos.
LAST MINUTE | The company RECTIFIES and agrees to READMIT our three dismissed workers.
There is no deal, will go on
There is no deal, will go on strike
https://www.elsaltodiario.com/laboral/portuarios-amarradores-barcelona-pie-guerra-despidos-inseguridad
https://twitter.com/PortuariosCNT/status/963479114685480960
They won! Anarchist Union
They won!
Anarchist Union Reverses Firings at Port of Barcelona Through Militant Strike
https://itsgoingdown.org/anarchist-union-reverses-firings-port-barcelona-militant-strike/
It would have been Mick who
It would have been Mick who wrote the pamphlet. Mick, one of my closest friends, died in December 2018. I have most of his writings and will see if I have a copy of it.
An obituary of Mick Parkin,…
An obituary of Mick Parkin, 1957 - 2018.