Is there an anarcho-syndicalist perspective on "Brexit"? Please limit replies to anarcho-syndicalist or positions that are libertarian and close to anarcho-syndicalism.
Most anarcho-syndicalists I know voted 'remain' in the referendum because they saw it as a plebiscite on immigration rather than a referendum on EU membership. A significant proportion of anarcho-syndicalists didn't vote because neither choice on the ballot was appealing.
Yeah, it's the kind of subject that it's hard to have a distinctively anarcho-syndicalist take on, because a-s tends to focus its attention away from politics at the state/government level and Brexit is all about that. Beyond "we don't take sides in the bosses' fights", I don't know how much more there is to say.
I figured someone might have written an analysis
Of the historical situation, etc brining on this idea,
that's all. Yeah, I get a plague on both your houses
thing and would've expected that. Yeah, prolly should've
figured that's all to expect.
Not anarcho-syndicalist but the IWGB originated from a split with the IWW UK. This is what they said about Brexit:
IWGB President Henry Chango Lopez
As migrant and precarious workers we have had to fight tooth and nail to win even the most basic rights and dignity at work. Losing EU employment law protections would mean we lose a vital weapon in our arsenal against exploitative bosses. That's why we need a people's vote. To stop a Brexit that will most likely be a carnival for profiteering companies and a curse for UK workers, not least, those at the bottom of the pile.
https://www.iwgb.org.uk/en/post/5bfcf93d5df02/iwgb-joins-call-for-a
Along with this critique of it: https://nothingiseverlost.wordpress.com/2016/11/13/brexit-means-the-sky-is-falling-how-aufheben-learned-to-stop-worrying-and-love-the-eu/
Trying hard to think of other stuff: The WSM have written quite a bit about Brexit (possibly more than some UK-based groups?), see for instance http://wsm.ie/c/brexit-border-poll-anarchist-view and http://wsm.ie/brexit
The New Syndicalist said that they were gonna run a series on populism, which I guess is relevant, they don't seem to have written much of it so far though: https://newsyndicalist.org/2019/02/09/threat-and-potential-populism-editorial/
The Angry Workers of the World do some of the best analysis of the contemporary UK situation imo, see https://angryworkersworld.wordpress.com/2018/01/15/migration-and-national-social-democracy-in-britain/ and https://angryworkersworld.wordpress.com/2016/06/20/tragedy-and-comedy-in-the-uk-a-short-report/
Yeah, it's the kind of subject that it's hard to have a distinctively anarcho-syndicalist take on, because a-s tends to focus its attention away from politics at the state/government level and Brexit is all about that. Beyond "we don't take sides in the bosses' fights", I don't know how much more there is to say.
Alas, all the links you found.....so there's something people are saying (wink,wink, smile, grin)
Fair point, I think I was tripped up by the anarcho-syndicalist part, I did try to think of any more explicitly a-s takes about "here's how Brexit could affect the possibilities for a revolutionary union movement" or even "here's how a revolutionary union movement could affect Brexit" but was drawing a blank on that score.
Anarcho-Syndicaliste do see things beyond a revolutionary unionist perspective. How do things affect the working class and social aspects as well. I was mainly interested in a non left communist viewpoint, one closer to an anarcho-syndicalist. Anarcho-syndicalists are not usually the best writers (self-criticism here as well). Though we do some good shorter newspaper type stuff, which might be out there and have not seen. But, hey, all links welcome at this point.
If you haven't already, I'd really recommend the other thread darren p linked to above, it has contributions from a range of viewpoints, as well as links to AF and ACG statements.
Nada?
Nada?
syndicalist
syndicalist
Most anarcho-syndicalists I know voted 'remain' in the referendum because they saw it as a plebiscite on immigration rather than a referendum on EU membership. A significant proportion of anarcho-syndicalists didn't vote because neither choice on the ballot was appealing.
European capitalism..or
European capitalism..or homegrown....no difference
Yeah, it's the kind of
Yeah, it's the kind of subject that it's hard to have a distinctively anarcho-syndicalist take on, because a-s tends to focus its attention away from politics at the state/government level and Brexit is all about that. Beyond "we don't take sides in the bosses' fights", I don't know how much more there is to say.
tyneside anarchist
tyneside anarchist
Unless you’re an EU worker living in the UK or a UK worker living in the EU...
That was discussed more in this thread:
http://libcom.org/forums/theory/eu-roads-travel-13012019
I figured someone might have
I figured someone might have written an analysis
Of the historical situation, etc brining on this idea,
that's all. Yeah, I get a plague on both your houses
thing and would've expected that. Yeah, prolly should've
figured that's all to expect.
Have you seen the Aufheben
Have you seen the Aufheben article?
https://libcom.org/library/brexit-means%E2%80%A6-what-hapless-ideology-practical-consequences
Not anarcho-syndicalist but
Not anarcho-syndicalist but the IWGB originated from a split with the IWW UK. This is what they said about Brexit:
IWGB President Henry Chango Lopez
Jim wrote: Have you seen the
Jim
Now I have. Thx
Along with this critique of
Along with this critique of it: https://nothingiseverlost.wordpress.com/2016/11/13/brexit-means-the-sky-is-falling-how-aufheben-learned-to-stop-worrying-and-love-the-eu/
Trying hard to think of other stuff: The WSM have written quite a bit about Brexit (possibly more than some UK-based groups?), see for instance http://wsm.ie/c/brexit-border-poll-anarchist-view and http://wsm.ie/brexit
The New Syndicalist said that they were gonna run a series on populism, which I guess is relevant, they don't seem to have written much of it so far though: https://newsyndicalist.org/2019/02/09/threat-and-potential-populism-editorial/
The Angry Workers of the World do some of the best analysis of the contemporary UK situation imo, see https://angryworkersworld.wordpress.com/2018/01/15/migration-and-national-social-democracy-in-britain/ and https://angryworkersworld.wordpress.com/2016/06/20/tragedy-and-comedy-in-the-uk-a-short-report/
R Totale wrote: Yeah, it's
R Totale
Alas, all the links you found.....so there's something people are saying (wink,wink, smile, grin)
Fair point, I think I was
Fair point, I think I was tripped up by the anarcho-syndicalist part, I did try to think of any more explicitly a-s takes about "here's how Brexit could affect the possibilities for a revolutionary union movement" or even "here's how a revolutionary union movement could affect Brexit" but was drawing a blank on that score.
Anarcho-Syndicaliste do see
Anarcho-Syndicaliste do see things beyond a revolutionary unionist perspective. How do things affect the working class and social aspects as well. I was mainly interested in a non left communist viewpoint, one closer to an anarcho-syndicalist. Anarcho-syndicalists are not usually the best writers (self-criticism here as well). Though we do some good shorter newspaper type stuff, which might be out there and have not seen. But, hey, all links welcome at this point.
If you haven't already, I'd
If you haven't already, I'd really recommend the other thread darren p linked to above, it has contributions from a range of viewpoints, as well as links to AF and ACG statements.
Thank you all for your links
Thank you all for your links and contributions.