The Dislocation of Vendémiaire (IV): The Misrecognized Socialism and the Resisters Who Refuse Connection 【葡月的错位(四)被误认的社会主义与拒绝联结的抗争者】 【A commentary on the French riots between September and October】

The Dislocation of Vendémiaire (IV): The Misrecognized Socialism and the Resisters Who Refuse Connection 【葡月的错位(四)被误认的社会主义与拒绝联结的抗争者】 【A commentary on the French riots between September and October】

This essay is the fourth part of The Dislocation of Vendémiaire. Drawing on Karl Marx's famous "sack of potatoes" metaphor from 1851, it contrasts the historical inability of the French peasantry to unite with the contemporary resisters of the 2026 French/European movements who actively "refuse connection." The author argues that while previous struggles centered on physiological survival, modern struggles have shifted to the realm of existential subjectivity—the refusal to be treated as mere interchangeable parts ("elementalization") within social machinery. The essay re-examines the Soviet experience, arguing that it substituted market-based elementalization with a planned one, thereby creating a historical illusion that alienated modern resisters from political organizations. Ultimately, the text critiques the movement's decentralized, anti-party stance as "eating the child with the bathwater," arguing that without the vanguard, organization, and discipline, resisting a highly organized capitalist state machine is impossible.

Author
Submitted by 张皓翔 on October 23, 2026

Related content