Friday 14 January 2011 -- After a dramatic 24 hours when Tunisia's dictator president Ben Ali first tried promising liberalisation and an end to police shootings of demonstrators and then, this evening at 16:00, declaring martial law, he has finally fallen from office. While the rumours are still swirling, one thing is clear, Ben Ali has left Tunisia and the army has stepped in. The comments after this article contain continuous updates of the uprising.
The day began with a mass demonstration called by Tunisia's trade union federation, the UGTT, in the capital Tunis. Between 10 and 15,000 people demonstrated outside the Ministry of the Interior. The initially peaceful scene broke down at around 14:30 local time as police moved in with tear gas and batons to disperse the crowd, some of whom had managed to scale the Ministry building and get on its roof. From then on, the city centre descended into chaos with running battles between the riot police and Tunisians of all ages and backgrounds fighting for the overthrow of the hated despot.
Finally, armoured cars from the army appeared on the street and a state of emergency and curfew was declared with Ben Ali threatening the populace that the security forces had carte blanche to open fire on any gatherings of more than three people. Soon, however, he disappeared from view and the rumours began to circulate. The army seized control of the airport and there were reports of convoys of limousines racing to the airport from the Ben Ali families palace. Finally the official announcement came. Ben Ali is gone. Prime Minister Mohammed Ghannouchi appeared on state TV to announce that he was in charge of a caretaker government backed by the army.
Tonight the long-suffering people of Tunisia may rejoice that their last four weeks of heroic resistance has finally seen off the dictator who ran the most vicious police state in North Africa over them for the last 23 years.
But tomorrow morning will find the army in charge. What will happen tomorrow and the days to follow is anybody's guess. But the people now know that they have the power to overthrow a long-entrenched dictatorship, how much easier to take on a new unstable regime.
Report by Workers Solidarity Movement
Comments
The Register have finally got
The Register have finally got the scoop on the details of that country-wide Facebook, Gmail etc password hack that we were hearing about a few weeks before the 14th.
It's got a high geek content, but I would suggest it should be of interest to anybody who uses FB, Gmail, Yahoo, etc. just as a cautionary tale.
Tunisia plants country-wide keystroke logger on Facebook
Founding statement of the
Founding statement of the 14th of January Front
Slideshows: 14 January -----
Slideshows: 14 January ----- 22 January
I'm going to dispense with
I'm going to dispense with including the original French version of these stories, as people can always check out the original via the links, and it's just taking up space for people who only read english.
TF1: Tunisie : les ministres de l'ère Ben Ali écartés lors du remaniement ?
On the Gafsa thing, the union are saying:
le Monde: Tunisie : sécurité renforcée avant l'annonce d'un remaniement
No mention of anyone setting themselves on fire. NB it's hard to know exactly what the state of the internal wranglings are within the UGTT at the moment, but in the past the word of the leadership of the union centre may not have been trustworthy on events in Gafsa, considering that the indications are that they may have played a role supportive to the Ben Ali regime in suppressing the 2008 uprising there, expelling local union militants and making no protest over their subsequent imprisonment. Nb those militants have now released and, under point 12 of the UGTT declaration of Jan 18, all previously expelled union sections and militants have had their explusion revoked:
from UGTT - National Administration Commission Statement, Jan 18
Clashes this morning BBC:
Clashes this morning
BBC: Tunisia protests: Clashes near government compound
La lucha de clases machine
La lucha de clases
machine translation
Tunisia protests turn violent
Tunisia protests turn violent (Al Jazeera)
http://www.npa2009.org/conten
http://www.npa2009.org/content/tunisie-le-peuple-s%E2%80%99organise
Some information on the
Some information on the situation in Tunisia and Algeria, by an Algerian.
------------------------------------------
1) Tunisie-Algérie, différences syndicales
Si le régime de Ben Ali a éliminé d’importantes médiations possibles entre lui et la population (partis crédibles, associations...), il n’a pas réussi à concrétiser le rêve caressé par Habib Bourguiba de transformer l'Union générale tunisienne du travail (UGTT) en un syndicat-maison. Contrepoids au pouvoir politique depuis l’indépendance et terrain d’action privilégié pour la gauche radicale, l’UGTT n’a pas soutenu la jeunesse de la Tunisie profonde seulement par des sit-in, dont deux devant son siège central, le 25 décembre 2010 et le 7 janvier 2011. Elle l’a aussi soutenue en portant sa voix dans la presse mondiale, qui continue à recueillir ses informations auprès de « sources syndicales ».
La direction de l’UGTT a certes appuyé la candidature de Ben Ali à la présidence en 2004 et 2009 (au prix d’une crise intérieure) et la majorité de ses membres, rassemblés autour du secrétaire général Abdesselam Jerad, sont loin d’être indépendants. Toutefois, cette organisation n’en compte pas moins, à ses échelons intermédiaires (directions des syndicats de la fonction publique : santé, éducation nationale, etc.), des dirigeants suffisamment radicaux pour saluer l’intifada de Sidi Bouzid en des mots plus francs que ceux du bureau exécutif. L’implication de dizaines de syndicalistes dans les luttes démocratiques de ces dernières années est également un fait notoire. Leur radicalisme explique que la direction de la centrale ne cède pas complètement aux pressions des autorités, qu’elle appuie les populations révoltées et appelle même à élargir le champ des libertés (déclaration du 4 janvier 2011).
Ce n’est pas le cas pour l’Union générale des travailleurs algériens (UGTA), de plus en plus inféodée au régime depuis l’arrivée de Bouteflika au pouvoir, en 1999, et dont la majorité des secrétaires nationaux sont membres des deux « partis officiels », le FLN et le RND. Cette soumission au gouvernement a achevé de détacher d’elle des pans entiers de syndicalistes, qui l’ont quittée pour des syndicats autonomes plus combatifs. Elle explique sa quasi-indifférence aux contestations en cours dans le pays. Celles-ci n’ont fait l’objet que d’une seule déclaration (rendue publique le 7 janvier 2011) dans laquelle elle défend le point de vue du gouvernement qui accuse les « spéculateurs » d’être à l’origine de la crise actuelle.
[9 janvier 2011]
2) Les Tunisiens dépossédés de leur victoire.
La transition démocratique va-t-elle être menée par le parti officiel, le RCD moyennant un petit lifting et quelques figures honnies offertes en pâture à la vindicte populaire ? Au-delà de l’euphorie et des inquiétudes, les signes d’un changement politique radical ne sont pas évidents. Le système RCD relooké pourrait profiter des divergences de l’opposition pour rester au pouvoir.
Ils sont rares les signes d’un changement politique radical qui ferait de la chute de Zine El Abidine Ben Ali le début d’une époque nouvelle et non d’une autre « Ere du changement ». Le pays est gouverné par un symbole du Parti officiel, Fouad Mbazaâ, qui, pas plus tard qu’en novembre 2010, priait l’ancien président de se porter candidat aux présidentielles de 2014. Le Premier ministre, Mohamed Ghannouchi, est celui-là même dont le gouvernement a réprimé les manifestations de ces dernières semaines, et bien qu'il soit présenté comme un simple « technocrate », son image ne peut être dissociée de celle de l’Etat-RCD. Les élections présidentielles annoncées dans quelque deux mois seront organisées par ces deux hommes, qui traînent le boulet de leur appartenance à un régime massivement rejeté pendant un mois de troubles. Les manifestants arrêtés depuis le 18 décembre 2010 ont été libérés mais des militants politiques sont encore sous les verrous, dont Ammar Amroussia, un dirigeant du PCOT, le journaliste Fahem Boukeddous et Hassan Ben Abdallah, dirigeant de la contestation populaire dans le Bassin minier de Gafsa (janvier-juin 2008). L’armée, présentée comme « neutre », semble déterminée à assurer la continuité du système sous une forme aménagée. Si elle fait arrêter d’anciens ministres de l’Intérieur, elle offre sa protection à d’autres anciens responsables non moins impliqués dans les exactions policières de ces 23 dernières années. Le « modèle tunisien », célébré par le FMI et la Banque mondiale, et dont l’échec a été magistralement démontré, n’est pas remis en cause. On a presque déjà oublié que le feu de la révolte qui a provoqué la chute d’un des plus anciens despotes de la région s’est allumé dans l’arrière-pays déshérité, marginalisé par un système économique très dépendant de l’économie européenne. Seule la corruption est dénoncée et seuls Ben Ali et sa famille sont désignés à la vindicte populaire, comme si le pillage des ressources tunisiennes était le fait d’une poignée d’hommes et de femmes et que personne au sein du Parti-Etat n’avait profité de leurs largesses ou leur a offert sa protection.
[16 janvier 2011]
Yassin T.
Not sure this source is very
Not sure this source is very reliable, but it does offer another angle on the situation in Tunisia:
http://www.voltairenet.org/article168223.html
English version of that last
English version of that last link posted by sitcom: http://www.voltairenet.org/article168224.html
This is probably worth reading but definitely has elements of leftist conspiracy theory:
While this may be nonsense I'm sure there's a lot going on behind the scenes. It would be surprising if Western governments weren't trying to influence events. What this amounts to and how competently it is done is another question.
Video posted up this
Video posted up this afternoon, I'm not sure if the footage is from today.
[youtube]o75PsBIjq6Q[/youtube]
From the International
From the International Marxist Tendency. The usual caveats apply.
Tunisia – for a national general strike against the Gannouchi government!
As suspected the
As suspected the international arrest warrant for Ben Ali, Leila & co (and the even more annoying news that Imed is not only alive but was allowed to flee the country) was simply by means of a delaying tactic.
As the day dragged on yesterday with no announcement on the "reshuffle", Chebbi finally said that it wouldn't be til late hours, possibly Thursday morning. Finally, at ten past ten local time, the curt announcement was that it would be Thursday now. This for an announcement originally due on Tuesday.
le Parisien
Tensión en la Qasba Quote: Si
Tensión en la Qasba
machine translation
Tunisia may purge Ben Ali
Tunisia may purge Ben Ali loyalists (Al Jazeera)
more delays NouvelObs:
more delays
NouvelObs: Tunisie: nouveau report du remaniement ministériel
From the Tunisia Scenario
From the Tunisia Scenario blog
Instability and military rule
From the Moor Next Door Re:
From the Moor Next Door
Re: Algerian leftists & the winter uprisings: or, the weakness of political parties
liveblog Quote: 2135 GMT: The
liveblog
A number of different sources
A number of different sources have it that the reshuffle deal, including Ghannouchi staying on, had the agreement of UGTT centre.
l'Humanité
Radio-Canada
All of which makes the one-day general strikes in Sfax on Tuesday and Sidi Bouzid yesterday, look suspiciously like bargaining leverage ploys from the perspective of the UGTT centre negotiators. Quite what the militants and union members at the base and outside of Tunis will make of this deal and the way the centre has negotiated it, is another question.
Obstinación y
Obstinación y contrarrevolución
machine translation
From the EA
From the EA liveblog
Call for the formation of a
Call for the formation of a front for the popular liberation of Tunisia
French
Spanish
English (machine translation)
While the world's attention
While the world's attention was distracted by the uprising in Egypt...
Police destroy protest camp at Tunisian PM's office
From the Moor Next Door Vague
From the Moor Next Door
Vague thoughts on the Arab winter uprisings
"Finally this afternoon at
"Finally this afternoon at 4pm [Friday] the police have attacked the Kasbah, killing Omar Auini, asphyxiated by teargas, and wounding at least 15 people, most of them with fractures in their hands and legs … As was feared yesterday the support from the UGTT for the government has seriously damaged unity in the square. From very early on small groups from Kasserine and Regueb have abandoned the rally to return to their towns. Some of them, according to what they tell us, have received money. Those that remain show themselves to be determined and militant, but the hours already seem numbered..."
El asalto de la Qasba
machine translation
From the International
From the International Marxist Tendency
Reject the government reshuffle, the revolutionary people must take power
Photo report of police attack
Photo report of police attack on the Kasbah
What the kids
What the kids think
Se acabó la
Se acabó la libertad
machine translation
Apparently, capital has found
Apparently, capital has found its man for Tunisia (or so they hope):
Tunisian Islamist leader Rachid Ghannouchi returns home
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-12318824
FLPT Front de Libération
FLPT Front de Libération Populaire de la Tunisie is on Facebook
Closer to a libertarian position (?) than anything else I've seen so far. My French isn't up to much though so maybe someone else could give an opinion. Am I justified in borrowing the avatar?
Fuego bajo las
Fuego bajo las cenizas
machine translation
Interview with Islamist
Interview with Islamist leader Rashid Al-Ghannouchi
Machine translation of one of
Machine translation of one of the texts from their facebook page:
http://www.hs.facebook.com/pages/FLPT-Front-de-Liberation-Populaire-de-la-Tunisie/180942368603909?v=wall#!/note.php?note_id=494233542326&id=719697600
Some of the form (people's committees, excluding those who'd run for elections) look quite positive. A lot of the content/demands look like standard liberal ones, although in the context of Tunisia likely that reflects what a lot of people want at this point - and it's calling for a front so you'd kinda expect that. The main things that stick out are the faith in the unions (didn't the main one already demobilise people as soon as the new government was set up?) and in the army - apart from the generally democratic tone.
Would be great if someone who actually understands French could have a look and try to figure out if this is representative, it looks a lot like the sort of thing that broad coalitions (or groups hoping to become such) might come out with, and it has some bits that are a bit self-contradictory as well.
http://www.lemonde.fr/tunisie
http://www.lemonde.fr/tunisie/article/2011/01/21/le-debat-entre-militants-politiques-tunisiens-se-poursuit-en-france_1468903_1466522.html names a spokesperson of the FPLT who is also labelled a long time activist of the UGTT
The repression from the new,
The repression from the new, or not so new, regime continues...
"Going through a friend we let Al Jazeera know about the news received from Sfax. The answer is sincere: 'Tunisia isn't an international issue any more, it's a local issue.'"
La estrategia de la tensión
Alma Allende
machine translation
From the EA
From the EA liveblog
...failing to mention that the demo on Ave. Bourghiba was attacked by police with teargas and sticks as it was breaking up anyway.
On twitter just now -
On twitter just now - something seems to be kicking off but I'm not sure what
le Parisien Quote: Hundreds
le Parisien
zawya.com Quote: TUNIS, Feb
zawya.com
UN reports higher death toll
UN reports higher death toll from Tunisia unrest
New union formed, the CGTT.
New union formed, the CGTT. There were previous attempts to set it up a few years ago.
Naissance du second syndicat de l'histoire de la Tunisie
More about the CGTT. The
More about the CGTT. The first link is to a statement from them. It might be useful if someone with better French than me had a look at it. I'm assuming they will be closer to the autonomous unions in Algeria and Morocco and to the CNT-F and Spanish CGT, but I'd welcome any views on this.
La CGTT réclame sa légalisation
Facebook page
Some background, though it's history now
Mark. wrote: More about the
Mark.
Mmm. I'm afraid, going on the texts on their site, it appears more Blairite than revolutionary syndicalist.
Here's a rough translation of part of their position paper on syndicalism in the modern era
from Le pluralisme syndical : passage obligé du renouveau syndicaliste
I doubt the CNT-F or the Spanish CGT would recognise themselves in this vision of a new unionism for our times.
ocelot wrote: I doubt the
ocelot
Actually I suspect from some of the wording in the text you've translated that it reflects discussion in the Euro-Mediterranean union network (Red Sindical Euro-Mediterránea, previously the Red Sindical Euro-Magrebi before Egypt was drawn into it.).
There were no Tunisians at the last meeting in Oran on 16 January, but this may be because they were otherwise occupied with events in Tunisia. The unions and groups that were present were the ODT from Morocco, SNAPAP, CLA and CNES from Algeria, the CGT from Spain and the CNT-F and Solidaires from France. Tunisians have gone to some of the previous meetings. Other European unions at previous meetings have included USI-Roma and a couple of the Italian base unions, I think Unicobas and CUB. The CGTT was also at the i07.
zabalaza
Towards an anarcho-syndicalist strategy for Africa
ocelot
I don't see anything revolutionary in the text you translated, but is there anything anti-revolutionary (or 'Blairite') either? I'm not suggesting that the CGTT or the other autonomous unions in North Africa are ideologically anarcho-syndicalist or revolutionary syndicalist. Possibly some of the European base unions might be a better comparison. Again I'm open to other people's views on this.
Mark. wrote: ocelot
Mark.
Well there's no "Clause 4" for any Blair like figure to remove. I.e. there's no explicit committment to the emancipation of the workers, socialising the means of production, ending capitalism or class society. It's very much about modernising and adapting to the changes brought about by globalisation and neoliberalism so as not only to counter their negative effects, but to embrace the opportunities that their "positive side" presents.
Certainly there's themes in the mix that reflect the social movement unionism discourse of Solidaires, but in a form that I'm pretty sure Tony Giddens would also be happy with.
Of course you can't really tell the political content of an organisation from its published documents in isolation from any information about it's actual practice.
I guess the key thing here is really what does the CGTT represent in terms of the struggle of grassroots union miltancy against the RCD-compromised ruling clique at the federal centre of the UGTT? That is a question we cannot answer without direct information from union militants in places like Gafsa, Kasserine and Sidi Bouzid.
Perhaps the CGTT is simply Habib Guiza's personal fiefdom down in Gabès and the South of the country, motivated by local resentment at the dominance of both RCD and UGTT politics by people from the Sahel? Who knows? OK, dumb question, Tunisians will know.
But I think the key question is whether the union militants in the Western interior, especially those who got so badly screwed over by the state and the UGTT leadership in the 2008 struggle, consider the CGTT to be a useful alternative, or a distraction from the struggle to wrest control of the UGTT from the Jerad clique.
We need interviews with militants. There's no viable substitute for exploring any of these questions.
edit: this HRW piece on the CGTT's struggles against Tunisian state repression, prior to Jan 14th is a good backgrounder, also - HRW: The Price of Independence
Apropos of the union stuff.
Apropos of the union stuff. Here's the UGTT's "appeal" to the participants of the the 24-hour sit-in outside the PM offices on the Kasbah esplanade, issued last Friday the 28th - when the protesters were violently cleared out with batons and CS gas by the cops (while the world was watching events in Egypt).
Appel aux participants au Sit-in de la Kasbah
translation: Sorry 'bout the beating guys, we got you a bus back home to the sticks. Why don't you, like, set up a committee or something? We'll be in touch...
From CGT North Africa En
From CGT North Africa
En Túnez sigue el pulso entre el pueblo y el gobierno
machine translation
From Alma Allende ¿Quién
From Alma Allende
¿Quién gobierna Túnez?
machine translation
------
Entrevista a Fahem Boukadous, periodista y militante del Partido Comunista Obrero de Túnez
machine translation
Sit-in of Tunisian External
Sit-in of Tunisian External Communication Agency (ATCE) staff
Unconfirmed report on EA
Unconfirmed report on EA liveblog
Confirmation... Quote: Four
Confirmation...
Photo from Sidi Bouzid today
Photo from Sidi Bouzid today - I'm not really sure what this is about
Edit: see last paragraph of next post
One dead in fresh
One dead in fresh anti-government unrest
Tunisian minister suspends ex-ruling party
Fresh violence erupts in
Fresh violence erupts in Tunisia (Al Jazeera)
What the heck is going on in Tunisia while camera lenses watch Egypt?
Video: Sidi Bouzid
Video: Sidi Bouzid yesterday
On twitter
Congressional Research
Congressional Research Service: political transition in Tunisia (pdf)
Guardian live updates
Union leader speaks out
Union leader speaks out against UGTT recognition of Ghannouchi government
Tunisia calls up reserve troops amid unrest
Tunisia protest town fears for unfinished revolution
Change comes to Tunisia,
Change comes to Tunisia, slowly (Al Jazeera)
Thanks for keeping on
Thanks for keeping on reporting what's happening in Tunisia, now everyone is looking at Egypt
From Alma Allende De Paisaje
From Alma Allende
De Paisaje a territorio: tres días en el sur de Túnez (1) -- Gafsa
machine translation
Reports on twitter of trouble
Reports on twitter of trouble in Sousse today
Tunisia finds its voice -
Tunisia finds its voice - Issandr el Amrani
New signs of unrest
http://www.babtounes.com/ Quo
http://www.babtounes.com/
There's an element of
There's an element of repetition in what follows, but it seems like there's a pattern emerging here of castigating "the mob" as paid goons of an RCD conspiracy, when the detail suggests that what the mob is actually protesting about is the cops and the now officially "not RCD any more" government.
le Parisien: Tunisie : encore des violences dans plusieurs villes
[* probably best as 'parade of ambulances', but ballet was too cool to translate]
Note the use of the union official to label the protesters as goons paid by RCD. Another source mentions Raouf Hadoui was backed up in this claim by another union boss, Abdelatif Bouguera.
le Figaro: Tunisie: des gouverneurs chahutés
AFP: Tunisie: le gouvernement avance à petit pas, l'armée rappelle des réservistes
So the government are no longer the RCD and the protesters now trying to get them out are part of an RCD conspiracy against the revolution. And the UGTT agree. Just so we're clear on that.
From Alma Allende Tres días
From Alma Allende
Tres días en el sur de Túnez (2) -- Redeyef y Moulares, vecinos y extremos
machine translation
More on that power-of-decree
More on that power-of-decree story
AA: Tunisia leader gets wide powers
Just to fill in some gaps in
Just to fill in some gaps in information here and there:
On Monday 7th, the demonstration outside Parliament apparently involved a blockade aimed at preventing the MPs from getting into Parliament where the power-by-decree law was being proposed (considering that this power-by-decree law is being presented as something that
it's not clear to me whether this is just a bullshit justification which the demonstration was opposing, or whether the demonstrators support the old government party, which seems unlikely; any ideas?).
Same day an RCD building in Tozeur was set on fire.
8th Feb:
In Bizerte the army intervened to allow the governor to retake his offices.
In Kairouan, the main road leading to the centre of town was blocked by demonstrators who set fire to tyres and looted a service station before the army came and fired warning shots.
In Gabès and in Nabeul, the new governors were forced to leave their government buildings, protected by the military. In Kébili, the governor left the county.
In La Manouba, there were protests by temp workers and building workers.
In Zaghouan, high school students and council workers managed to get the governor to quit.
Demonstrations in front of the governors' HQs in Siliana, Medenine, Monastir and Tozeur.
In Béja, the governor also quit his post after a sit-in.
In Ariana, during a similar demonstration, youths tried to seize the governor's HQ but were repulsed by the army.
In Sousse, depots of the port were looted and demonstrators also managed to get the governor to quit.
In the Hichria area of Sidi Bouzid, after the forbidding of a peaceful march and warning shots in the air by the cops, the building of the national guard, and the residence and car of the chief of the national guard, were set on fire as well as the HQ of "l'association d'intérêt commun" ( translation: "the association of common interests"). There was some looting as well.
Teachers' strikes in Sfax and transport drivers strikes in Bizerte.
Information in French gleaned here (of course we never know how much of this is exaggerated or misleading in some other way; these sites get their information from all over the place and can't possibly check them up):
http://juralibertaire.over-blog.com/
http://dndf.org/
__________
From Alma Allende Tres días
From Alma Allende
Tres días en el sur de Túnez (3) -- Qasserine, humillados y ofendidos
machine translation
France refuses to allow
France refuses to allow Tunisian activists in (Edu factory)
From CGT North Africa En
From CGT North Africa
En Túnez sigue la presión en la calle. Avances y retrocesos en el proceso democrático
machine translation
.
Llamamiento de mujeres tunecinas / Appel de femmes tunisiennes
machine translation
From
From Reuters
FEATURE-Tunisia's long-hidden poor seize public land
also, apropos de rien, this from Guardian thread
Reuters Quote: Tunisian
Reuters
Alma Allende Laicismo y
Alma Allende
Laicismo y democracia ----- machine translation
Otra vez la Qasba ----- machine translation
-----
English translations of other articles on Tunisia by Alma Allende
If you haven't read them in the Spanish or struggled through the machine translations these are worth looking at.
Over 100,000 marching in
Over 100,000 marching in Tunis today.
Tunis today...
Tunis today...
[youtube]y2MZFynbe28[/youtube]
Gafsa
Gafsa
[youtube]UUguRQTL09c[/youtube]
Police fire tear gas to
Police fire tear gas to disperse new Tunisia protest
Alma Allende Venezuela en la
Alma Allende
Venezuela en la Qasba
machine translation
Live firing by police in Tunis yesterday, one protester killed
Guardian Quote: 4.02pm:
Guardian
AFP report on yesterday's
AFP report on yesterday's protests
Four dead in Tunisia after
Four dead in Tunisia after renewed violence
This video appears to be from today's clashes
EA Liveblog: Quote: 1510
EA Liveblog:
EA liveblog Quote: 1950 GMT:
EA liveblog
Guardian - another ZABA era
Guardian - another ZABA era cabinet member resigns.
Alma Allende Ghanoushi cae,
Alma Allende
Ghanoushi cae, la Qasba sigue en pie
machine translation
The Tunisian equivalent of
The Tunisian equivalent of "disgusted of Tunbridge Wells" articulates the local version of the Daily Mail perspective. However much I may find the general politics of the statement repellant, there are some interesting details, plus it's a useful reality check to keep tabs on anti-left perspectives.
from Angry Arab blog
That is pretty much the
That is pretty much the development we could expect coming from these revolts; an eventual polarisation of class relations based on conflicting expectations of the aftermath, with the middle class rallying round the state as a force of order and helping reconstitute the new regime. Meanwhile the poor - while gaining valuable experience of collective self-organisation, cohesion and a few concessions - confront many of the same economic realities as before.
Quote: the middle class
Don't you understand? - "middle class" is just a sociological category.
A footnote to a long article
A footnote to a long article about Algeria on the Moor Next Door blog
I think the chimera of the
I think the chimera of the "middle class majority" always rests on a more or less explicit decomposition of the class along indentitarian lines. Whether it be racism as in the US, or more regional considerations as apparently in the Tunisian case. All the evidence is that there is a strong tension between the coastal "core" of Tunis and the Sahel (the north east coast around the Gulf of Hammamet, including Sousse) and the "periphery" of the interior - Kef, Gafsa, Kasserine, Sidi Bouzid; and the excluded southern coastal towns of Sfax and Gabès. Having said that, the perspective outlined in the piece above seems to assume that all the people in those core cities are of one mind, regardless of their place in the actual social hierarchy or how many of the low-status workers in the "core" are in fact migrants from the impoverished regions, and might be expected not to share the quasi-racist characterisation of their home townsfolk as illiterate and "ga'rah".
Although the general pattern of a movement of reaction getting itself together in the weeks and months following the initial moment of rupture in the ongoing transformative process, to defend their positions in the economic and political niches they held in the ancien regime, is common. What is interesting is that this is couched in a discourse that is not primarily nationalistic or religious, but more explicitly class based (even if to the subjectively delineated "middle class") and founded on (capitalist) economic rationality.
'Tunisia frees last political
'Tunisia frees last political prisoners'
At least that's what the headline says
I don't want to derail too
I don't want to derail too much here, but the denial of the middle class as anything but a "subjective" "chimera" or "sociological" category is of no use when trying to analyse these events and how class relations will develop. (Note that Egyptian bloggers refer to the obvious existence of a middle class and their ability to organise and represent their interests politically - surely not mere "chimerical" deluded "subjectivity".) If a class is portrayed as existing without any material/economic basis to its emergence and continued existence but the "chimera" of "subjectivity", well that may be an amusing ideological conjuring trick but not one that will fool many people outside the confines of libcom, least of all those in more strictly delineated countries outside the West. Trying to reduce it to racist/regional attitudes is also unconvincing.
I said the "middle class
I said the "middle class majority" was the chimera. Do you believe that the majority of Tunisia's 10.5 m people are middle class? What is the material/economic basis of this class? Do you also accept that if the majority are middle class, then the remaining rump minority (other than the rich) must therefore be an underclass of marginals and excluded, that, by the same token the working class no longer exists?
Quote: Do you believe that
Not at all, though recent govt. figures may be the source of such claims; http://www.subzeroblue.com/archives/2007/08/tunisia_747_thousand.html
Sorry if I misunderstood - partly cos at the end you said "the subjectively delineated "middle class"", which could apply to such a category whatever its relative size. I'm misjudging you due to such a viewpoint being oft-expressed on libcom as "2-class 'theory'". I assumed you were denying the m/c its genuine independent material existence as anything more than subjective, sociological etc - so subsuming the middle class into the working class, as has been common on libcom. In my arguing against that fictional categorisation I apparently made you think I was trying to do similar - ie subsuming the working class into the middle class.
Red Marriott
Red Marriott
OK, the original is actually far better than that blogger's re-interpretation. Unfortunately for English reader's it's in French, but a hack translation of one section in the original:
So the 80% middle class figure is key claim in the Ben Ali story of what great things the RCD have done in Tunisia, based on a patently absurd interpretation of the national statistics.
Red Marriott
That's a much bigger debate, which probably would be a derail. But briefly my own position is, I guess, somewhat ambiguous. On the one hand I do reject the orthodox Marxist conception of objectively existing class with subjective false consciousness. But I do relate class to situation within the relations of production, rather than simple income level. I would take an operaisti/autonomist conception of a historical dynamic between technical composition of social production and political (de-/re-)composition. That is, that even though class has material foundations in the technical composition, subjectivity is necessarily the form of appearance of class, as interests must be aprehended/constructed within consciousnesses. So, like Malatesta against Monatte, the existence of material relations of dispossession, exploitation etc, does not mean that the emergence of a self-awareness of common class interests, overriding all capitalism's competitive pressures that set sectional interests against each other, is neither automatic nor apolitical.
So even though situations such as those managing workers either for the benefit of a capitalist enterprise or, more nebulously, for the benefit of capitalist society as a whole (and there are big differences between those two) can lead to the individuals involved seeing their interests as distinct and sometimes opposed to those of the working class. But, OTOH, the subjectivity of alienation from and opposition to working class interests, is simply too good for capitalists to let lie. Hence Thatcher's "we're all middle class now", not to mention the US discourse that assumes that the vast bulk of the North American working class is middle class by dint of either a) not living in a trailer park, or b) not being ghettoised and black (slight caricature).
What I would say in relation to MENA countries and other regions gradually emerging out from the neo-colonial frying pan (and into the global money market fire), is that there are strong divisions in the technical composition, almost as if there were different economies, first and third world, now operating side by side within the same territory. So on the one hand you would have a workforce incorporated into the salaried, (relatively) 'guaranteed' sector, with access to consumer credit (mortgages, bank accounts, credit cards, car loans, etc) and an interaction with the globalised economy. On another hand a relatively small section of workforce still labouring in the old neo/colonial economy, often under almost serf-like conditions. And a larger, ever-expanding un- or under-employed labour force that currently has no real place in either economic sector but must scrabble around in the informal sector or rely on family or clan charity.
Because the material gulf between the first sector and the other two is huge, you could see how a middle class identity could potentially accrete around the first sector in relation to the other two. In Argentina we saw this in the 1990s when the employed, "first world" sector looked on the activities of the piqueteros with disdain or even violent hostility. It was only with the crisis of December 2001 when the global worker or "middle class" sector lost the contents of their bank accounts, followed in many cases by their jobs, that you had a reconciliation between cacerolazos and piqueteros and a recognition of common interests (however brief).
AFP Quote: Tunisia unveils
AFP
edit: additional details from Reuters
Interior ministry announces
Interior ministry announces that it is disbanding the State Security Department
EA liveblog Quote: 0855 GMT:
EA liveblog
Reports from a CGT delegation
Reports from a CGT delegation to Tunisia
Crónicas desde Túnez (1) ----- machine translation
Crónicas desde Túnez (2) ----- machine translation
Crónicas desde Túnez (3) ----- machine translation
I'm not sure these reports dig very deep but it's interesting that some of the towns where the uprising started still seem to be under the control of committees to safeguard the revolution.
Quote: Tunisian boat people
- from here.
Part 4 of the CGT reports.
Part 4 of the CGT reports. This one is an analysis of the Tunisian unions and is worth reading. The machine translation is more or less readable.
Crónicas desde Túnez (4). La UGTT: entre la traición y la lucha.
machine translation
Part 5 of the CGT
Part 5 of the CGT reports
Crónicas desde Túnez (5) La mujer tunecina y su revolución
machine translation
Part 6 - the movement of
Part 6 - the movement of unemployed graduates
Crónicas desde Túnez (6) El movimiento de l@s parad@s: un proceso incontenible
machine translation
Part 7 - the committees to
Part 7 - the committees to safeguard the revolution
Crónicas desde Túnez (7) Los comités de salvaguardia de la revolución. El ejemplo de Bizerta
Edit: The FdCA has now started translating these reports over on Anarkismo
--------------------------------------------------------------------
The Committees to Safeguard the Revolution: the example of Bizerte
Since 14th January numerous committees to safeguard the revolution have been set up in many places throughout the country, with a variety of forms, constitutions and functions.
Municipal bodies almost everywhere in Tunisia have been swept away, and temporary bodies for managing municipalities have taken their place. The form and make-up of these institutions depends on the balance of forces in each locality. In some cases, they have been created on the basis of proposals by the committees to safeguard the revolution, in others they maintain links with the old local political bosses.
The Bizerte committee to safeguard the revolution
Bizerte is a city of 200,000 inhabitants (the province, or governorate, has around 700,000) and lies on the Mediterranean coast at a distance of 66 km from the capital, Tunis.
Around 25 people, mostly women, are waiting for us at the House of Culture (now run by the committee to safeguard the revolution) to exchange experiences and ideas with us.
The Bizerte committee is of an open, assembly-based nature. Between 500 and 1,000 people attend the meetings, where decisions are made. The committee is then responsible for implementing these decisions. People attend as individuals, not as representatives of parties and trade unions. The main force is the Union of Unemployed Graduates who have organized more than 10 branches in the province, in addition to the one in Bizerte. Lawyers, teachers, trade unionists and young people all participate in the provisional running of the city. The assembly has elected 25 people to the City Council, which was submitted to the governor of the province.
It seeks to foster participation and direct democracy. Each person has the right to vote at the assembly and everything is done to make sure the interests of all rather than party interests are catered for. It also seeks to encourage people to be active in everyday tasks. It is clearly run as an example of an attempt at counterpower and social self-management.
A difficult task ahead
We discuss the lack of experience in taking on so many responsibilities and the need for training and cooperation. On the one hand, it seeks to continue the process of dissolving all of the dictatorship's apparatus of repression. We talk about the example of El Kef, a town where the committee to safeguard the revolution has produced a dossier containing the photos of all the corrupt individuals and those who were involved in repression. But also about the biased judiciary and government who have freed the police officers and corrupt individuals who were brought to justice by the people.
On the other hand, we also discuss the process of building a new society that will carry on a consistent struggle against unemployment, defend human rights, establish new economic and political criteria that can enhance strong cooperation between the workers and the people as a whole.
Factory closures
More than 4,500 metal workers from Menzel Bourguiba, in the governorate of Bizerte, are on strike against the threat of a lockout. The bosses have responded to the creation of a union in the factories and the state of mobilization and worker participation with layoffs and relocations. Shipyards have been the traditional industry in the area. Employers are now seeing their profits threatened and are trying to move to other countries or else waiting for better times, for the revolutionary tide to subside.
Mutual aid - a necessity
The Bizerte comrades tell us: "There has been an insurrection in Tunisia, now we need a revolution". And for that, they need help: publicity, information, training, support of all kinds.
Our discussions brought up the idea of twinning the committee to safeguard the revolution with European bodies (federations, trade unions, associations, etc.) with a commitment to maintain an ongoing relationship where information on the activities and needs of the committee can be exchanged, together with practical mutual aid.
After the talks, we visited the former premises of the political police that were burned down by the people. This was a tangible expression of the people's strength against the dictatorship. But now there remains the hardest task of all: that of making sure that change does not remain a purely formal affair, a new coat of paint on the old house. Change must mean a real, profound transformation of this society.
Our commitment and our support is needed. How? By following with interest the current situation of what is happening in Tunisia, by taking part in the campaign to cancel Tunisia's foreign debt, by twinning with the committees to safeguard the revolution, through solidarity and support for the struggles of the workers, the unemployed and the Tunisian people. But also, through our struggles at home, fighting our own governments and multinationals, the accomplices of Ben Ali who still keep to their neo-colonial view of the countries of North Africa, the back yard of the European Union.
Solidarity and mutual aid with the people of Tunisia.
Mouatamid
North Africa Working Group of the CGT International Secretariat
First published (in Spanish) on 19 April 2011.
Translation of part
Translation of part 1
--------------------------------------------------------------------
The voice from the streets is clear: the revolution in Tunisia has just begun
Avenue Habib Bourguiba is a hive of activity. The hum of debate rebounds on all sides. From the steps outside the Municipal Theatre, the megaphone is passed from hand to hand. People talking, shouting, freely stating that the revolution must go on. Ben Ali has not gone away: his political police, though hidden, is still at work, his web of corruption is still in place, his people from the Constitutional Democratic Rally (RCD) are still there, though today mixed in with various political parties and are preparing for the right moment to return to power, which they never really left.
Calls for a "Third Kasbah" are repeated, spread and discussed in the streets. It is the response to the words of the new prime minister Essebsi, who speaks with the arrogance of power and a legitimacy that the people have not given him. And the people have responded. They say that they are still there, alive and well, and have no intention of yielding easily to a "normality" that does not involve real change in Tunisian society.
From all those places where social isolation and exclusion is the norm, from Sidi Bouzid, Redeyef, Thala, Kasserine... spreading throughout the whole country, the Tunisian people on the streets carried on this revolution of dignity. No office, no hidden power, no party, no-one drew up their programme. It is the people of Tunisia themselves who have been writing their own history, not with jasmine, but with the dignity and the blood of their young, their martyrs.
During the First Kasbah, the caravan of the revolution, thousands of people from the poorest areas of Tunisia all over the country occupied the Prime Ministry in the Kasbah from Sunday 23rd January until the 28th, when they were brutally evicted. They had no intention of accepting a government where the majority of members were in Ben Ali's party, starting with his prime minister, Ghannouchi.
With the Second Kasbah, Ghannouchi was toppled. They had already brought down two governments after the fall of the dictator. The Tunisian people took yet another step forward, ignoring the support being offered Ghannouchi's government by the European Union and the United States. The main police chiefs from the Ben Ali era were removed from their positions, political prisoners were freed and the RCD was dissolved but the people wanted still more. The counter-revolution had not been stopped.
April 1st. Calls for a Third Kasbah have brought together several thousand people. It has become impossible to reach the Kasbah square. Police and military personnel control access points. The army is also visible on the streets. Tanks and trucks everywhere. Along the road leading to the square, several police cordons block the way of those who are gathering. There are impromptu speeches by the people. Meher, a young man who has been vocal in the debates, talked to me about the revolution, about how the murderers are going unpunished and the corrupt go free. They want real change. They want to destroy the whole party-state apparatus. They want another Tunisia. They have no trust in parties or trade unions. They know that their strength keeps them on the streets.
Suddenly, the crowd starts moving. Some are receding, most are pushing towards the police. It seems that the police have started to charge - then the pushing starts, blows, stones fly, paving stones are ripped up and the air fills with tear gas, causing the crowd to disperse into the streets of the Medina.
But the gas follows us through the streets. An asthmatic comrade from the CGT falls to the ground in a faint. But the people are here. From the houses come women, men, children, to care for the wounded. Milk, lemon, blankets... everything. A young girl gives my comrade some ventolin. And kisses her on the forehead out of respect. The love and solidarity of the people. Another comrade from Solidaires has got lost and is overcome by the gas. The same response. He is quickly welcomed into a house to for treatment and to avoid arrest. There have been about twenty arrests, they tell us.
People are already arriving on the Avenue Habib Bourguiba and gathering in front of the Municipal Theatre. There are discussions and debates. A young student talks to us, aware that he is an important part of what is happening. He rejects the continued interference by the West in his country's affairs, our sense of superiority. He speaks of a tolerant Tunisia, where people can live together and build a different democracy, more real than ours. He breathes conviction and self-confidence from every pore. He is the image of a people which is organizing itself, which has hope and the ability to build and move forward.
The unemployed university graduates have mobilized and are organizing themselves. In just two months 45,000 unemployed people have come together in real grassroots organizations. Committees for safeguarding the revolution are everywhere, some whose operations are more closed (coordination of organizations), some more open (assembly-based). In practice, many municipalities are being run by them. Big protests are being prepared against the government if it fails to dismantle the old apparatus of power and does not send those responsible for murders committed during the revolution to prison.
And all this time, the debates of the councils working on constitutional changes and preparing new elections, initially scheduled for 25th July, the struggles and alliances between political parties, continue. The situation is difficult. And there is no shortage of people with an interest in slowing down the process or using to their own advantage.
But the voice from the streets is clear. The revolution in Tunisia has just begun.
First published (in Spanish) on Saturday 6 April 2011.
English translation by FdCA-International Relations Office
From english
From english Wikipedia
Translation of part 2 of the
Translation of part 2 of the CGT reports
--------------------------------------------------------------------
In the heart of Tunisia. Thala: the occupied police station
Thala, Kasserine governorate (province), 300 kms from the capital. A poor city, on the fringe, whose only resourse is agriculture which depends on rainfall: wheat, prickly pears... without industry.
Upon our arrival, we were surprised to find an outdoor museum filled with graffiti. Graffiti demanding freedom and dignity, against Ben Ali and his henchmen, tributes to the 6 who died in the revolution, a sign of the inhabitants' desire to be true to their memory. The free expression of the people on the walls of this small, abandoned city of the Tunisian interior.
Young people throng around us to see us taking pictures of the graffiti. They tell us the story of their struggle. As early as 24th December they held their first solidarity march with Sidi Bouzid, where the first call in all of Tunisia was made demanding the fall of Ben Ali. On 3 January, students from the town's two schools - one at each end of the city - decided to protest. The principals of the schools called parents in an attempt to stop the students taking to the streets. But they only achieved the opposite: the parents joined their children and all the people took to the streets in a peaceful demonstration.
The hated Colonel Youssef Abdelaziz ordered to fire on the demonstrators. Marouan Jemli, 19, was the first martyr in Thala. The struggle not to lose his body, fearing that the police would try to hide their crime, caused a second death - another 19-year-old. Finally, the young people were able to carry Marouan's body to his grandmother's house after a 10-hour walk over mountain trails.
Marouan's funeral was used by the criminal colonel Youssef as an opportunity to shoot at the people carrying the coffin. A 32-year-old comrade who was preparing for his wedding in March and a disabled man were both hit by police bullets and died beside the coffin, the latter with five bullets in his body! The mothers had originally tried to carry the coffin themselves (in Muslim culture, it is the men who accompany the dead to the cemetery), but the young men instead had decided to carry it.
Between 3rd and 6th January, Thala - a town of 15,000 inhabitants - was completely surrounded by 1,800 police. It was impossible to leave or to enter. Supplies of water, bread and sugar were cut off. Cries were heard in every corner of Thala, "YES to bread and water, NO to Ben Ali". 150 people were imprisoned and a great many young men, women and children were tortured and abused. But through Facebook and other social networks, the young were able to publish videos of the repression and publicize the police murder of 5 young people and their siege of the town.
On 8th January, Col. Youssef was overthrown and replaced by another police chief. But the movement had spread throughout Tunisia and the rebellion had reached the capital. On 12th January, yet another person was killed by the police outside his home. New police chief, new murder.
The orders to the police in the early days were clear: crush the rebellion in the Sidi Bouzid and Kasserine (home to Thala) governorates in order to prevent it from spreading to the rest of Tunisia. The 1,800 police officers who surrounded the town for days had clear orders to kill, to crush resistance, like elsewhere.
Thala, a town without police, without a municipality, managed by the people
But Thala, a town with a revolutionary tradition, resisted and won. Today, there are no police in town. Young people take it in turns to deal with security. Only the military presence reminds us that there is a state.
The committee to safeguard the revolution runs the town and has "justice for our dead" as its prime demand. They have submitted a list of people involved in the killings, complete with names, and for 17 days in March they organized demonstrations to demand the imprisonment and trial of the murderers. The Justice Department of the interim government has asked for 15 days in which to respond. If in the first week of April there is no answer, the struggle will be taken up again.
They do not recognize President Fouad Mebazaa, nor prime minister Beji Caid Essebsi. They are calling for the dissolution of the three councils that have been created: the political and constitutional reform council, the council investigating the repression since 17th December and the anti-corruption council. They do not trust them, as they were created by Ghannouchi and are filled with people from Ben Ali's RCD party. How can they investigate themselves?
The police station transformed into a social centre
After the death of Marouan, his friends were consumed with anger. One of them, filling his motorbike with petrol, set it on fire and crashed it into the police station, causing a fire that forced the police to leave the town.
On 17th February, Nemri Bassem, a mechanical engineer unemployed since 2004, occupied the police station and stayed there, demanding his right to work. This action is only one of hundreds of actions that have been carried out in Tunisia by the Union of Unemployed Graduates.
Nemri is not alone. Many young people joined him for his hours at the police station, which has today been converted into a place where you can listen to music, play cards and talk about revolution.
We said goodbye to Thala. Marouan's father points out to us the place where they killed his son: "I will never forget this place". And so says the graffiti that he did there.
Neither will the Tunisian people forget.
M.H.
Translation by FdCA-International Relations Office
Part
Part 4
--------------------------------------------------------------------
The UGTT: caught between struggle and betrayal
The Union Générale Tunisienne du Travail (UGTT - Tunisian General Labour Union), the sole union in Tunisia up to now, has for many years played an ambiguous role as part of the dictatorial state apparatus with multiple links to the ruling party while being at the same time the centre of combative, independent trade unionism.
Both poles have coexisted because they needed each other. The UGTT's bureaucratic leadership apparatus has needed, and now needs more than ever, this veneer of militancy and struggle that the militant sector gives the union in order to maintain its share of power within the state apparatus and to survive the dictatorship in circumstances such as those at present. For its part, the militant sector has found in the UGTT the infrastructure that is essential if it is to reach the workers and enjoy legal coverage, even though that coverage has often not prevented repression in such a context where there is a total lack of freedoms.
A little history
As in most North African countries, the first Tunisian trade union was created following the example of French syndicalism. In 1924, Mohamed Ali El Hammi and Mohamed Tahar Haddad created the first workers' organization in Tunisia, the Confédération générale des travailleurs tunisiens (CGTT - General Confederation of Tunisian Workers), which was quickly repressed by the colonial authorities.
In 1946, after a process of union-building lasting two years from south to north, the UGTT, the first union in North Africa, with Farhat Hached (later killed by extremist French colonists) and Ahmed Tlili leading it. From its birth the UGTT was closely linked to the nationalist movement and marked by the subordination of the class struggle to the struggle for national independence, a condition which determined its dependence on the new national state apparatus.
During the Bourguiba dictatorship there were ongoing tensions between its submission to the single party and a certain autonomy that allowed it to put pressure on the power in the '60s and '70s. The general strikes of '78 and the bread revolt of 1984 amounted to the highest levels of confrontation and repression against the UGTT by the State, and many union activists suffered long years in prison.
The UGTT and Bel Ali
In 1989, Ben Ali's regime imposed direct submission on the UGTT leadership, led by Ismail Sahbani, who collaborated in the implementation of neoliberal economic policies and fought the trade union left fiercely. Tried and convicted for embezzlement, he was replaced at the congress of Djerba in 2002 by the current secretary general, Abdessalem Jerad.
The double game played by the UGTT leadership
The history of the leadership of the UGTT is a story of betrayal and manoeuvring. From its support for Ben Ali's candidacy in the elections of 2004 and 2009 to social welfare reform, from the implementation of neoliberal economic measures to their abandoning of the Gafsa UGTT activists, jailed during the 2008 uprising, when they limited themselves to a simple request for the release of the prisoners.
Surprised by the uprisings in Sidi Bouzid and Kasserine, the leadership only permitted strikes at the local or regional level and demands for democratic reforms once the rebel movement had spread throughout the country and many local unions had become directly involved. A general strike in Tunis was not called until 14th January. And on 13th, Abdessalem Jerad, secretary general of the UGTT, was in talks with Ben Ali, looking for solutions to the situation. A week earlier, he had allowed students and unemployed workers who had locked themselves into the premises of the UGTT in Tunis to be violently evicted by the police, and many of them were tortured and imprisoned.
After Ben Ali had fled, the leadership agreed to participate in Mohamed Ghannouchi's provisional government of national unity with 3 ministers, before withdrawing their representatives under pressure from the people on the streets and the UGTT's more radical wing. While people were fighting Ghannouchi's government on the streets, the leadership of the UGTT called for a "government of national salvation", without clarifying what it was to be or how it was to be made up, in an attempt to please everyone.
UGTT involvement in the Tunisian revolution
As I said in the first paragraph, the UGTT has always been an area of convergence for militant trade unionism and the struggle against power. With most opposition political parties banned, with any other trade-union option prohibited and with any organized structure not controlled by the government suffocated (such as the Tunisian League for Human Rights - LTDH, restricted to its central premises in Tunis, always guarded by the political police and prevented from organizing any public event), the UGTT remained the only place from which it was possible to struggle against the system and where the various militant sectors were obliged to work together in order to deal with the union bureaucracy. This historical reality has allowed the formation within the UGTT of a current that for years has struggle for common goals - the radicalization of the UGTT, an end to the dictatorship and internal union democracy, at a price of enormous sacrifice (prison, exclusions, etc.) - and has reinforced its presence in the intermediate levels (general unions, regional unions, etc.) and, consequently, the National Administrative Committee.
All this has resulted in the UGTT playing an important political role in the popular revolt in Tunisia. Involved from the start of the uprising in Sidi Bouziz, its premises have been open, in most cases, for the purpose of organizing demonstrations - often being the starting point of marches. It has organized rallies, marches and regional general strikes in various governorates and is currently committees involved in the committees to safeguard the revolution.
Whither the UGTT?
The coexistence of such conflicting trends within the same organization has been possible due to the situation of dictatorship and lack of freedom. It is still too early to know what the outcome of the Tunisian democratic transition will be and, indeed, the outcome of the next UGTT congress, but it is clear that both issues will influence the maintenance of UGTT as a single union.
The processes of popular self-organizing that are in progress, such as the Union of Unemployed Graduates or the committees to safeguard the revolution, to the extent that they are maintained and consolidated, will influence the future of the UGTT. Even taking into account the weight of a tradition of trade-union unity in the UGTT, in terms of democratic freedoms, sooner or later the impossibility bureaucratic unionism controlled by the state and autonomous, militant trade unionism will manifest itself.
Other options: the CGTT
In 2006, a group of former leaders of the UGTT decided to create the Confédération Générale Tunisienne du Travail (CGTT - Tunisian General Confederation of Labour) as an alternative to the UGTT's dependence on the state.
However, the failure to legalize the union meant a cessation of its activities, and it focused almost exclusively on the celebration each year of a summer school for union training through the Association Club Mohamed Ali de la Culture Ouvriere (Mohamed Ali Club Association for Working-Class Culture, the name Mohamed Ali being a reference to the founder of the original CGTT).
On 1st February 2011, the CGTT was finally legalized and began organizing. However, it is still developing a clear union line and, more worryingly, its seems to be somewhat aloof and uninvolved in the current revolutionary process. From 3rd to 5th December, it is due to hold its first congress, where the line will be established together with its trade-union practice.
The former secretary general of the UGTT, Ismail Sahbani, has also created a third union, the Union of Tunisian Workers (UTT) as a bureaucratic apparatus more for the sake of competition within a possible framework of purely formal democracy.
If the Tunisian revolutionary process continues to progress, Tunisian workers will know the best way to organize themselves. If it retreats or comes to a halt, the various union bureaucracies will continue to play their role in order to avoid any autonomous self-organization by Tunisian workers.
Mouatamid
North Africa Working Group of the CGT International Secretariat
14 April 2011
Translation by FdCA International Relations Office
Part
Part 6
--------------------------------------------------------------------
The unemployed movement in Tunisia: an unstoppable process
In the '80s and '90s, especially in the western countries of North Africa, there was widespread access to university for young people from the working classes. The first rural women got to attend university. There were large-scale demonstrations at universities and from them emerged organizations such as the Union nationale des étudiants du Maroc (UNEM - National Union of Moroccan Students) which served as a nursery of activism and united struggle of all the tendencies struggling for social change.
But after university came unemployment. To continue studying in Europe or for a doctorate, masters', etc., one needs to have enough money. To enter the civil service, where cronyism and corruption dominate, graduates from the working classes and rural areas have little chance. Continuing the experience and contacts formed in the UNEM, the Association nationale des diplômés chômeurs au Maroc (ANDCM - National Association of Unemployed Graduates) was created in Morocco in 1992, the first organization of the unemployed to be created in the region and which, after 19 years of struggle without being legalized, blazed a trail in the fight against unemployment.
The enemployed graduates in Tunisia organize themselves
Influence from and knowledge of the experience of the ANDCM spread. Contacts were established between Morocco, Algeria and Tunisia.
In 2006, the Ligue Tunisienne des Diplômés Chômeurs (Tunisian League of Unemplyed Graduates) was founded. Tunisian representatives attended several international conferences by the ANDCM, also attended by the CGT. Post-graduation unemployment was massive and the need to organize was clear.
But in Tunisia, Ben Ali's dictatorship repressed branches of the unemployed graduates' league. There was persecution and division was fomented. The organization returned underground. But it continued to sow its seeds, there were still contacts being made and the uprising in Gafsa was like a flame that the repression put out, but it did point the way.
The revolution arrives. The Tunisian Union des Diplômés-Chômeurs (UDC) is formed
Young people have been at the forefront of the revolution. Mohamed Bouazizi, whose death sparked off the revolt, was one of those educated young people who were rotting in villages with no prospect for the future. But these young people today are organizing themselves. More than 100 local branches of the Union have been created since February, when it was legalized, and so far it has gathered 45,000 members, male and female. In Tunisia, a country with 10 million inhabitants, there are 140,000 young unemployed graduates with another 60,000 students who finish school early. This is one of the motors of change.
We spoke with Salem Ayari, president of the UDC in Tunis. In the last three months, the process has been unstoppable. Local branches are created almost daily. There is a national committee, but without any decision-making powers. They have rented premises in Tunis so that the committee can continue to organize the process. A bond system has allowed the movement to finance itself. Computers from the local premises of the RCD and from friends give the UDC a minimal infrastructure.
Following the experience of the ANDCM, they have developed a standard scale for jobs obtained by the various branches of the association. Actions at local level are essential. We have seen permanent protest camps in various places (Sidi Bouzid, Thala, Tozeur...).
Apart from the common struggle to end all structures linked to the dictatorship, in the field of unemployment the UDC focuses on three key demands:
1. In the civil service, control over and participation in jobs that are created based on real social needs.
2. A social wage for all unemployed people.
3. Support for and participation in job-creation projects. The study of projects by the association, with public support.
The whole process of local struggle will merge on 1 May in Tunis. The idea is to mobilize 50,000 unemployed graduates, showing the strength and capacity of movement in order to promote a policy of job creation which takes account of the people directly involved. They are facing the challenge of the organizational and logistical efforts required to mount such a mobilization with optimism.
But they know they have to combine the struggle and the mobilization with analysis of the current situation and find concrete alternatives for employment that are viable. To do so, they are organizing a conference debate on 9th and 10th May, with the participation of various intellectuals, on the theme of "Unemployment and models for development", as well as the issue of migration.
The ability to organize ourselves
We do not talk about the past or about dreams. Before our eyes, here and now, in less than three months tens of thousands of young Tunisians have managed to make a tool that they themselves have forged, autonomously at each location, with solidarity between all, with common objectives, with bottom-up participation, without depending on anyone. It is not perfect or without contradictions and weaknesses - it is after all a human process. But it is real, present, and something from which we should all learn.
Mouatamid
Quote: The processes of
These committees are however small and are mostly animated by the Union of Unemployed graduates themselves :
Total number of the Union of unemployed graduates:
Sunday will be a crucial test it seems for them:
What Komar quoted shows the islamic 'moderates'(?) party as the big winner:
Noa Rodman wrote: What Komar
Noa Rodman
This interview with Al-Nahda/Ennahda (aka Renaissance Party) leader Rashid Al-Ghannouchi makes him sound quite moderate (social democracy plus moral conservatism?). At least if it can be taken at face value.
Edit: see also this in-depth article on Al Nahda
The reawakening of Nahda in Tunisia
Noa Rodman wrote: These
Noa Rodman
Actually I think this may vary in different places. Part 3 (there doesn't seem to be a translation as yet) talks about meeting the committees in Sidi Bouzid and Redeyef in their respective UGTT locals, and it sounds like there is more union involvement in these towns in the interior (as opposed, maybe, to the larger and better off cities on the coast).
Redeyef in particular was at the centre of the 2008 uprising against the restructuring of the Gafsa phosphate mines (the precursor of this year's uprising) and the report talks about meeting with miners/ex-miners there, along with the unemployed graduates.
'Manifesto of Tunisian women
'Manifesto of Tunisian women for equality and citizenship'
French ----- Spanish ----- machine translation
Prison breakout in Kasserine
Prison breakout in Kasserine and Gafsa
--------------------------------------------------------------------
International Crisis Group - Tunisia report (summary)
Full report (in French, pdf)
Quote: Protests continue in
http://globalvoicesonline.org/2011/05/06/tunisia-police-brutality-is-back/
(No subject)
[youtube]Ul80dEedX58[/youtube]
Quote: Tunisians demand
- from here.
Quote: 14-year-old youth shot
http://www.monstersandcritics.com/news/africa/news/article_1651736.php/14-year-old-youth-shot-dead-in-Tunisian-riots
Edit: more on this -
http://uk.reuters.com/article/2011/07/18/uk-tunisia-riots-idUKTRE76H1X020110718?rpc=401&feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&rpc=401
Crude scary use of
Crude scary use of 'conspiracy theory' ideology here:
Rothschilds Stage Revolutions in Tunisia and Egypt To Kill Islamic Banks In Emerging North African Markets, written a few months ago, but only just seen it as it's only just been posted onto a relatively known site.
Quote: A 14-year-old boy was
- Wall Street Journal.
Insurgent Notes: On Tunisia
Insurgent Notes: On Tunisia
pdf version
Elections in Tunisia Arabist:
Elections in Tunisia
Arabist: On Nahda's victory in Tunisia
Brian Whitaker: Tunisia on the road to gridlock?
Police violently disperse
Police violently disperse anti-capitalism protesters
photos -- which suggest a lot of involvement from PCOT members
http://communismeouvrier.word
http://communismeouvrier.wordpress.com/2011/11/14/manifestation-anti-capitaliste-a-tunis/
AA: Riots break out in a
AA: Riots break out in a second Tunisian province
One year on - interview with
One year on - interview with a couple of Tunisian Trotskyists
http://www.socialistworld.net/doc/5556
It's interesting that "already Ennahda has experienced a fall in support in the opinion polls, from 41% to 28%. And a certain part of Ennahda’s electoral support is on the streets to protest against the party they voted for in October."
Quote: In the last few days,
http://www.socialistworld.net/doc/5599
Quote: Police used tear gas
http://globalvoicesonline.org/2012/02/26/tunisia-police-use-tear-gas-and-batons-to-disperse-labor-union-protest/
General strike in Sidi Bouzid
General strike in Sidi Bouzid called by trade unions and opposition parties against the Islamist government.
http://www.france24.com/en/20120814-thousands-tunisians-take-islamists-general-strike-sidi-bouzid
I noticed that the video that goes with that news article shows somebody holding a red and black flag with a black star at 1:16.
A short video from the
A short video from the general strike.
[youtube]MSLDeZhaWaI[/youtube]
More reports from Sidi
More reports from Sidi Bouzid
http://globalvoicesonline.org/2012/08/14/tunisia-sidi-bouzid-rises-again/
http://www.tunisia-live.net/tag/sidi-bouzid/
Quote: Mouvement
http://www.facebook.com/notes/هيئات-العمل-الثوريحركة-عصيان/إعلان-المبادئ-العامة-حركة-عصيان-mouvement-désobéissance-déclaration-de-principes/395259483883277
http://www.facebook.com/disobey.tn
Tunisia: A call for
Tunisia: A call for unity
Tunisia: Statement of Disobey Movement
Scenes from a revolt
Scenes from a revolt sustained: http://revoltsustained.tumblr.com/about
Some clips from the film here
[youtube]4r6pDfD8OlU[/youtube]
Interview with the
Interview with the Disobedience Movement
.
.