Review of "Design of a Worker Cooperatives Society," by Geert Reuten

Seven principles of worker cooperatives

This is a review of a book published in 2023.

Submitted by Marx-lover on November 20, 2026

Ancien régimes are always tenacious, but it is clear that society in its present form cannot last. Capitalism itself, as Marx predicted, is evidently unsustainable. The question is, what will come after it? Social thinkers have pondered this question for almost two centuries, and we seem to be no closer to an answer now than in the 1840s. It remains just as difficult now as then to imagine a radically different society than our own oligarchically structured one. Notoriously, it is easier to imagine social chaos or human extinction than an organized post-capitalist world.

Nevertheless, in the (overlapping) anarchist, socialist, and communist traditions, there has been no shortage of visions and sketches of a new society. In some cases, a continued role for government is envisioned; in others, society is to consist of a federation of communes and voluntary associations. Typically, the sketch of the future is not at all detailed, both because it is impossible to predict social evolution and because it is up to people themselves to forge new institutions in their struggles against oppression. Marx famously disdained to write “recipes for the cookshops of the future,” and most socialists and anarchists have been similarly reticent.

Not all have, however. Among the small minority of thinkers who have been bold enough to plan the new world in minute detail, Geert Reuten is probably the boldest. His new book Design of a Worker Cooperatives Society: An Alternative Beyond Capitalism and Socialism, and the Transition Towards It consists of an incredible profusion of detail—420 pages of it—about all the major institutions of a possible new society and what the transition process might look like. Whatever flaws the book has, it is an astonishing imaginative feat, a tour de force of imaginary social reconstruction. A former professor of economics who has previously written from a Marxist viewpoint, Reuten seems to have thought of everything, down to the organization of hospitals, pharmacies, museums, and concert halls. The book is hardly pleasure-reading, but it is so dense with ideas that anyone seriously interested in building a non-capitalist society might want to use it as a kind of reference book.

Before proceeding to the impossible task of summarizing the book, however, it may be worthwhile to express some reservations about Reuten’s project. Specifically, one can’t help sharing Marx’s intuition that writing such an astoundingly detailed recipe for the kitchens of the future is profoundly misguided. The book has plenty of intriguing ideas, but there is approximately zero chance that its grand Design (as Reuten calls it) will ever be enacted. This just isn’t how history works, from the ideal to the material. Rather, new institutions emerge laboriously out of popular economic and political struggles, as new challenges arise and people come up with new ways to meet them. Reuten justifies his book in the following terms (p. 3):

"General accounts or main lines of the organisation of a future society are in my view insufficiently convincing for most people to really see it as an alternative to capitalism... Hence, for the judgement on the possible functioning of a “worker cooperatives society” and the adequacy thereof, one needs a design of its full economic and state organisation that is blueprint-like in its detail. Detailed such that the feasibility and consistency of the design can be fully scrutinised."

But even if the Design is consistent and highly detailed, people can still object that it’s completely unfeasible because of the realities of social conflict and the messiness of society. The latter isn’t pliable enough to be molded into fitting an ideal blueprint. This was one problem with, say, Charles Fourier’s utopianism, and it’s a problem with all utopian blueprints. They’re all more-or-less unfeasible, precisely because they’re blueprints (and thus idealistic, conceived out of thin air far in advance of the era when supposedly they might be realized).

One might object, moreover, that in an age of ecological collapse, it is an oversight for a book outlining a future society not to acknowledge humanity’s grim prospects. Escalating global warming and the ongoing destruction of ecosystems might seem to vitiate any attempt to establish a socialist utopia. (And yes, despite the book’s subtitle, the society Reuten envisions is a type of socialism, in which workers collectively control property and all political and economic institutions.) This doesn’t mean it isn’t worth trying to achieve such a society, but it does undermine the feasibility of any blueprint that doesn’t really take environmental destruction into account.

Nevertheless, Design of a Worker Cooperatives Society shouldn’t be seen as merely an academic exercise or a monument to the utopian imagination. It deserves to be read and discussed; perhaps someday a reconstituted and more powerful left will find it full of stimulating ideas. So let’s take a look at the Design it proposes.

The new economy will consist overwhelmingly of worker cooperatives, although “single-person enterprises” are allowed too—but in that case, it isn’t allowed to hire a worker (in order to avoid exploitative capitalist relations). Members of a cooperative have no ownership stake in it; they have only usufruct rights (the right to use it and to appropriate its fruits). The cooperative, not its members, owns the means of production. Every cooperative is governed by a workers’ council, which sets rules for the individual remuneration of its members, both in “wages” and in end-of-the-year “dividends.” These enterprises are subject to a variety of rules and constraints that will tend to prevent any of them from achieving market dominance or being aggressively competitive and undermining the economy’s stability. For instance, no cooperative can be organized in more than a single location; they’re not allowed to found other cooperatives; and they can’t expand beyond a certain ceiling that would generate market power. They aren’t even allowed to advertise their products or services; instead, there are “output information services” under the responsibility of a government minister and/or a consumer association.

The state is a parliamentary democracy in which elections are on a proportional basis. The parliament elects a government that is accountable to it and can be removed by a parliamentary majority. In addition to parliament and the government, the state consists of the judiciary, ministries, eighteen state agencies (e.g., the central bank, the national health agency, the national education agency, the public transport agency, and the patents and copyrights authority), and provinces and municipalities. The workers of each state institution constitute a council, which has several functions: for instance, it elects its management and it determines the structure of its internal wage scales. The state’s budget is generally financed by two kinds of taxation: a tax on the output of cooperatives, and an individual income tax, whose rates range from 25 percent to 95 percent (for incomes above five times the minimum wage, if such exist). There are no municipal or provincial taxes.

Healthcare and education (primary, secondary, and tertiary) are free, financed out of taxation. Medical and educational institutions are legally and internally structured as “workers’ council-governed foundations,” which belong to the public sector but not, strictly, the state sector. They receive budgets from the relevant state agency, and rent their premises and fixed equipment from the state. –For the National Real Estate Agency owns most of the nation’s real estate and rents it out to people and institutions. This fact ensures that there is no (speculative) real estate market. (There is also a National Infrastructure Agency that owns intercity waterways, railways, roads, bridges, and nationwide networks for communication, information, and energy. It contracts with cooperatives to help build and maintain all these resources.)

Skipping several hundred pages of detail, the question arises as to what the transition between capitalism and the cooperative society will look like. Reuten addresses this topic in the final two chapters. He argues, rightly, that much depends on how large the worker cooperative sector has already grown on the eve of the transition, when the revolutionary party is about to achieve power (presumably through peaceful electoral means). The larger that sector is, the less disruptive will be capitalists’ hostile responses to the prospect of a government run by the far-left. Reuten doesn’t think capital flight will have a particularly damaging effect on the economy, but the reluctance of capitalist corporations to invest because of the insecure future might cause a serious recession. The more dominant the cooperative sector is, the less serious the recession will be. But it’s likely that the new left-wing government will immediately have to adopt recession-countering measures.

The chapter on how the left party, once in power, will manage the transition is long, and, as usual, full of details whose feasibility can’t possibly be judged in advance. History itself determines what is feasible and what isn’t; decades or even generations in advance, one has no idea what will be possible. But there is no reason to think the specific course of events Reuten describes will ever happen anywhere. In a best-case scenario, an approximation of some of the legislative measures he sketches might come to pass. But such proposals as that “the first broad period” of the transition will take five to six years and be organized in five legislative phases; that the capitalist sector will phase out within one generation because, in part, of an inheritance tax of 100 percent on incomes above twice the minimum wage (which itself will be 167 percent of the estimated minimum cost of living); that medium-sized and large corporations will have to split into multiple entities because of their (prohibited) large market share and the “single location” rule; and all the proposals for how the state will, within just a few years, be radically restructured—with regard to all these ideas and countless others, one has no basis on which to evaluate the feasibility decades from now.

Not everyone would find the Design morally unimpeachable. Anarchists, especially, will object to its quite statist nature. But this objection is likely misguided, for it is hard to imagine a complex modern society without a role for government. And this government, at least, is very democratic, not only in its relations with the population but even internally, its various agencies being organized according to workers’ councils. Marx himself, of course, anticipated a “withering away of the state” in the distant future—his values were ultimately those of anarchism—but he gave no indication of how this could possibly happen. There will always be social conflict, after all, which, in societies of dozens or hundreds of millions of people, seems to necessitate laws. And it seems that to enforce these laws, one needs a government, backed up by the power of physical coercion if necessary. Moreover, some of the functions of modern states are constructive: for example, aggregating resources to invest in infrastructure, science and technology, education, and medical care. The relatively centralized state, fat with revenue from the entire society, is probably more functional for these purposes than dispersed, decentralized networks of municipalities or “communes” would be. So in this respect, at least, Reuten’s Design is realistic, and surely justifiable.

We can’t know how history will proceed, so, as I said earlier, it may be that someday the Design, or at least aspects of it, will be useful in the construction of a better world. But for now, its value is probably twofold: first, it is a remarkable testament to humanity’s moral imagination, the human capacity for social engineering (if only intellectually, in this case) guided by ideal principles of justice. Second, in an age of widespread pessimism and despair, readers might find the book inspiring for its optimism that a more just world is still possible. Society is in dire need of a left that offers visionary proposals for the future, to take the wind out of the sails of the global far-right. Reuten’s blueprint may be unrealistic, but it certainly qualifies as visionary. In more accessible and less detailed forms, visions such as his might help revitalize the left.

Comments